People on certain benefits need to be wary of having to pay back their winter fuel payment (Image: aquaArts studio via Getty Images)

       Personal finance guru Martin Lewis has shed light on which benefits are taxable, potentially affecting eligibility for the winter fuel payment. Chancellor Rachel Reeves recently expanded the ￡2-300 winter fuel payment to an additional 9 million pensioners in 2024, following its previous cancellation.

       The Department for Work and Pensions has stated that individuals earning over ￡35,000 within a tax year will be required to repay it, sparking worries among those close to the threshold who fear savings interest could tip them over.

       Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       Millions of households to get ￡450 cost of living payment-check your eligibility

       6 Comments

       DWP minister statement as he is pushed to make 'additional' Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       The surprising 'loophole' that allows pensioners to claim Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       Pensioners urged to check their savings as many face missing out on ￡300

       1 Comments

       The 4 'loopholes' pensioners can use to avoid Winter Fuel Payment 'tax cliff edge'

       4 Comments

       How to unlock thousands in tax savings with ‘incredibly effective' pension hack

       Comments

       Full list of DWP benefits and pension payment dates in July 2025

       Comments

       All the state pensioners who'll get Winter Fuel Payment taken back by HMRC

       1 Comments

       Tweak your income to keep the winter fuel payment, pensioners told

       1 Comments

       DWP alert as Brits going on holiday could have payments paused

       18 Comments

       Winter fuel payment ‘issue' could see millionaires eligible for up to ￡300

       13 Comments

       Single households over age of 25 to get ￡459 monthly cash boost from DWP

       1 Comments

       State pensioners living together can get weekly ￡346 payment from DWP

       1 Comments

       DWP set to pay nine million pensioners up to ￡300 this winter - check if you're eligible

       Comments

       Martin Lewis says one winter fuel payments group 'best to opt out' of cash

       4 Comments

       Martin Lewis winter fuel payment warning to state pensioners earning ￡500 in savings

       1 Comments

       New state pensioners earning ￡23,027 and 1p set to lose winter fuel payment

       Comments

       Rachel Reeves's winter fuel U-turn descends into madness - can you work out what you get?

       300 Comments

       HMRC says 'we will change tax codes' over Winter Fuel Payment

       25 Comments

       State pensioners warned over ￡10,000 savings limit

       21 Comments

       Millions of households to get ￡450 cost of living payment-check your eligibility

       6 Comments

       DWP minister statement as he is pushed to make 'additional' Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       The surprising 'loophole' that allows pensioners to claim Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       Pensioners urged to check their savings as many face missing out on ￡300

       1 Comments

       The 4 'loopholes' pensioners can use to avoid Winter Fuel Payment 'tax cliff edge'

       4 Comments

       How to unlock thousands in tax savings with ‘incredibly effective' pension hack

       Comments

       Full list of DWP benefits and pension payment dates in July 2025

       Comments

       All the state pensioners who'll get Winter Fuel Payment taken back by HMRC

       1 Comments

       Tweak your income to keep the winter fuel payment, pensioners told

       1 Comments

       DWP alert as Brits going on holiday could have payments paused

       18 Comments

       Winter fuel payment ‘issue' could see millionaires eligible for up to ￡300

       13 Comments

       Single households over age of 25 to get ￡459 monthly cash boost from DWP

       1 Comments

       State pensioners living together can get weekly ￡346 payment from DWP

       1 Comments

       DWP set to pay nine million pensioners up to ￡300 this winter - check if you're eligible

       Comments

       Martin Lewis says one winter fuel payments group 'best to opt out' of cash

       4 Comments

       Martin Lewis winter fuel payment warning to state pensioners earning ￡500 in savings

       1 Comments

       New state pensioners earning ￡23,027 and 1p set to lose winter fuel payment

       Comments

       Rachel Reeves's winter fuel U-turn descends into madness - can you work out what you get?

