Sir Keir Starmer’s chief legal officer has come under fire after drawing a controversial parallel be (Image: Getty)
Sir Keir Starmer’s chief legal officer has come under fire after drawing a controversial parallel between Conservative and Reform UK policies on international law and Nazi Germany, reports The Times.
Lord Hermer, Labour’s attorney-general, warned that Britain must be prepared to reform international agreements such as the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) to ensure they retain “democratic legitimacy”. However, his comparison between current political stances and the legal thinking that underpinned 1930s Germany has raised eyebrows across the political spectrum.
Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT
Fly New York to Paris in Luxury with La CompagnieFor business travel this summer, La Compagnie offers an all-business-class experience from New York to Paris. Enjoy comfort, efficiency, and top-tier service, making your journey as productive as it is luxurious.La Compagnie | Sponsored Sponsored
Book Now
Undo
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
Move over Alison Hammond - Visit West Midlands gem crowned the UK's top tourist attraction
6 Comments
Manchester: Boy 'stabbed to death in pub garden' as police issue major statement
Comments
Youngest ever Omaze winner selling ￡3million mansion for ￡500k less than its worth
5 Comments
'Resident from hell' moved into retirement community - here's how they got rid of them
13 Comments
Free tickets for West End shows on sale on Tuesday - here's how to get them
2 Comments
River Island tipped to shut stores in major blow to high street
4 Comments
Manchester murder: Stabbed boy, 13, 'ran to house for help' before five tragic final words
17 Comments
Men Are Trying This ED Trick at Night (And Urologists Say It Works)The Male Hub | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Huge boost for campaign to halt Keir Starmer's betrayal of Northern Ireland veterans
61 Comments
The tiny UK seaside town with a huge beach that's 'better and quieter' than Newquay
1 Comments
Xenomorph Bottle: A Must-Have for Sci-Fi Fans and Whisky CollectorsZekear | Sponsored Sponsored
Shop Now
Undo
"Fat Jab" Fury Erupts Over Plans to Put Brits on Weight-Loss Drugs for Life
5 Comments
'Our seaside town's been ravaged by 1 huge problem - we don't recognise it any more'
495 Comments
Why Are People Snapping up This New Flag Wreath?Sherum | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
UK-US trade threatened over plans for Chinese 'mega-embassy' in London
67 Comments
The UK's ‘best railway stations' where 81% of trains arrive on time
13 Comments
Dating for Senior Singles in NevadaMature Dating | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
How Seasoned Travelers Are Beating Cruise Price HikesOnline Shopping Tools | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
Transform Your Space with Local Home BuilderHome Builder | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
You’ll Never Guess Which Common Item Helps Eliminate Tartar From Dog's Teethnyhealthlabs.com | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
Move over Alison Hammond - Visit West Midlands gem crowned the UK's top tourist attraction
6 Comments
Nevada: Gov May Cover Your Cost To Install Solar If You Live In These Zip CodesEnergy Bill Cruncher | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Manchester: Boy 'stabbed to death in pub garden' as police issue major statement
Comments
Youngest ever Omaze winner selling ￡3million mansion for ￡500k less than its worth
5 Comments
Man Fights Nail Fungus for 15 Years - Until He Found This DeviceLunavia | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
'Resident from hell' moved into retirement community - here's how they got rid of them
13 Comments
Free tickets for West End shows on sale on Tuesday - here's how to get them
2 Comments
The Bronx estate where JFK lived as a child seeks $6.4 millionHomes.com | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
River Island tipped to shut stores in major blow to high street
4 Comments
Manchester murder: Stabbed boy, 13, 'ran to house for help' before five tragic final words
17 Comments
Huge boost for campaign to halt Keir Starmer's betrayal of Northern Ireland veterans
61 Comments
The tiny UK seaside town with a huge beach that's 'better and quieter' than Newquay
1 Comments
"Fat Jab" Fury Erupts Over Plans to Put Brits on Weight-Loss Drugs for Life
5 Comments
'Our seaside town's been ravaged by 1 huge problem - we don't recognise it any more'
495 Comments
UK-US trade threatened over plans for Chinese 'mega-embassy' in London
67 Comments
The UK's ‘best railway stations' where 81% of trains arrive on time
13 Comments
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
Referring specifically to Business Secretary Kemi Badenoch’s call to “disengage” from the ECHR and other international bodies that no longer serve British interests, Lord Hermer likened such a “pick and mix” approach to the ideas promoted by Nazi jurist Carl Schmitt. Schmitt famously argued that state power should override legal constraints—an ideology that helped justify Adolf Hitler’s authoritarian rule.
In a speech at the Royal United Services Institute, Lord Hermer said: “The claim that international law is fine as far as it goes, but can be put aside when the conditions change, is a claim that was made in the early 1930s by ‘realist’ jurists in Germany, most notably Carl Schmitt, whose central thesis was in essence the claim that state power is all that counts.”
Powered By
10 Sec
10.7K
1
22 June
Next
Stay
He added: “Our approach is a rejection of the siren song, that can sadly now be heard in the Palace of Westminster, not to mention the press, that Britain abandon the constraints of international law in favour of raw power.”
Sponsored
Health Wellness Journal | Sponsored Sponsored
Watch More
Cardiologists: How to Quickly Lose a Hanging Tummy
Undo
Don't miss...
Question Time audience member speechless as Fiona Bruce forced to step in [LATEST]
New Reform MP blasts 'rattled' Keir Starmer after Nigel Farage rant [LATEST]
Andrew Neil brutally tears apart Keir Starmer over Nigel Farage speech [LATEST]
'Nigel Farage could be PM – so obvious even Tories are admitting it' [LATEST]
Schmitt’s ideas were instrumental in allowing Hitler to bypass Germany’s constitution and assume dictatorial powers in 1933. Reform UK’s previous policy called for a full withdrawal from the ECHR and the Strasbourg-based European Court of Human Rights.
Although Lord Hermer’s comments triggered fierce backlash, sources close to him were quick to clarify he was not comparing right-wing politicians to Nazis, stressing he believed they were “acting in good faith” and were “patriots”.
“He (Hermer) is the son of a former Conservative councillor, who sees this as nothing but a good-faith argument in the British family,” said one source. “The attorney-general sees those on the other side of this debate as patriots acting in good faith — but deeply misguided because ripping up international law will only help those who want a lawless world like Vladimir Putin.”
However, critics were quick to slam Hermer’s remarks. Shadow Justice Secretary Robert Jenrick said: “It is appalling that Hermer would insinuate those who think we should leave the ECHR are like the Nazis. David Lammy tried that disgusting smear with Brexiteers and it didn’t work for him. It won’t work for Hermer either.”
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
Move over Alison Hammond - Visit West Midlands gem crowned the UK's top tourist attraction
6 Comments
Manchester: Boy 'stabbed to death in pub garden' as police issue major statement
Comments
Youngest ever Omaze winner selling ￡3million mansion for ￡500k less than its worth
5 Comments
'Resident from hell' moved into retirement community - here's how they got rid of them
13 Comments
Free tickets for West End shows on sale on Tuesday - here's how to get them
2 Comments
River Island tipped to shut stores in major blow to high street
4 Comments
Manchester murder: Stabbed boy, 13, 'ran to house for help' before five tragic final words
17 Comments
This is why people put onions in their socksLifehackSpot | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Huge boost for campaign to halt Keir Starmer's betrayal of Northern Ireland veterans
61 Comments
The tiny UK seaside town with a huge beach that's 'better and quieter' than Newquay
1 Comments
What Really Happens If You Drink Bottled Water DailyWater Health Experts | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
"Fat Jab" Fury Erupts Over Plans to Put Brits on Weight-Loss Drugs for Life
5 Comments
'Our seaside town's been ravaged by 1 huge problem - we don't recognise it any more'
495 Comments
Dating for Senior SinglesMeetheage | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
UK-US trade threatened over plans for Chinese 'mega-embassy' in London
67 Comments
The UK's ‘best railway stations' where 81% of trains arrive on time
13 Comments
Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later [video]Health Benefits | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
Eyelash Transformation For Older WomenPrime Prometics | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
Mascara Older Women Can’t Stop Talking AboutPrime Prometics | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
10 VA Benefits So Generous They Seem FakeProud Veteran Savings | Search Ads | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
Move over Alison Hammond - Visit West Midlands gem crowned the UK's top tourist attraction
6 Comments
8 Ridiculous Expenses Americans Waste The Most Money OnBetterBuck | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
Manchester: Boy 'stabbed to death in pub garden' as police issue major statement
Comments
Youngest ever Omaze winner selling ￡3million mansion for ￡500k less than its worth
5 Comments
The Secret Revealed: Why All Hummingbirds Go to My Neighbor's GardenSherem | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
'Resident from hell' moved into retirement community - here's how they got rid of them
13 Comments
Free tickets for West End shows on sale on Tuesday - here's how to get them
2 Comments
Walgreens Faces Worst Nightmare as 87￠ ED Pill Takes OverHealth Alliance by Friday Plans | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
River Island tipped to shut stores in major blow to high street
4 Comments
Manchester murder: Stabbed boy, 13, 'ran to house for help' before five tragic final words
17 Comments
Huge boost for campaign to halt Keir Starmer's betrayal of Northern Ireland veterans
61 Comments
The tiny UK seaside town with a huge beach that's 'better and quieter' than Newquay
1 Comments
"Fat Jab" Fury Erupts Over Plans to Put Brits on Weight-Loss Drugs for Life
5 Comments
'Our seaside town's been ravaged by 1 huge problem - we don't recognise it any more'
495 Comments
UK-US trade threatened over plans for Chinese 'mega-embassy' in London
67 Comments
The UK's ‘best railway stations' where 81% of trains arrive on time
13 Comments
Horror as dead baby found in UK town in 'unexplained' incident
Comments
Overtourism in stunning UK town leaves locals paying ￡600 a year to park - 'it's crazy'
17 Comments
Everyone with an induction hob in their kitchen urged to spend 25p now
4 Comments
Southport killer 'could be moved to cushy hospital' - costing taxpayers ￡325k a year
49 Comments
M65 traffic recap: Major motorway closed after crash as drivers face delays
4 Comments
Staggering cost of housing migrants laid bare as it 'equals taxes paid by 582k workers'
69 Comments
Man's one-word response as he's arrested by cops - as he's released from prison
8 Comments
$99 Hearing Aids Better Than $2500 Ones?Senior Vitality Magazine
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
The Lace Comfort Bra Is Taking Nevada By StormGraddi
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Mature Dating Starts TodayGirls with love
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Experts Tested 17 Hearing Aids. Their #1 Pick Will Shock Youhear.com
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Don't miss...
Nigel Farage loses it with Keir Starmer after huge attack – 'Project Fear 2.0' [LATEST]
I was in the room for Starmer's Farage-bashing speech – PM is taking a huge risk [LATEST]
'Keir Starmer's mask-off premiership – PM is exposed as totally out of control' [LATEST]
Nearly 140 MPs remain silent on Labour's WASPI betrayal - 'national scandal' [LATEST]
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
Jenrick also poured cold water on Hermer’s ambitions to reform the ECHR, calling the idea “fanciful” due to the need for unanimous agreement from all 46 signatory nations.
While Lord Hermer emphasised the need to respect and comply with international institutions, he insisted that the law must continue to evolve.
“International law cannot and must not replace politics. As we have shown time and again as a nation, from a position of respect and compliance . . . reform is possible and institutions can be reformed. We must be ready to reform where necessary,” he said.