Sir Keir Starmer was compared to Chinese leader Xi Jinping (Image: PA)
Sir Keir Starmer has been compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping over a power grab in the House of Lords.
Tory critics have branded the move to oust hereditary peers "partisan" and "political gerrymandering" aimed at reducing scrutiny of the Government.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Gary Lineker has cost taxpayers at least ￡30m during his BBC career
18 Comments
Vandalising or defacing war memorials is an insult to British history, says Mark Francois
33 Comments
Andrew Neil sends brutal 4-word response to Keir Starmer in furious outburst
95 Comments
Why Kemi Badenoch offers a hope with which Keir Starmer can never compete
72 Comments
Starmer forced to slap down Blair advisor over 'irresponsible' attack on UK farmers
57 Comments
Panic outside parliament as man armed with several knives is arrested by armed police
155 Comments
Labour could ditch plans to punish thugs who climb on war memorials
32 Comments
'I'm an American - here's everything you need to know about the 2024 Election'
14 Comments
What is the US Senate? From its design to the power it holds
8 Comments
Labour panic that party faces disaster like Democrats if they make this one big mistake
797 Comments
Starmer warned Trump charm offensive at risk after Lammy and Streeting's 'childish slurs'
921 Comments
Tory leadership LIVE: Badenoch or Jenrick lie in wait as Starmer suffers devastating blow
451 Comments
Keir Starmer accused of 'disrespecting' pensioners with winter fuel petition snub
597 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Gary Lineker has cost taxpayers at least ￡30m during his BBC career
18 Comments
Vandalising or defacing war memorials is an insult to British history, says Mark Francois
33 Comments
Andrew Neil sends brutal 4-word response to Keir Starmer in furious outburst
95 Comments
Why Kemi Badenoch offers a hope with which Keir Starmer can never compete
72 Comments
Starmer forced to slap down Blair advisor over 'irresponsible' attack on UK farmers
57 Comments
Panic outside parliament as man armed with several knives is arrested by armed police
155 Comments
Labour could ditch plans to punish thugs who climb on war memorials
32 Comments
'I'm an American - here's everything you need to know about the 2024 Election'
14 Comments
What is the US Senate? From its design to the power it holds
8 Comments
Labour panic that party faces disaster like Democrats if they make this one big mistake
797 Comments
Starmer warned Trump charm offensive at risk after Lammy and Streeting's 'childish slurs'
921 Comments
Tory leadership LIVE: Badenoch or Jenrick lie in wait as Starmer suffers devastating blow
451 Comments
Keir Starmer accused of 'disrespecting' pensioners with winter fuel petition snub
597 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Conservative Lord Mancroft claimed the UK Parliament will become “like the toothless farce that is the Chinese People’s Congress”.
He said: "Anyone with even the most basic knowledge cannot compare a chamber set up 42 years ago in a communist dictatorship with one political party and a population of 1.4billion to an 800-year-old second chamber of a highly developed legislature in a multi-party democracy of 68million - or can they?
Chinese President Xi Jinping with Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto (Image: Getty Images)
Hereditary peers will be removed from the House of Lords under Labour's plan (Image: AP)
"Because while there are now many countries around the world with bicameral legislatures, many of which are based on the Westminster model, there is only one where the head of the executive has complete control.
"Not even the most powerful executive in Europe, the President of France, or President-elect Trump with his party's control of the Senate, will have the power that Sir Keir Starmer is giving himself under this Bill.
"Because what the Government is proposing is to give the Prime Minister the same powers of appointment that President Xi has.
"The silly joke is about to become reality. With the Bill the Government is now proposing, this House and this Parliament will be on the way to becoming like the toothless farce that is the Chinese People's Congress."
The criticism was levelled during an impassioned debate in the unelected chamber as legislation continued its passage through the Commons, which will abolish the 92 seats reserved for peers who are there by right of birth.
The House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill, which delivers on a promise in Labour's election manifesto, has been promoted as the first step in a process of reform.
However, another commitment - a mandatory retirement age of 80 in the Lords - was not included in the Government's legislative plans.
There have been ongoing concerns about the size of the House and calls to reduce its membership - which stands at around 800, compared with the number of MPs being capped at 650.
Referring to the current legislation, Conservative shadow leader of the upper chamber Lord True said: "The aim of the Bill is partisan.
"It is to remove 88 peers who do not align themselves with Labour and four who do. We should at least be honest about that.
"Aside from the partisan, there is another aspect that is notable.
"It will be unpleasant. Some may not like to hear it, but there is no evading it.
"The execution will have to be done at close quarters, brushing shoulders in the lobbies as we go to vote for the removal of much-respected colleagues."
He conjured the image of peers seeking to "avoid sitting next to a colleague we have just voted to expel".
Lord True added: "There can be no doubt that the Bill being discussed in another place will cause some great hurt. And it will almost inevitably issue in conflict. Conflict which may well spill out in quite unpredictable directions.
"All that is avoidable. There must be a better way."
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
He was backed by Tory former cabinet minister Lord Forsyth of Drumlean, who warned: "If the party opposite continues with this act of constitutional vandalism they ain't seen nothing yet."
In a scathing broadside, he said: "A disgraceful piece of political gerrymandering aimed at weakening scrutiny of his Government by the House of Lords."
House Of Cards author and Conservative peer Lord Dobbs argued for wider reform, rather than a "rushed standalone Bill".
He said: "At the very least, we should allow hereditary peers to continue sitting and contributing to this House until the end of this Parliament, rather than the end of a session.
"That would make little practical difficulty to the work of the Government but it would be a mark of respect.
"Our hereditary colleagues should be allowed to leave with their heads held high, not stuck on the end of a pike.
"When Brutus discussed doing away with Julius Caesar he knew it had to be done with a sense of justice: 'Let's carve him as a dish fit for the gods, not hew him as a carcass fit for hounds.'
"Our hereditary colleagues have done nothing but their duty, and the rest of us have a duty, may I suggest, to remember that."
Labour peer Lord Grocott, a former MP who had long campaigned to scrap hereditary peer by-elections, argued the way to reform was not "one grandiose scheme".
He said: "The overwhelming evidence of the last 100 years is that attempt at wholesale reform all in one go will slowly and inexorably grind into the sand.
"The reforms which will succeed are those which are short, simple and focused."
Noting more than 70 peers were due to speak during the debate, Lord Grocott added: "We are entertained and fascinated by these issues and happy to spend hours discussing them ... It's an enthusiasm which is not shared by the British public.
"Whilst reform is important, and I don't doubt that, other issues to most people are far more important and far more deserving of debate and parliamentary time."
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Gary Lineker has cost taxpayers at least ￡30m during his BBC career
18 Comments
Vandalising or defacing war memorials is an insult to British history, says Mark Francois
33 Comments
Andrew Neil sends brutal 4-word response to Keir Starmer in furious outburst
95 Comments
Why Kemi Badenoch offers a hope with which Keir Starmer can never compete
72 Comments
Starmer forced to slap down Blair advisor over 'irresponsible' attack on UK farmers
57 Comments
Panic outside parliament as man armed with several knives is arrested by armed police
155 Comments
Labour could ditch plans to punish thugs who climb on war memorials
32 Comments
'I'm an American - here's everything you need to know about the 2024 Election'
14 Comments
What is the US Senate? From its design to the power it holds
8 Comments
Labour panic that party faces disaster like Democrats if they make this one big mistake
797 Comments
Starmer warned Trump charm offensive at risk after Lammy and Streeting's 'childish slurs'
921 Comments
Tory leadership LIVE: Badenoch or Jenrick lie in wait as Starmer suffers devastating blow
451 Comments
Keir Starmer accused of 'disrespecting' pensioners with winter fuel petition snub
597 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Gary Lineker has cost taxpayers at least ￡30m during his BBC career
18 Comments
Vandalising or defacing war memorials is an insult to British history, says Mark Francois
33 Comments
Andrew Neil sends brutal 4-word response to Keir Starmer in furious outburst
95 Comments
Why Kemi Badenoch offers a hope with which Keir Starmer can never compete
72 Comments
Starmer forced to slap down Blair advisor over 'irresponsible' attack on UK farmers
57 Comments
Panic outside parliament as man armed with several knives is arrested by armed police
155 Comments
Labour could ditch plans to punish thugs who climb on war memorials
32 Comments
'I'm an American - here's everything you need to know about the 2024 Election'
14 Comments
What is the US Senate? From its design to the power it holds
8 Comments
Labour panic that party faces disaster like Democrats if they make this one big mistake
797 Comments
Starmer warned Trump charm offensive at risk after Lammy and Streeting's 'childish slurs'
921 Comments
Tory leadership LIVE: Badenoch or Jenrick lie in wait as Starmer suffers devastating blow
451 Comments
Keir Starmer accused of 'disrespecting' pensioners with winter fuel petition snub
597 Comments
Jacob Rees-Mogg warns of Labour's dark plot to return UK to EU 'via the back door'
184 Comments
DWP issues urgent state pension warning to all women born in the 1950s
17 Comments
Labour facing humiliating legal challenge over 'cruel' winter fuel payments cut
194 Comments
Kemi Badenoch announces Conservative shadow cabinet - new roles in full
360 Comments
Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces fury with pensioners ditching food after winter fuel axe
120 Comments
Sir Keir Starmer compared to Chinese dictator Xi Jinping in huge Lords row
27 Comments
Was Gary Lineker worth all the licence fee payers' money BBC gave him?
15 Comments
Opening the debate earlier, leader of the Lords Baroness Smith of Basildon said: "We are more than aware that when it comes to meaningful reform of this place there is a track record of stagnation and stalled attempts.
"There are those who argue we shouldn't do anything until we do everything, but with no consensus or agreement on what everything means we have ended up doing nothing.
"That's why a more incremental approach is an appropriate way forward."