       300 Comments

       HMRC says 'we will change tax codes' over Winter Fuel Payment

       25 Comments

       State pensioners warned over ￡10,000 savings limit

       21 Comments

       Millions of households to get ￡450 cost of living payment-check your eligibility

       6 Comments

       DWP minister statement as he is pushed to make 'additional' Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       The surprising 'loophole' that allows pensioners to claim Winter Fuel Payments

       1 Comments

       Pensioners urged to check their savings as many face missing out on ￡300

       1 Comments

       The 4 'loopholes' pensioners can use to avoid Winter Fuel Payment 'tax cliff edge'

       4 Comments

       How to unlock thousands in tax savings with ‘incredibly effective' pension hack

       Comments

       Full list of DWP benefits and pension payment dates in July 2025

       Comments

       Lewis has now clarified that even those receiving benefits might not be safe from the cap, as certain benefits are indeed taxable. This means their total income, including employment, savings, and other sources, combined with these benefits, could inadvertently exceed the limit, obligating them to return the ￡200 or ￡300 payments.

       On his BBC Podcast, Lewis detailed the benefits at risk under the regulations. He explained: "Let's say you earn ￡40,000 of taxable income. If you earn ￡35,000 and a penny, you lose the entire ￡200. It is not a graduated scheme, it is a cliff edge scheme."

       He also noted that investment dividends outside an ISA, carer's allowance, incapacity benefit, and other taxable state benefits are included in the calculation.

       READ MORE State pensioners in one UK area getting more than ￡300 winter fuel payment

       Regarding what doesn't contribute to the ￡35,000 earnings amount, Mr Lewis clarified that it excludes the winter fuel payment itself, investment income or savings income within ISAs, the tax-free lump sum from a pension, capital gains, and non-taxable benefits like Attendance Allowance, Disability Living Allowance Pension Credit and PIPS. He added: "If it's generally taxable, it counts, if it's generally not taxable, it doesn't count."

       State benefits that are taxable

       The most common benefits that you pay Income Tax on are:

       Bereavement Allowance (previously Widow’s pension) Carer’s Allowance or (in Scotland only) Carer Support Payment contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) Incapacity Benefit (from the 29th week you get it) Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA) pensions paid by the Industrial Death Benefit scheme the State Pension Widowed Parent’s Allowance

       On his BBC podcast, Mr Lewis suggested that in some instances, it might be simpler to opt out of the payment rather than receive it only to have to repay it later. He stressed that the DWP has yet to explain the 'opt out' procedure, but he believes it will be more straightforward for those earning over ￡35,000.

       During the podcast, caller Denise queried: "My question relates to a single person household of state pension age but under 80 years old. If your total income is over the ￡35,000 threshold and therefore your winter fuel payment is to be clawed back through PAYE or self assessment will the whole sum of ￡200 be clawed back or only a percentage according to your personal tax liability.

       READ MORE State pensioner couples under 80 to get ￡100 payment from DWP

       SUBSCRIBE Invalid email

       We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

       "If 100 per cent is to be clawed back then would it be simpler to opt out and are there any pros and cons in doing so?".

       Martin responded: "Let's say you earn ￡40,000 of taxable income. You're due to get the ￡200 payment will you, because you're a basic rate taxpayer lose 20 per cent of that income? No. This is a cliff edge. If you earn ￡35,000 exactly or less you will get the ￡200 in your payslip because you're under 80.

       "If you earn ￡35,000 and a penny, you lose the entire ￡200. It is not a graduated scheme, it is a cliff edge scheme so in your case I'm presuming you will get nothing. Would it be simpler to opt out? Possibly yes although the opt out mechanism is the one thing that we don't have much detail on yet. But in your particular case as you're a single pensioner if you're almost certain to have over ￡35,000 income in this current tax year, opting out is the simplest thing to do once you are able to do so. I can't think of any reason why you wouldn't want to opt out.

       "I give myself the slight caveat in that the opt out details aren't published yet and when they publish it there might be a reason but at the moment I can't see any reason."