Lindsay Hoyle sparks Commons uproar

       Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has been urged to reveal precisely what he said to Sir Lindsay Hoyle, Speaker of the House of Commons, prior to last night’s chaotic scenes at Westminster which saw a walkout by SNP and Tory MPs.

       Sir Vernon Bogdanor, Professor of Government at King's College, London was speaking after a tumultuous day of wrangling over Sir Lindsay’s handling of a debate on the situation in Gaza.

       The shambolic scenes stemmed from Sir Lindsay’s decision to defy parliamentary convention by selecting Labour's bid to amend an SNP motion on the Israel-Hamas war. Labour's amendment, calling for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire in Gaza, was subsequently approved unanimously.

       As a result, both Tories and the SNP accused him of helping Sir Keir Starmer avoid another damaging revolt over the Middle East issue, with Penny Mordaunt, leader of the House of Commons Leader, accusing him of "hijacking” the debate and "undermining the confidence" of the House in its long-standing rules.

       Sir Vernon told Express.co.uk: “Obviously the issue of Gaza is highly emotive and arouses strong opinions on both sides of the debate. In such situations, the best solution is to stick to precedent.

       READ MORE: UK scores major Brexit victory – and it is all thanks to France

       Stay up-to-date with the latest Politics news Join us on WhatsApp Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info

       Sir Lindsay Hoyle and Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer in the Commons (Image: PA)

       “Standing Orders provide that on an SNP day, the SNP motion should be debated together with the government amendment and then there should be a vote which presumably the government would win.

       “It is rare for there to be an opposition amendment to an opposition motion.”

       Before the vote, Sir Keir is understood to have met with Sir Lindsay, Sir Vernon pointed out.

       He continued: “Whether that was wise or not is a matter of dispute.

       Penny Mordaunt, leader of the House of Commons, last night (Image: Parliament TV)

       Become an Express Premium member Support fearless journalism Read The Daily Express online, advert free Get super-fast page loading

       Start 30-day

       FREE trial

       “But Keir Starmer is under a duty to tell us precisely what was said to the Speaker.”

       It was possible Sir Lindsay, who was himself a Labour MP before succeeding John Bercow in the important, non-party political role in 2019, may have therefore felt “under particular pressure” given a Labour government before the end of the year was “a distinct possibility”, Sir Vernon suggested.

       He added: “Such an attempt to bend the procedural rules does not reflect well on Starmer, who as a public lawyer, should know better.

       “The Speaker gave an advantage to Labour, damaged the SNP and as it turned out the Conservatives as well.”

       Insiders have suggested Sir Keir told Sir Lindsay he was concerned his MPs were at risk of abuse from the public should they find themselves unable to vote on a Labour amendment.

       Stephen Flynn, the SNP's Westminster leader, was visibly angry (Image: PA)

       Sir Vernon said: “That is a matter for the police, not the Speaker.

       “In parting from precedent, the outcome has been that there was no vote on the SNP motion nor on the government amendment. This means that electors do not know how their MPs voted.

       “It may be that the procedural rules take insufficient account of the fact of a multi-party parliament implying three votes one on the motion and two on amendments, rather than a two-party one.

       “In that case, the rules should be changed.”

       Nevertheless, for as long as they were in place, they should be observed, insisted Sir Vernon, who is also author of The New British Constitution.

       Don't miss...

       Boris Johnson and Liz Truss savaged by farmers’ union boss [INSIGHT]

       Vladimir Putin 'testing limits', warns exiled Belarus leader [VIDEO]

       Vladimir Putin may test NATO by invading Baltic state, warns ex-Russian PM [ANALYSIS]

       Sir Lindsay is facing calls to resign (Image: PA)

       He explained: “They are there for a reason.

       “The Speaker, it is generally agreed, has two duties - to be fair to all parties and to take particular care that small parties are given due consideration.”

       It had been anticipated that Sir Lindsay would pick just the Government's amendment seeking an "immediate humanitarian pause" to the Israel-Hamas conflict, potentially paving the way for a more permanent stop in fighting.

       However, he decided that the Commons would first vote on Labour's calls for an "immediate humanitarian ceasefire" before moving on to further votes on the SNP's original motion, and then the Government's proposals if either of the first two were to fail to garner enough support.

       Last night’s extraordinary scenes saw SNP MPs and some Conservatives walk out of the debate in protest.

       Trending

       After calls for him to return to the chamber to explain his move, Sir Lindsay apologised to MPs and promised to hold talks with senior party figures.

       Amid shouts of "resign", he said: "I thought I was doing the right thing and the best thing, and I regret it, and I apologise for how it's ended up."

       He stressed that he took the decision to allow all sides to "express their views" and that he was "very, very concerned about the security" of MPs who have received personal threats over their stance on the Gaza conflict.

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today

       268 Comments

       Should Speaker Lindsay Hoyle resign after Commons chaos over Gaza? Vote here

       660 Comments

       Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle

       883 Comments

       Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate

       1123 Comments

       Sadiq Khan fact-checked on X after hitting out at Rishi Sunak over Gaza

       175 Comments

       Rishi Sunak hits out at 'very concerning' rule-bending by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle

       73 Comments

       Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant

       17 Comments

       Full list of MPs voting no confidence in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle after Commons uproar

       137 Comments

       ‘I absolutely didn't threaten him': Keir Starmer dodges crucial question after Commons row

       438 Comments

       The Gaza debate became a clown show - but here's why we shouldn't be laughing

       100 Comments

       Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle fights for political survival as 67 MPs call for him to go

       602 Comments

       Our latest poll suggests Tory plots against Rishi Sunak are doomed

       12 Comments

       Keir Starmer faces prospect of new Labour rebellion as SNP pushes for fresh Gaza vote

       112 Comments

       MPs' righteous fury will change nothing in Gaza and Israel

       195 Comments

       Who should be the next speaker of the House of Commons?

       17 Comments

       Speaker sparks furious Commons chaos after tearing up rule book over SNP Gaza debate

       859 Comments

       Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker after chaos

       262 Comments

       Palestine protest: Jaw-dropping moment 'from the river to the sea' projected onto Big Ben

       2497 Comments

       Furious MPs plot to oust Lindsay Hoyle over Labour 'stitch-up' of crunch Gaza vote

       1577 Comments

       Nigel Farage issues stark warning after chaos erupts in Commons over Gaza

       687 Comments

       Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today

       268 Comments

       Should Speaker Lindsay Hoyle resign after Commons chaos over Gaza? Vote here

       660 Comments

       Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle

       883 Comments

       Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate

       1123 Comments

       Sadiq Khan fact-checked on X after hitting out at Rishi Sunak over Gaza

       175 Comments

       Rishi Sunak hits out at 'very concerning' rule-bending by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle

       73 Comments

       Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant

       17 Comments

       Full list of MPs voting no confidence in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle after Commons uproar

       137 Comments

       ‘I absolutely didn't threaten him': Keir Starmer dodges crucial question after Commons row

       438 Comments

       The Gaza debate became a clown show - but here's why we shouldn't be laughing

       100 Comments

       Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle fights for political survival as 67 MPs call for him to go

       602 Comments

       Our latest poll suggests Tory plots against Rishi Sunak are doomed

       12 Comments

       Keir Starmer faces prospect of new Labour rebellion as SNP pushes for fresh Gaza vote

       112 Comments

       MPs' righteous fury will change nothing in Gaza and Israel

       195 Comments

       Who should be the next speaker of the House of Commons?

       17 Comments

       Speaker sparks furious Commons chaos after tearing up rule book over SNP Gaza debate

       859 Comments

       Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker after chaos

       262 Comments

       Palestine protest: Jaw-dropping moment 'from the river to the sea' projected onto Big Ben

       2497 Comments

       Furious MPs plot to oust Lindsay Hoyle over Labour 'stitch-up' of crunch Gaza vote

       1577 Comments

       Nigel Farage issues stark warning after chaos erupts in Commons over Gaza

       687 Comments

       Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today

       268 Comments

       Should Speaker Lindsay Hoyle resign after Commons chaos over Gaza? Vote here

       660 Comments

       Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle

       883 Comments

       Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate

       1123 Comments

       Sadiq Khan fact-checked on X after hitting out at Rishi Sunak over Gaza

       175 Comments

       Rishi Sunak hits out at 'very concerning' rule-bending by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle

       73 Comments

       Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant

       17 Comments

       SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn responded by saying his party had been treated with "complete and utter contempt".

       So far, 33 MPs have already signed a parliamentary motion tabled by Tory MP William Wragg declaring no confidence in the Speaker.

       Express.co.uk has contacted Sir Keir via the Labour Party for further comment on Sir Vernon's remarks.

       Related articles Penny Mordaunt takes aim at Speaker over Gaza vote as chaos erupts in Commons Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle Furious MPs plot to oust Lindsay Hoyle over Labour 'stitch-up' of Gaza vote Sir Lindsay Hoyle issues grovelling apology amid MP shouts to 'resign' Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker