Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Supported by
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Study About Purported Ancient ‘Pyramid’ in Indonesia Is Retracted
The study, based on research featured in a Netflix documentary, fueled debate over a site that is used for Islamic and Hindu rituals.
Share full article
Read in app
Students visiting Gunung Padang last year in Cianjur, Indonesia.Credit...Ulet Ifansasti for The New York Times
By Mike Ives
Reporting from Seoul
March 20, 2024Updated 5:00 a.m. ET
The American publisher of a study that challenged scientific orthodoxy by claiming that an archaeological site in Indonesia may be the world’s “oldest pyramid” says it has been retracted.
The October 2023 study in the journal Archaeological Prospection made the explosive claim that the deepest layer of the site, Gunung Padang, appears to have been “sculpted” by humans up to 27,000 years ago.
The study’s critics say that it incorrectly dated the human presence at Gunung Padang based on radiocarbon measurements of soil from drilling samples, not artifacts. The journal’s American publisher, Wiley, cited that exact reasoning in the retraction notice it issued on Monday.
Gunung Padang is widely considered a dormant volcano, and archaeologists say that ceramics recovered there so far suggest that humans have been using it for several hundred years or more — not anything close to 27,000 years. The pyramids of Giza in Egypt are only about 4,500 years old.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
The retraction, based on a monthslong investigation, said that the study was flawed because its soil samples “were not associated with any artifacts or features that could be reliably interpreted as anthropogenic or ‘man-made.’”
Uncovering the Past, One Discovery at a Time A Treasure Hunter's Find: Trevor Penny was magnet fishing in an English waterway when he pulled out a rusty sword. Experts say the weapon is probably more than 1,000 years old. A Mysterious Finding: A marble Roman head from the first or second century was found buried in England. How did it get there? The Enduring Comet Strike Theory: Mainstream science has done its best to debunk it, but a belief in a world-changing series of prehistoric impacts persists. A 3,000-Year-Old Purple Factory: Archaeologists have revealed a major production site in Israel of antiquity’s most prized pigment, the color purple, harvested from sea snails.
Some archaeologists said in interviews that they welcomed the retraction. But the study’s authors called it “unjust,” saying in a statement on Wednesday that their soil samples had been “unequivocally established as man-made constructions or archaeological features,” in part because the soil layers included artifacts.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Mike Ives is a reporter for The Times based in Seoul, covering breaking news around the world. More about Mike Ives
Share full article
Read in app
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT