Sir Anthony Seldon, right, has criticised Sir Keir Starmer's start as Prime Minister (Image: PA)
Sir Keir Starmer has been ripped apart by one of the country’s foremost political historians, who told Newsnight: “No Labour prime minister, certainly not since 1945, has begun so badly.” Sir Anthony Seldon has written biographies of every PM’s time in No 10 since Sir John Major and has written several books about the office of prime minister.
But he told the late-night BBC current affairs show that Sir Keir’s first year in office ranked worse than the starts made by Clement Attlee, Harold Wilson, James Callaghan, Sir Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. Callaghan’s first year was marked by Labour going cap in hand to the International Monetary Fund for a large loan to keep Britain afloat during financial turmoil. Mr Brown was widely ridiculed for “bottling it” months after he arrived at No 10 in 2007 by failing to call a general election.
Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
POLL: Should Keir Starmer resign if he makes another u-turn?
137 Comments
Labour minister torn apart on GB News with brutal nine-word poll question
5 Comments
Personal tax allowance raise from ￡12,570 to ￡20,000 update as backing soars
Comments
Huge Starmer blow as ex-Cabinet Minister says he's 'lurching from crisis to crisis'
65 Comments
Keir Starmer blind panic as 123 Labour MP welfare rebels tell PM: ‘F*** you!'
125 Comments
Labour defector blasts Starmer's leadership in shock resignation: ‘No moral compass!'
252 Comments
Keir Starmer torn apart over 'humiliating U-turn' on welfare cuts
177 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Keir Starmer rinsed again by historian Anthony Seldon who warns ‘skates are under' PM
52 Comments
Keir Starmer breaks his silence over benefit cuts U-turn after massive Labour rebellion
48 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Weakened Keir Starmer now facing big Labour MP rebellion over family farm tax
459 Comments
Nigel Farage faces dramatic landslide election win in huge bombshell poll
121 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
GB News' Camilla Tominey questions if Keir Starmer should resign in tense exchange
13 Comments
Reform triumphs to win three by-elections as Labour slumps to humiliating quadruple defeat
Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
Forgetfulness Over 50? Do This 7-Secon d Elephant Trick To Sharp Recall!Memory Health Today | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
POLL: Should Keir Starmer resign if he makes another u-turn?
137 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Labour minister torn apart on GB News with brutal nine-word poll question
5 Comments
Personal tax allowance raise from ￡12,570 to ￡20,000 update as backing soars
Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Huge Starmer blow as ex-Cabinet Minister says he's 'lurching from crisis to crisis'
65 Comments
Keir Starmer blind panic as 123 Labour MP welfare rebels tell PM: ‘F*** you!'
125 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Labour defector blasts Starmer's leadership in shock resignation: ‘No moral compass!'
252 Comments
Keir Starmer torn apart over 'humiliating U-turn' on welfare cuts
177 Comments
Keir Starmer rinsed again by historian Anthony Seldon who warns ‘skates are under' PM
52 Comments
Keir Starmer breaks his silence over benefit cuts U-turn after massive Labour rebellion
48 Comments
Weakened Keir Starmer now facing big Labour MP rebellion over family farm tax
459 Comments
Nigel Farage faces dramatic landslide election win in huge bombshell poll
121 Comments
GB News' Camilla Tominey questions if Keir Starmer should resign in tense exchange
13 Comments
Reform triumphs to win three by-elections as Labour slumps to humiliating quadruple defeat
Comments
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
“It tells a story of a fundamentally incompetent prime minister.”
Political biographer Sir Anthony Seldon believes that Keir Starmer has made the worst start of any Labour prime minister since 1945.
#Newsnight pic.twitter.com/pVmOut3izP
— BBC Newsnight (@BBCNewsnight) June 27, 2025
Don't miss... Keir Starmer's latest U-turn shows he's in office – but not in power [LATEST]
Sir Anthony’s comments on Friday suggested that Sir Keir’s start in Downing Street has been worse than both of those.
The historian said the PM, who was forced into U-turns on winter fuel payment cuts and a national grooming gangs inquiry, had “begun with such ignorance of history and how you conduct yourself as prime minister”.
Powered By
10 Sec
1.2M
101
UK weather maps shows possible high temperatures
Next
Stay
Sir Anthony pinpointed two main faults with the current occupant of Downing Street – firstly, that he is “incapable of telling a story”, and secondly that “he doesn’t understand that the prime minister is only there if you keep and carry your MPs with you”.
Sponsored
Any Home Value Lookup | Sponsored Sponsored
Las Vegas: Lookup Anyone's Home Value Instantly By Addr ess
Undo
Referring to this week’s U-turn on benefits cuts after a massive rebellion of Labour MPs, he said: “If there was a clear vision that he’d laid out, a story about where he is taking the Labour Government and the country, people perhaps might understand why this cut was necessary. But there have been so many flip-flops, they don’t get it.
“It tells a story of a fundamentally incompetent prime minister. He’s repeating the same mistakes.”
