SPRINGFIELD — The final day of the Illinois General Assembly’s fall session dragged late into the evening Thursday with unresolved issues that included a measure to prevent people from using a decades-old state law to skirt coronavirus vaccination mandates by citing moral or religious objections.
The Illinois State Capitol on Jan. 13, 2021. (Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune)
The change to the state’s Health Care Right of Conscience Act was passed by the House Wednesday on a 64-52 vote but still awaited a Senate vote in the final hours of the scheduled fall session before potentially heading to Gov. J.B. Pritzker’s desk.
The proposal comes as numerous lawsuits across Illinois challenge government and employer vaccination and testing requirements by citing a law originally intended to shield doctors and other health care workers from having to provide abortions or other reproductive services that conflict with their beliefs.
The issue has become a lightning rod amid battles over the government’s role in combating the COVID-19 pandemic, though it hasn’t broken cleanly along partisan lines. Seven of the 73 Democrats in the House joined the Republican minority in opposing the measure, and two other members of the majority party voted “present.”
Aside from the right-of-conscience proposal pending in the Senate, by late Thursday neither chamber had voted on a new map of the state’s 17 congressional districts.
[Most read] Kyle Beach, a former Chicago Blackhawks prospect, reveals he is the ‘John Doe’ suing the team over a 2010 sexual assault allegation: ‘I felt alone and dark’ ？
Late Thursday, the Senate voted 55-0 to approve a Pritzker-backed package of incentives for electric vehicle companies, sending the measure to the House. The proposal would create the Reimagining Electric Vehicles in Illinois, or REV, tax credit program.
The Senate also voted 44-12 Thursday night to send the House gambling legislation that, among other changes, would allow limited in-person betting on Illinois college sports teams and create a sportsbook license for Wintrust Arena, the home court of the WNBA champion Chicago Sky.
The proposed change to the Health Care Right of Conscience Act passed through the Senate Executive Committee on Thursday afternoon with a 9-6 vote, with the six Republicans on the panel all voting against the measure.
Senate Republicans had previously expressed their opposition to the bill, a sentiment repeated during Thursday’s committee hearing in a debate between three Republicans and Senate President Don Harmon.
“The premise behind this act is the broad premise of freedom to invoke your conscience or your religious belief from being subjected to something you don’t want,” said Sen. Jil Tracy, a Republican from Quincy.
[Most read] Ask Amy: Guilt about distance leads to more distance ？
Harmon, an Oak Park Democrat, said he believes the law was “poorly drafted” but said he doesn’t believe the original intent of the law was to excuse someone from doing anything they don’t want to do if they cite moral or religious objections.
“Let’s imagine that your constituent is pulled over under suspicion of drunken driving. Could that constituent tell the officer they would refuse a Breathalyzer test on the Health Care Right of Conscience Act? Could they refuse a field sobriety test because their medical condition is being tested?” Harmon said. “That’s the absurd conclusion we reach if you read it as expansively as you are suggesting. This was designed to provide protections to health care providers.”
Republican Sen. Jason Barickman of Bloomington raised a familiar talking point among the Republicans, criticizing Pritzker for sidestepping the legislature by issuing executive orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
“For how long do you think the governor should be allowed to continually issue these executive orders that seem to circumvent the legislative process that allows us as a coequal branch of government an opportunity to have some input and dialogue in that? How long does that continue?” Barickman asked Harmon.
Harmon argued that Pritzker has the authority to issue executive orders in the time of emergencies, a law that was adopted by a previous General Assembly.
[Most read] Timeline: The Chicago Blackhawks video coach scandal ？
“Similarly, a prior General Assembly adopted this law on the Health Care Right of Conscience, and people are using it in a new circumstance that was not foreseen when it was passed,” Harmon said. “I am here with an amendment to this law because I think it is being misapplied.
“Should someone bring forward a bill suggesting that the governor’s use of executive orders are misapplied? We can consider that if that was the majority consensus,” he continued.
Sen. Sue Rezin, a Republican from Morris, asked Harmon if the revised law would include a threshold for doing away with state mandated COVID-19 protocols — such as if Illinois gets to the point where 70% of its population is vaccinated against the virus.
Sen. Sue Rezin, R-Morris, on the Illinois House floor at the State Capitol in Springfield on Jan. 29, 2020. (E. Jason Wambsgans/Chicago Tribune)
“I don’t know when COVID-19 will no longer be a public health threat. I don’t know what those thresholds are. I don’t know that you know. And I’m fairly certain you’re going to vote ‘no’ on this,” Harmon told Rezin. “So, if you’d like to work with us to fashion an alternative, I’m happy to listen and see if you want to influence the legislative process. But if you’re just opposed to it, then you can be opposed to it.”
As Pritzker prepares for a trip to Britain next week to promote the state’s efforts to combat climate change and its business climate, his top priority for the fall session was winning approval of a package of incentives to attract electric vehicle manufacturers and suppliers to the state.
[Most read] ‘This made my life complete.’ Hundreds greet Orthodox Christian patriarch at South Bend church, part of the spiritual leader’s historic visit to the US ？
Pritzker has aimed to position Illinois a leader in the growing industry, building off the success of the Rivian electric vehicle factory that opened in a former Mitsubishi plant in Normal with state assistance approved under his predecessor, Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner. Earlier this year, Pritzker announced a $7.9 million tax credit deal that is bringing Montreal-based Lion Electric Co. to the state to build electric buses and trucks in Joliet.
Supporters of the program — which, among other among things would create income and property tax incentives for electric vehicle manufacturers and suppliers — say it’s necessary to give Illinois a competitive edge in attracting companies.
Democratic Sen. Steve Stadelman of Caledonia, the measure’s sponsor, acknowledged that he has a “parochial interest” in trying to sway automaker Stellantis to transform its Jeep plant in nearby Belvidere into an electric vehicle plant.
But the proposal ultimately could create “thousands of jobs, potentially throughout the state,” Stadelman said.
Testifying on behalf of the Pritzker administration at a hearing earlier Thursday, Deputy Gov. Andy Manar called the plan “a major piece of Gov. Pritzker’s vision of economic growth as we come out of the COVID pandemic as a stronger state.”
[Most read] Vaccine mandate refusal sidelines 2 dozen Chicago Fire Department personnel; judge hears police union bid to pause shot reporting rule ？
“We are not going to heap a mountain of cash on a company to be here,” Manar said. “We’re just not going to do that. That’s not good public policy. But we will have targeted incentives.”
Business interests are divided over the plan, with the Illinois Manufacturers’ Association offering its support but the Illinois Chamber of Commerce expressing concerns that so-called labor peace agreements required under the proposal would cause some major companies to look elsewhere.
“If we want to be in the game, we have to pass the incentive package, and we have to pass it today because these companies have been making decisions and they’re making these decisions between now and the end of the year,” said Mark Denzler, president and CEO of the manufacturers group.
The Senate on Thursday also voted 40-17 to approve an amendment to a criminal justice overhaul Pritzker signed into law earlier this year.
It clarified several measures from the reform package, including language about phone access to anyone in police custody and the process for decertifying police officers.
jgorner@chicagotribune.com
dpetrella@chicagotribune.com
Issues including measure to eliminate potential loophole on COVID-19 vaccination mandates remain as Illinois legislature’s fall session draws to close
1h
Vaccine mandate refusal sidelines 2 dozen Chicago Fire Department personnel; judge hears police union bid to pause shot reporting rule
4h
Chicago Blackhawks Kyle Beach, a former Chicago Blackhawks prospect, reveals he is the ‘John Doe’ suing the team over a 2010 sexual assault allegation: ‘I felt alone and dark’
Oct 27, 2021
Ask Amy Ask Amy: Guilt about distance leads to more distance
Oct 24, 2021
Breaking News ‘This made my life complete.’ Hundreds greet Orthodox Christian patriarch at South Bend church, part of the spiritual leader’s historic visit to the US
4h