Journalist calls for a Nicola Sturgeon comeback to the SNP (Image: Getty)
Despite leaving office in 2023 and being under police investigation, calls to reverse Nicola Sturgeon’s exit can be heard from Scottish journalists who believe “the SNP should ask her back”.
According to the Nationalist writer, Neil Mackay, both the party and the country had it the best when the Glasgow MSP was in power.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
Energetic Badenoch takes swipe at unpopular PM over petition disaster
35 Comments
Ed Balls' GMB salary exposed as viewers demand he's axed in Labour 'bias' row
33 Comments
General election petition hits one million names in humiliating new milestone for Labour
3239 Comments
Angela Merkel reveals her 'respect' for Donald Trump in bombshell memoir after fiery clash
5 Comments
Lee Anderson's defiant 5-word verdict as latest data shows Reform UK on for major success
84 Comments
John Prescott had a connection with the public that politicians today would die for
7 Comments
Who is Alex Burghart as Kemi Badenoch ally takes on Angela Rayner
24 Comments
Chaos at Alex Salmond memorial as SNP's John Swinney booed by mourners
96 Comments
SNP mocked as First Minister hints at early election months after Westminster annihilation
17 Comments
Reform UK set to 'help Labour' in Scotland - 'anything's better than the SNP'
14 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon torn apart in brutal four-word verdict from Matt Hancock
121 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon under fire as she reveals new 2026 campaign
42 Comments
Nigel Farage could hold balance of power in Scotland after shock poll for SNP and Labour
261 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
Energetic Badenoch takes swipe at unpopular PM over petition disaster
35 Comments
Ed Balls' GMB salary exposed as viewers demand he's axed in Labour 'bias' row
33 Comments
General election petition hits one million names in humiliating new milestone for Labour
3239 Comments
Angela Merkel reveals her 'respect' for Donald Trump in bombshell memoir after fiery clash
5 Comments
Lee Anderson's defiant 5-word verdict as latest data shows Reform UK on for major success
84 Comments
John Prescott had a connection with the public that politicians today would die for
7 Comments
Who is Alex Burghart as Kemi Badenoch ally takes on Angela Rayner
24 Comments
Chaos at Alex Salmond memorial as SNP's John Swinney booed by mourners
96 Comments
SNP mocked as First Minister hints at early election months after Westminster annihilation
17 Comments
Reform UK set to 'help Labour' in Scotland - 'anything's better than the SNP'
14 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon torn apart in brutal four-word verdict from Matt Hancock
121 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon under fire as she reveals new 2026 campaign
42 Comments
Nigel Farage could hold balance of power in Scotland after shock poll for SNP and Labour
261 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
Ms Sturgeon served as a member of the Scottish Parliament since its establishment in 1999, going on to become the First Minister of Scotland and Leader of the Scottish National Party from 2014 to 2023 - after Alex Salmond's failed independence referendum campaign.
Her long service came to an abrupt end in 2023 when she resigned from the post, yet Mr Mackay wrote in The Herald that "there are many SNP members still loyal to Sturgeon, who wish that like some 'queen over the water' she would return".
Despite many viewing things as having gotten worse under over a decade of SNP rule, many of her fans believe, somewhat delusionally, that she could restore Scotland to greatness, despite polls showing the Nats are headed for a similarly poor Scottish election result following their annihilation at Westminster on July 4.
READ MORE: SNP says ‘pregnant men’ should have the same maternity rights as women
John Swinney is the current Leader of the Scottish National Party and First Minister of Scotland (Image: Getty)
Get the latest politics news straight to your phone Join us on WhatsApp Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
He supports his claims with her election performances as proof she would do a better job than John Swinney who oversaw the General Election, which saw the Nats reduced to a handful of MPs in the Commons. The writer also raises the point of party membership plummeting since her resignation which is partly due to the SNP finance investigation.
He highlighted Ms Sturgeon's "almost cult-like following among a certain type of nationalist" and said he is only "half joking" when suggesting "the SNP should ask her back".
Mr Mackay adds how the SNP has become a "poor imitation of its former self" and "stumbles from stupid scandal to stupid scandal, defending the indefensible whether that’s Michael Matheson running up enormous bills on the public purse or Stephen Flynn plotting against another SNP politician".
"Now, compare that rotten state of affairs to the fortunes of the party when Nicola Sturgeon was in charge. Under Sturgeon, the nationalists never had it so good," the journalist says.
READ MORE:
Nicola Sturgeon torn apart in brutal four-word verdict from Matt Hancock
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
Nicola Sturgeon under fire as she plans new 2026 campaign
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
The SNP won 2.3 million votes under Ms Sturgeon in the 2021 Scottish election (Image: Getty)
Trending
Mr Mackay points out that the SNP won 2.3 million votes when Ms Sturgeon was in power during the 2021 Scottish election - this was the highest number of votes ever achieved, surpassing Alex Salmond.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
Energetic Badenoch takes swipe at unpopular PM over petition disaster
35 Comments
Ed Balls' GMB salary exposed as viewers demand he's axed in Labour 'bias' row
33 Comments
General election petition hits one million names in humiliating new milestone for Labour
3239 Comments
Angela Merkel reveals her 'respect' for Donald Trump in bombshell memoir after fiery clash
5 Comments
Lee Anderson's defiant 5-word verdict as latest data shows Reform UK on for major success
84 Comments
John Prescott had a connection with the public that politicians today would die for
7 Comments
Who is Alex Burghart as Kemi Badenoch ally takes on Angela Rayner
24 Comments
Chaos at Alex Salmond memorial as SNP's John Swinney booed by mourners
96 Comments
SNP mocked as First Minister hints at early election months after Westminster annihilation
17 Comments
Reform UK set to 'help Labour' in Scotland - 'anything's better than the SNP'
14 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon torn apart in brutal four-word verdict from Matt Hancock
121 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon under fire as she reveals new 2026 campaign
42 Comments
Nigel Farage could hold balance of power in Scotland after shock poll for SNP and Labour
261 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
Energetic Badenoch takes swipe at unpopular PM over petition disaster
35 Comments
Ed Balls' GMB salary exposed as viewers demand he's axed in Labour 'bias' row
33 Comments
General election petition hits one million names in humiliating new milestone for Labour
3239 Comments
Angela Merkel reveals her 'respect' for Donald Trump in bombshell memoir after fiery clash
5 Comments
Lee Anderson's defiant 5-word verdict as latest data shows Reform UK on for major success
84 Comments
John Prescott had a connection with the public that politicians today would die for
7 Comments
Who is Alex Burghart as Kemi Badenoch ally takes on Angela Rayner
24 Comments
Chaos at Alex Salmond memorial as SNP's John Swinney booed by mourners
96 Comments
SNP mocked as First Minister hints at early election months after Westminster annihilation
17 Comments
Reform UK set to 'help Labour' in Scotland - 'anything's better than the SNP'
14 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon torn apart in brutal four-word verdict from Matt Hancock
121 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon under fire as she reveals new 2026 campaign
42 Comments
Nigel Farage could hold balance of power in Scotland after shock poll for SNP and Labour
261 Comments
Nicola Sturgeon tax avoidance row heats up as 'hypocritical' SNP under fire
36 Comments
SNP says ‘pregnant men' should have the same maternity rights as women
19 Comments
The three Tory MPs who could jump ship to Reform after latest bombshell defection
146 Comments
Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition
611 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg's sister reveals what to expect in new reality TV show
3 Comments
Labour civil war as Diane Abbott slams Keir Starmer's ‘poor judgement' on winter fuel cuts
123 Comments
The one reason Keir Starmer should be absolutely petrified as 2m sign that petition
1846 Comments
In his piece for The Herald, he continues to say that she "made the careers of deadweight MPs who rode to Westminster on her coat-tails, then fell once she departed".
Ms Sturgeon was arrested and interviewed in connection with Operation Branchform, although she has never been charged. The investigation has since cast a shadow over the party, contributing to its potential wipeout.