Don't miss... Keir Starmer confesses he 'deeply regrets' using 'island of strangers' phrase [LATEST]
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
In a particularly wounding jibe for the PM, given his support for Arsenal, Sir Anthony said it would be like manager Mikel Arteta worrying about the seating in the stands rather than his team’s performance on the pitch.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
POLL: Should Keir Starmer resign if he makes another u-turn?
137 Comments
Labour minister torn apart on GB News with brutal nine-word poll question
5 Comments
Personal tax allowance raise from ￡12,570 to ￡20,000 update as backing soars
Comments
Huge Starmer blow as ex-Cabinet Minister says he's 'lurching from crisis to crisis'
65 Comments
Keir Starmer blind panic as 123 Labour MP welfare rebels tell PM: ‘F*** you!'
125 Comments
Labour defector blasts Starmer's leadership in shock resignation: ‘No moral compass!'
252 Comments
Keir Starmer torn apart over 'humiliating U-turn' on welfare cuts
177 Comments
This Quick, 1-Step Ear Cleaner Can Save Your Dog From a Life of Ear ItchingPupLabs | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Keir Starmer rinsed again by historian Anthony Seldon who warns ‘skates are under' PM
52 Comments
Keir Starmer breaks his silence over benefit cuts U-turn after massive Labour rebellion
48 Comments
Award Winning ERP Research PLM Arena Netsuite Development TrialERP Research | Search Ads | Sponsored Sponsored
Click Here
Undo
Weakened Keir Starmer now facing big Labour MP rebellion over family farm tax
459 Comments
Nigel Farage faces dramatic landslide election win in huge bombshell poll
121 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
GB News' Camilla Tominey questions if Keir Starmer should resign in tense exchange
13 Comments
Reform triumphs to win three by-elections as Labour slumps to humiliating quadruple defeat
Comments
Memory Slipping? Do This One “Elephan t Trick” Every Morning To Sharpen...Health and Memory Today | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
The Greatest Enemy of Memory Loss? Try this tonightMemory Health Today | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
High Speed Internet for Seniors at low rates worth switchingHigh-Speed Wi-Fi Internet Deals | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Find Out Why These Shoes Are Ridiculo usly ComfortableWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Order Now
Undo
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
POLL: Should Keir Starmer resign if he makes another u-turn?
137 Comments
Dementia Has Been Linked To a Common Habit. Do You Do It?Memory Health | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Labour minister torn apart on GB News with brutal nine-word poll question
5 Comments
Personal tax allowance raise from ￡12,570 to ￡20,000 update as backing soars
Comments
High Speed Internet for Seniors at low rates worth switchingHigh-Speed Wi-Fi Internet Deals | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Huge Starmer blow as ex-Cabinet Minister says he's 'lurching from crisis to crisis'
65 Comments
Keir Starmer blind panic as 123 Labour MP welfare rebels tell PM: ‘F*** you!'
125 Comments
Memory Slipping? Do This One “Elephan t Trick” Every Morning To Sharpen...Health and Memory Today | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Labour defector blasts Starmer's leadership in shock resignation: ‘No moral compass!'
252 Comments
Keir Starmer torn apart over 'humiliating U-turn' on welfare cuts
177 Comments
Keir Starmer rinsed again by historian Anthony Seldon who warns ‘skates are under' PM
52 Comments
Keir Starmer breaks his silence over benefit cuts U-turn after massive Labour rebellion
48 Comments
Weakened Keir Starmer now facing big Labour MP rebellion over family farm tax
459 Comments
Nigel Farage faces dramatic landslide election win in huge bombshell poll
121 Comments
GB News' Camilla Tominey questions if Keir Starmer should resign in tense exchange
13 Comments
Reform triumphs to win three by-elections as Labour slumps to humiliating quadruple defeat
Comments
Keir Starmer out! PM on edge as rebel Labour MPs demand 'regime change'
439 Comments
Humiliation for 'wounded' Keir Starmer as Angela Rayner allies say he'll be gone in a year
175 Comments
Nigel Farage nails it as he sums up perfectly why UK voters are eyeing Reform
565 Comments
‘Justifying the unjustifiable!' Labour torn to shreds by audience in brutal Question Time
168 Comments
‘Keir Starmer will be gone in a year' - and guess who's lining up to replace him
588 Comments
Labour minister shuts down GMB's Kate Garraway in furious clash 'Let me finish!'
8 Comments
Crisis for Keir Starmer as even his friends say it's 'start of the end'
437 Comments
The Greatest Enemy of Memory Loss? Try this...Memory Health Today
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Memory Slipping? Do This One “Elephant Trick”...Memory Wellness Blog
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
The Business Sneaker Loved by CEOs and NFL...Wolf & Shepherd
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
This Quick, 1-Step Ear Cleaner Can Save Your D...PupLabs
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Sir Keir’s personal popularity has plummeted since he took office after last year’s thumping General Election victory.
In May, his net approval rating plunged to -46%, although it has since improved to -36%. Labour has also been overtaken in the polls by Nigel Farage’s insurgent Reform UK.
A damning YouGov poll this week showed that if a general election were held now, Labour’s majority would be wiped out with a loss of 233 seats. Reform UK would emerge as the largest party in a hung parliament.