OPINION
Cabinet Meeting in Downing Street in London (Image: Getty)
Though welcome, there are fundamental concerns about the new defence commitment of 2.6% of GDP by 2027 just announced by the Chancellor. It was triggered by John Healey’s Strategic Defence Review. However, as the Chancellor revealed, the debate has already shifted to when 3% will be attained. Some NATO members and the United States are pushing for a further rise to 5%. More money doesn’t mean more things; it opens the door to new programmes and capabilities.
The UK has always been geared to maximising defence and lethality from platforms rather than concentrating on mere numbers. Traditionally, well-resourced defenders should be able to inflict a loss rate of 3:1 on their attackers. As Russia’s human casualties have, according to Kyiv, just passed the million mark, Ukraine has demonstrated that it’s possible to up that ratio with a wise use of doctrine and technology to 10:1.
Article continues belowADVERTISEMENT
Undo
The real problem arises in that rigidly hugging a defence spending figure of 2.6%, like a climber clinging to a rocky cliff face, fast-becomes irrelevant in today’s era of international crises. It removes the inclination for blue-sky thinking using limited resources which is the hallmark of successful military activity, and demonstrated daily by Ukraine.
Don't miss: Donald Trump's 'Golden Dome' missile defence plan could spark WW3
The trouble with fixed figures such as 2.6% is they take no account of the fluidity of international security or advances in defence technologies, which are subject to their own dramatic rises in costs above inflation. Britain was caught in the inter-war period by a similar, rigid restriction, the Ten Year Rule. First adopted in August 1919, it directed spending plans based on the assumption that “the British Empire would not be engaged in any great war during the next 10 years”.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Jeremy Corbyn has ensured that the pints are on Nigel Farage if they ever go to the pub
I went to a migrant hotel protest - one thing left me feeling completely hopeless
Home Office staff enjoy massages in secret in-house beauty parlour during migrant crisis
Vacant Houses For 10K CashVacant Houses Selling For 10k Cash | Search Ads |
Undo
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Smooth Wrinkles Fast! [Trial Offer]Plexaderm |
Shop Now
Undo
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Clinical trials are underway. Invest in OA research.Cytonics | StartEngine |
Learn More
Undo
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Caught on Camera: Puppy Slips Into Tiger Enclosure!Lootcoffer |
Undo
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
Doctors Shocked: This Common Spice Burns Fat While You SleepHealth Now |
Undo
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
This Mouth Wrinkle Cream Keep Selling Out At Drugstores (And It's No Secret Why)Lift & Firm |
Undo
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
The Wrinkle Cream Amazon Keeps Sold Out (Finally Available In Virginia)Lift & Firm |
Undo
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
Labour MP under investigation over Israel-Palestine trip
Seniors Can Now Fly Business Class For the Price Of EconomyAirlines | Insider Deals |
Undo
Rachel Reeves issued major warning by business bosses over jobs
Where will it end? Now Angela Rayner threatens allotments with war
Sleep Apnea Pillow Goes Viral! Thousands Say They Finally Sleep DeeplyDerila Sleep Apnea Pillow |
Learn More
Undo
Britain's seaside towns can be saved with one simple move by Labour
Jeremy Corbyn has ensured that the pints are on Nigel Farage if they ever go to the pub
The Oldest Stars Still Alive In 2025Share&Seed |
Undo
I went to a migrant hotel protest - one thing left me feeling completely hopeless
Home Office staff enjoy massages in secret in-house beauty parlour during migrant crisis
Rachel Reeves has lost Labour the election and sent farmers to Reform UK
Breathtaking betrayal of UK taxpayers that even Emmanuel Macron can see
Fury over suggestion state pension age could be increased to 80
Jeremy Corbyn at war with Angela Rayner over plans to concrete over Britain's allotments
Keir Starmer's false advertising and 3 assurances Labour are failing on
New poll reveals exactly what Brits think of migration - it's bad news for Keir Starmer
Nigel Farage issues 8-word statement after Reform trans row erupts
New poll reveals Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves are now less popular than Donald Trump
POLL: Will Keir Starmer's ‘one in, one out' deal stop the boats?
Angela Rayner told 'there's still time' to reject Chinese Super Embassy in London
Labour proves Keir Starmer is busted flush with move showing it can get even worse
Deluded Keir Starmer shows how wrong Labour's priorities are with one new scheme
Labour surrendered on housing within days - here are vital steps they won't take for UK
7 Wealth Tips Once Your Portfolio Reaches $1MFisher Investments
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Put Tin Foil On Your Door Knob When Alone. Here's WhyTrendGuruTips
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
How Seniors Are Checking Glucose Without the HassleGlucose Monitor
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Undo
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Powered By
10 Sec
Patrick Christys slams Labour's way to tackle illegal immigration
Next
Stay
Ironically, the suggestion came from Winston Churchill, then Secretary of State for War and Air, who later became its bitterest opponent. Officially abandoned only in March 1932, even then spending continued to decline due to effects of the Great Depression. It led directly to Chamberlain’s woeful appeasement policy of 1938 and Britain unpreparedness for the Second World War in 1939.
Sponsored
Always Put a Penny on Your Tires when Parked, Here's Why
Undo
Healeys have traditionally had a close association with defence under Labour. Denis (no relation) held the post from 1964-70, and began the economic drives which brought us to where we are today. His namesake now has to reverse that trend. The Strategic Defence Review, urgent and necessary though it was, took 11 cumbersome months to deliver, in an era of unparalleled international tension. What Britain now needs is a continuous uninterrupted, rolling defence review, free from political interference.
Only this will ensure, as drone and AI technologies evolve at breakneck speed, that we are ready for the next war, if it comes.
SUBSCRIBEInvalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy