Wes Streeting (Image: Getty)
Labour has a deep-rooted belief that it is the only party that can be truly trusted with the National Health Service.
This is partly because it founded the NHS in 1945. A historic achievement, no doubt.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
People with these 56 health conditions can get ￡5,740 from DWP from April
20 Comments
Tories tipped for bombshell election victory as new poll hands boost to Kemi Badenoch
24 Comments
Elon Musk slams Keir Starmer saying UK has gone 'full Stalin' over farmer tax
21 Comments
Blow for Keir Starmer's EU negotiation plans as public say US is a more important ally
111 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
25 Comments
Labour 'wasting' ￡170m in taxpayer cash reopening old asylum centres
43 Comments
No. 10 claims Rachel Reeves is being 'straight' with public after CV 'lying' exposed
187 Comments
NHS bosses at failing UK hospitals told ‘no more pay rises, sort it or you will be sacked'
63 Comments
Wes Streeting faces backlash over ruthless NHS reform plan to root out 'rotten apples'
68 Comments
Wes Streeting vows to sack poor NHS managers in ruthless crackdown on bad performance
112 Comments
Labour's waiting list target 'unlikely to be met', NHS leaders say
26 Comments
Understaffed NHS must 'reform or die' after spending ￡3bn on agency workers last year
24 Comments
Labour to finally tell NHS bosses they can't just keep asking for more and more money
147 Comments
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
People with these 56 health conditions can get ￡5,740 from DWP from April
20 Comments
Tories tipped for bombshell election victory as new poll hands boost to Kemi Badenoch
24 Comments
Elon Musk slams Keir Starmer saying UK has gone 'full Stalin' over farmer tax
21 Comments
Blow for Keir Starmer's EU negotiation plans as public say US is a more important ally
111 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
25 Comments
Labour 'wasting' ￡170m in taxpayer cash reopening old asylum centres
43 Comments
No. 10 claims Rachel Reeves is being 'straight' with public after CV 'lying' exposed
187 Comments
NHS bosses at failing UK hospitals told ‘no more pay rises, sort it or you will be sacked'
63 Comments
Wes Streeting faces backlash over ruthless NHS reform plan to root out 'rotten apples'
68 Comments
Wes Streeting vows to sack poor NHS managers in ruthless crackdown on bad performance
112 Comments
Labour's waiting list target 'unlikely to be met', NHS leaders say
26 Comments
Understaffed NHS must 'reform or die' after spending ￡3bn on agency workers last year
24 Comments
Labour to finally tell NHS bosses they can't just keep asking for more and more money
147 Comments
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
But can Labour, now headed by Sir Keir Starmer, really claim to be the party of the NHS?
Not at all, judging by its latest wheeze to improve performance.
New Health Secretary Wes Streeting wants to publicly name and shame failing hospitals in league tables.
And he wants to sack NHS managers if they cannot improve patient care and take control of finances.
This, he claims, will drive up standards, reduce chronic backlogs and free up beds.
Unsurprisingly, his masterplan has been met with widespread condemnation and fury.
Simply put, it won’t work.
Don't miss... Rachel Reeves warned her Budget will wreck small shops and change high street [LATEST]
Those are the words of doctors, nurses and hospital trusts who say it will be divisive and lower staff morale.
The Royal College of Nursing’s executive director for England, Patricia Marquis, said we should not be tolerating poor management but that “scapegoating” trust leaders for underinvestment and systemic failures is not the solution.
“NHS staff must not be pitted against one another,” she said.
Thea Stien, chief executive for think tank the Nuffield Trust, warned that “naming and shaming” NHS trusts can make it harder to recruit staff.
Frontline medics said the plan would backfire without reform elsewhere.
Dr Nick Murch, president of the Society for Acute Medicine, said failing hospitals could become “stuck in a vicious cycle” unless social care was significantly improved, with some hospitals and vulnerable elderly patients impacted by issues such as delayed discharges.
Although some medics believed league tables could encourage a sense of competition among trusts and a determination to outdo rivals, more doctors appeared to oppose the plans.
The move comes after former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn was appointed as a non-executive director for the Department of Health and Social Care.
During Mr Milburn’s time as health secretary, league tables were also brought into the NHS.
It wasn’t a new idea then either. Tony Blair’s Labour government nicked the blueprint from the Tories, who had tried it in 1990.
On both occasions, it failed to work.
Former Conservative health secretary Stephen Dorrell was unequivocal in his belief that the plan is doomed to failure.
“What we were promised was new ideas, not reheated 35-year-old ideas,” he told Times Radio earlier this week.
Now a Lib Dem, Mr Dorrell said his successor’s plan is "borderline insulting”.
To resolve the problems, he said, you need to resolve the problems of social care and primary care in the wider healthcare system.
“The idea that the health service needs another round of league tables and it’ll all be okay I think is borderline insulting,” he said.
Don't miss...
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of doctors as NHS winter crisis looms [LATEST]
Norovirus warning as new strain of horror superbug spreading through the UK [LATEST]
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs [LATEST]
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
Dr Steve Taylor, from the frontline lobbying group Doctors’ Association UK, said: “We’ve been here before, haven’t we? And there’s no evidence that having league tables improved patient care.”
NHS England will carry out a “no holds barred” review of NHS performance across England with the results made public in league tables which are regularly updated.
Under government plans, the best NHS performers will be given greater spending control to help modernise their buildings, equipment and technology.
The DHSC said there is currently little incentive for trusts to run budget surpluses as NHS trusts are unable to benefit from them, but that will now change, with top-performing trusts given more cash.
Mr Streeting has already announced that failing NHS managers will be denied pay rises if they do not improve patient care or get their finances in order.
A new pay framework for very senior managers will be published before April next year, with those who do well given financial rewards.
And then we come to the question of money, billions of pounds of it to be more precise.
What will happen to the additional ￡22billion allotted to the NHS in Labour’s first Budget? Will it transform the service – and reduce the NHS England waiting list – or disappear into the abyss”
More than half the tax rises announced went to topping up day-to-day spending in the NHS. Yet despite Labour repeatedly prompting that there would be no cash without reform, there were no new requirements or productivity improvements attached to the additional funds.
But will these changes really ensure every penny of extra investment into the NHS is well spent?
The latest findings from the Institute for Fiscal Studies show that the NHS is still doing less than it did pre-pandemic, despite a huge boost in resources.
So simply pouring money in isn’t the answer. Cracking down on failing hospitals isn’t the answer.
Reform and investing in the whole package is the answer.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
People with these 56 health conditions can get ￡5,740 from DWP from April
20 Comments
Tories tipped for bombshell election victory as new poll hands boost to Kemi Badenoch
24 Comments
Elon Musk slams Keir Starmer saying UK has gone 'full Stalin' over farmer tax
21 Comments
Blow for Keir Starmer's EU negotiation plans as public say US is a more important ally
111 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
25 Comments
Labour 'wasting' ￡170m in taxpayer cash reopening old asylum centres
43 Comments
No. 10 claims Rachel Reeves is being 'straight' with public after CV 'lying' exposed
187 Comments
NHS bosses at failing UK hospitals told ‘no more pay rises, sort it or you will be sacked'
63 Comments
Wes Streeting faces backlash over ruthless NHS reform plan to root out 'rotten apples'
68 Comments
Wes Streeting vows to sack poor NHS managers in ruthless crackdown on bad performance
112 Comments
Labour's waiting list target 'unlikely to be met', NHS leaders say
26 Comments
Understaffed NHS must 'reform or die' after spending ￡3bn on agency workers last year
24 Comments
Labour to finally tell NHS bosses they can't just keep asking for more and more money
147 Comments
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
People with these 56 health conditions can get ￡5,740 from DWP from April
20 Comments
Tories tipped for bombshell election victory as new poll hands boost to Kemi Badenoch
24 Comments
Elon Musk slams Keir Starmer saying UK has gone 'full Stalin' over farmer tax
21 Comments
Blow for Keir Starmer's EU negotiation plans as public say US is a more important ally
111 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
25 Comments
Labour 'wasting' ￡170m in taxpayer cash reopening old asylum centres
43 Comments
No. 10 claims Rachel Reeves is being 'straight' with public after CV 'lying' exposed
187 Comments
NHS bosses at failing UK hospitals told ‘no more pay rises, sort it or you will be sacked'
63 Comments
Wes Streeting faces backlash over ruthless NHS reform plan to root out 'rotten apples'
68 Comments
Wes Streeting vows to sack poor NHS managers in ruthless crackdown on bad performance
112 Comments
Labour's waiting list target 'unlikely to be met', NHS leaders say
26 Comments
Understaffed NHS must 'reform or die' after spending ￡3bn on agency workers last year
24 Comments
Labour to finally tell NHS bosses they can't just keep asking for more and more money
147 Comments
Businesses buy up private healthcare to get sick employees back to work
Comments
GMB tension as Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley grill Wes Streeting in TV interview
Comments
Labour warned of 'dread in hearts' of emergency doctors as NHS winter crisis looms
53 Comments
Labour's national insurance raid could cost two million GP appointments - new analysis
9 Comments
Ministers urged to abandon gimmicks in tackling NHS obesity costs as shock report released
7 Comments
Sickness-hit firms set to offer private health perks to get employees back to work faster
2 Comments
POLL: Are doctors being greedy earning ￡200k to clear NHS backlog?
26 Comments
Tackling the UK's primary healthcare problem - GPs, community pharmacies, dental services and eye health services - not to mention the social care crisis must be done too.
Gimmicks like league tables will do nothing to take the NHS off life-support.