Rishi Sunak gives press conference after Rwanda Bill win
Rishi Sunak’s flagship Bill is on course for an explosive legal showdown in Strasbourg, after the European Court of Human Rights said that despite the PM’s new legislation deportations will still breach international law.
Mr Sunak has already pledged to ignore so-called Rule 39 orders from the ECHR, setting the UK up for potential legal action by the Human Rights body.
Speaking at a press conference this morning, ECHR president Síofra O’Leary said the UK would breach its legal obligations if it refused to comply with a Strasbourg judge demanding an injunction on any deportations.
She warned: “There is a clear legal obligation under the European Convention on Human Rights for states to comply with Rule 39 measures. The legal basis for this is principally Article 34 of the convention”.
“In the past, where states have in the past failed to comply with Rule 39 indications, judges have found that the states have violated their obligations under Article 34 of the convention.”
Stay up-to-date with the latest Politics news Join us on WhatsApp Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
READ MORE: Anti-Rwanda Peer says it's Lords' job to 'protect democracy from itself'
ECHR President Síofra O’Leary appeared to make a shocking comparison between Sunak and Putin (Image: ECHR)
She also appeared to compare Mr Sunak with Russian despot Vladamir Putin, when arguing the UK has previously declared the need for other states to comply with Rule 39 indications.
In 2021 the UK urged President Putin to abide by an ECHR measure regarding the release of political prisoner Alexei Navalny.
Responding to the legal chief’s incendiary remarks this morning, Tory Brexiteers are already holding the Prime Minister’s feet to the fire, calling on him to stand by his promise to ignore any legal interference.
Red Wall MP Jonathan Gullis said the ECHR is already “shamelessly trying to meddle with our nation’s sovereign right to control our borders”.
In a call to arms, he demanded: “We must ignore it!”
Don't miss...
Reform UK now just seven points behind Tories as they hit highest support yet [EXCLUSIVE]
Farage says Tories are ‘utterly terrified’ of him after PM's ex-aide's warning [LATEST]
Tory rebels pinpoint exact moment Simon Clarke's anti-Sunak revolt will explode [EXCLUSIVE]
Become an Express Premium member Support fearless journalism Read The Daily Express online, advert free Get super-fast page loading
Start 30-day
FREE trial
Tory MPs are already demanding the PM slaps the ECHR down, and ignores any Rule 39 orders (Image: Getty)
Senior Brexiteer and member of the ERG’s Star Chamber Court David Jones told the Express the Prime Minister was “entirely right” to promise he would ignore such meddlesome human rights rulings.
The legal brain pointed out: “Rule 39 indications are not binding on the UK.
"They are pronouncements frequently made in the dead of night by Strasbourg judges on the basis of minimal evidence and without hearing argument.
“They are alien to our legal system. Under the Rwanda Bill, ministers can ignore rule 39 indications.
“Furthermore, the Prime Minister has said that he won’t allow a foreign court to stop the flights taking off. He was entirely right to do so.”
Trending
The comments from Ms O’Leary were swiftly slapped down by Downing Street, as Mr Sunak’s official spokesman said he is “confident” the Government’s new flagship Rwanda Bill is “compliant” with international law.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
How Rishi Sunak beat Tory right with Priti Patel deal, Keir Starmer's PMQs and 'wimp' MPs
Comments
Robert Jenrick says UK can't stay in ECHR as he refuses to rule out Tory leadership bid
Comments
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg warns against voting down Rwanda deportation plans
Comments
Shapps urges action on Channel crisis, Jenrick questions Rwanda bill and ECHR
Comments
Kremlin 'spewing racism' as Vladimir Putin bids to silence all Ukraine war criticism
Comments
Europhile Donald Tusk accused of 'putting democracy and freedom in danger' in Poland
Comments
Rishi Sunak accidentally sparks EU chaos after refusing to set date for UK election
Comments
Iran killing spree as 'brutal' regime executes two men - with 11 more on death row
Comments
Rishi Sunak tears Keir Starmer apart for defending terror group in European court
Comments
Brexit was only a start but we need leaders to continue the revolution - John Longworth
Comments
'Brexit betrayal' warning with Rishi Sunak's new deal threatening to tie UK to EU forever
Comments
All the runners and riders to replace Rishi Sunak as Tory chief - with one clear favourite
Comments
Disaster for Ursula von der Leyen as she can't even get her own party to back major EU law
Comments
Rishi Sunak vows to 'ignore European judges' and put illegal migrants on Rwanda flights
Comments
Anti-Rwanda Peer says it's job of unelected Lords to 'protect democracy from itself'
Comments
Army conscription: Can you leave UK armed forces - the tough rules on when you can quit
Comments
What happens next for the Safety of Rwanda Bill?
Comments
Rishi Sunak wins a majority of 44 in the Safety of Rwanda Bill vote at 320-276
Comments
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg threatens to vote against Rwanda policy if it's not 'effective' enough
Comments
EU chaos as Viktor Orban lashes out at bloc's ‘blackmail' with MEPs 'under pressure'
Comments
How Rishi Sunak beat Tory right with Priti Patel deal, Keir Starmer's PMQs and 'wimp' MPs
Comments
Robert Jenrick says UK can't stay in ECHR as he refuses to rule out Tory leadership bid
Comments
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg warns against voting down Rwanda deportation plans
Comments
Shapps urges action on Channel crisis, Jenrick questions Rwanda bill and ECHR
Comments
Kremlin 'spewing racism' as Vladimir Putin bids to silence all Ukraine war criticism
Comments
Europhile Donald Tusk accused of 'putting democracy and freedom in danger' in Poland
Comments
Rishi Sunak accidentally sparks EU chaos after refusing to set date for UK election
Comments
Iran killing spree as 'brutal' regime executes two men - with 11 more on death row
Comments
Rishi Sunak tears Keir Starmer apart for defending terror group in European court
Comments
Brexit was only a start but we need leaders to continue the revolution - John Longworth
Comments
'Brexit betrayal' warning with Rishi Sunak's new deal threatening to tie UK to EU forever
Comments
All the runners and riders to replace Rishi Sunak as Tory chief - with one clear favourite
Comments
Disaster for Ursula von der Leyen as she can't even get her own party to back major EU law
Comments
Rishi Sunak vows to 'ignore European judges' and put illegal migrants on Rwanda flights
Comments
Anti-Rwanda Peer says it's job of unelected Lords to 'protect democracy from itself'
Comments
Army conscription: Can you leave UK armed forces - the tough rules on when you can quit
Comments
What happens next for the Safety of Rwanda Bill?
Comments
Rishi Sunak wins a majority of 44 in the Safety of Rwanda Bill vote at 320-276
Comments
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg threatens to vote against Rwanda policy if it's not 'effective' enough
Comments
EU chaos as Viktor Orban lashes out at bloc's ‘blackmail' with MEPs 'under pressure'
Comments
How Rishi Sunak beat Tory right with Priti Patel deal, Keir Starmer's PMQs and 'wimp' MPs
Comments
Robert Jenrick says UK can't stay in ECHR as he refuses to rule out Tory leadership bid
Comments
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg warns against voting down Rwanda deportation plans
Comments
Shapps urges action on Channel crisis, Jenrick questions Rwanda bill and ECHR
Comments
Kremlin 'spewing racism' as Vladimir Putin bids to silence all Ukraine war criticism
Comments
Europhile Donald Tusk accused of 'putting democracy and freedom in danger' in Poland
Comments
Rishi Sunak accidentally sparks EU chaos after refusing to set date for UK election
Comments
He said: “We’re clear the Bill and the treaty address the Supreme Court’s concerns. There should be no need for Strasbourg to intervene to block flights in the way they did in 2022.
“We’ve also drafted the Bill to give ministers the power not to comply with those rulings if necessary. And obviously every case is assessed on its individual facts, but the Prime Minister has been clear repeatedly that we will not let a foreign court block flights from taking off.”
He added it would be “bizarre” to compare Russia’s “cruel treatment of Alexei Navalny, who was a victim of an attempted assassination attempt, and our plan to protect and deter vulnerable migrants from making perilous crossings across the Channel”.
Related articles Book on 'sex for secrets' claims about former UK ambassador set to be sold in US Tory MPs know Simon Clarke is right but are afraid to act – analysis All the runners and riders to replace Rishi Sunak as Tory Party leader Fresh plot to derail Mark Drakeford's 20mph speed limit 'madness' 'Brexit betrayal' warning with Sunak's new deal threatening to tie UK to EU