Keir Starmer is forging closer ties with Beijing (Image: Getty)
Chinese plans for a 'spy base' in the heart of London is becoming a 'walk of shame' for Labour, Sir Keir Starmer has been warned. Former Tory leader Sir Iain Duncan Smith accused the Government of "denial" and "betrayal" as fears mount in the US that Beijing could target critical communication cables. The White House and Dutch Government have both issued warnings over the proposals because it is so close to London's financial hub. Sir Iain branded Labour's position "Project Kowtow" and condemned ministers for ignoring security concerns.
The Sunday Times said the US was "deeply concerned" about the plans, quoting a senior US official.
Article continues belowADVERTISEMENT
Undo
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Disaster for Keir Starmer as tens of thousands demand general election now in new petition
Rachel Reeves tax bombshell as 3.35m people's savings to be hit
Labour is conducting an assault on rural Britain with cruel family farm tax
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Disaster for Keir Starmer as tens of thousands demand general election now in new petition
Rachel Reeves tax bombshell as 3.35m people's savings to be hit
Labour is conducting an assault on rural Britain with cruel family farm tax
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Disaster for Keir Starmer as tens of thousands demand general election now in new petition
Rachel Reeves tax bombshell as 3.35m people's savings to be hit
Labour is conducting an assault on rural Britain with cruel family farm tax
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Fury has mounted over China's proposals (Image: Getty)
Sir Iain Duncan Smith has condemned Labour's position on the proposed Chinese embassy (Image: Getty)
In response, planning minister Matthew Pennycook said he could not give a full response as the matter was still to come before the department for a decision, and any verdict could be challenged by the courts.
Sir Iain said: "Beijing has a recent history of cutting cables and confirmed infrastructure hacks, including embedding malware capable of disabling all that infrastructure.
"Minister Peter Kyle yesterday on television said surprisingly that this was in the planning process and could be managed. Will the minister correct this record? The planning inquiry has concluded, no changes can be made to the Chinese planning application at all.
Sponsored
Read More
AI Bot Flips Wall Street on Its Head: Turns $1K into $50K in Record 30 Days
Undo
"I'll remind him the application contains nothing about cabling. Indeed to the inquiry, the Chinese have rejected only two requests, which he referred to actually, made by the Government in the letter from the foreign and home secretaries, despite ministers regularly saying that this letter, and I quote, should give those concerned, 'comfort'."
The Conservative MP said rerouting the cables would cost millions of pounds, and asked Mr Pennycook why the Government had denied the existence of cables until the White House confirmed it.
He asked Mr Pennycook to deny reports by Chinese state media, saying the UK had given the Chinese assurances that it would allow a development "no matter what".
He added: "I see this as Project Kowtow, one denial after another, one betrayal after another. No wonder our allies believe that this Chinese mega embassy is now becoming a walk of shame for the Government."
Mr Pennycook replied because of the "quasi-judicial nature" of his role, he could not comment on details of the application. He also said it would not be "appropriate" for him to comment on the cabling or national security issues.
He said he did not "recognise the characterisation" by the Sunday Times of the embassy being raised in talks between the UK and China on trade.
"It is important to also emphasise that only material planning considerations can be taken into account in determining this case," he said. "But, as I say, I cannot comment in any detail on a case and it is not yet before the department."
Tory shadow communities secretary Kevin Hollinrake said Parliament had been treated with disdain by the Government.
Trending
Mr Hollinrake said: "Question after question, letter after letter, the Government has consistently treated Parliament with complete disregard on this matter. Stonewalling legitimate inquiries about national security, about ministerial discussions, and warnings about security bodies."
He added: "Why won't the Government follow the examples of the US, Australian, and Irish governments which veto similar embassies that threaten their national security?
"The Government is on the verge of making a decision that will lead to huge risk, that will persist for decades. Will they change course before it is too late?"
Mr Pennycook replied: "No decision has been made on this case. No application is yet before the department."
Marie Rimmer, Labour MP for St Helens South and Whiston, said: "China has a track record of aggressive state-backed espionage, and surely this country cannot afford to make a massive underestimation of what risk if this would go ahead?"
She added: "We cannot not say anything in this House. We must comment on what we see, and please understand that we must do so."
Meanwhile, former security minister, Conservative MP Tom Tugendhat, asked whether the Government believed the Chinese would treat a similar application in the same way.
He said: "Do you honestly believe that thr minister thinks that the Chinese would look at this proposal in the same way?
"Do we actually in this House believe that our economic security being threatened, as highlighted by the Americans and the Dutch, would go through a bureaucratic planning process with no ability to vary it because, frankly, them's the orders?
"I don't think that's the way China would do it, and it's certainly not the way we should."
Mr Pennycook replied: "I'm very glad that we have a different and more robust planning system than the People's Republic ofChina."
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Put a Bread Clip in Your Wallet When Traveling. Here's WhyTrendGuruTips |
Undo
Disaster for Keir Starmer as tens of thousands demand general election now in new petition
Rachel Reeves tax bombshell as 3.35m people's savings to be hit
Invest in a biotech disruptorCytonics | StartEngine |
Learn More
Undo
Labour is conducting an assault on rural Britain with cruel family farm tax
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
This 60-Second Quiz Is Helping Virginia Drivers Save on InsuranceAutoSaveMax |
Learn More
Undo
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Live Updates: Insurance Coverage GIP & GLP-1 AgonistsGoodRx |
Learn More
Undo
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
This Simple Home Trick Is the Greatest Enemy Tinnitus HasHearWellCenter |
Undo
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
Keep Your Mind Sharp With SudokuClassic Sudoku |
Download
Undo
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Former Kansas missile silo seeks $1.3 million, could be a blast as a homeHomes.com |
Undo
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Put Salt on Your Face and Just WatchLifeHacksBay |
Read More
Undo
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Electrician Reveals: 1 Simple Tip To Reduce Your Electricity BillPowerNews |
Learn More
Undo
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
How to Find Out if GLP-1s Are Covered by Your InsuranceGoodRx |
Learn More
Undo
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Disaster for Keir Starmer as tens of thousands demand general election now in new petition
Rachel Reeves tax bombshell as 3.35m people's savings to be hit
Labour is conducting an assault on rural Britain with cruel family farm tax
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Put Baking Soda in the Toilet, Here's WhyLifeHacksBay
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
New AI Trading Bot for Beginners Delivers Impressive Gains in Just a WeekFX Market Insights
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
The 1 Household Item That Visibly Tightens Saggy SkinGlamourSkin
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Later in the session, Conservative MP Lincoln Jopp asked if the officer considering the case is "cleared to receive top secret information".
Mr Pennycook replied: "A planning inspector is assessing the case as part of a public inquiry.
"And I'm afraid, while I recognise why (Mr Jopp) has asked the question, it would not be appropriate for me to comment on national security matters."
SUBSCRIBEInvalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy