OPINION

       A proposed labour law seeks to ban banter across various social venues (Image: Getty)

       Are you ready for the “banter ban”? Labour is planning to ban banter in pubs, restaurants, bars, entertainment venues and football stadiums. Clause 20 of the Employment Rights Bill, currently going through the House of Lords, amends the Equality Act to impose a legal duty on employers to “take all reasonable steps” to prevent their employees being “harassed” by third parties – meaning they could be sued by their workers if they don’t do enough.

       That may sound reasonable, but the Worker Protection Act 2023 already extends employers’ liability under the Equality Act for third-party sexual harassment – and of course, any form of physical assault is already a crime. So the “harassment” we’re talking about here is verbal. Among other things, it will include conversations between customers or members of the public that are overheard by employees – not directed at them – and which they find offensive in virtue of one or more “protected” characteristics.

       Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT

       Milana Vayntrub, 38, Shows Off Her Perfect Figure In These PhotosSuburban Finance | Sponsored Sponsored

       Read More

       Undo

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Sky TV still down with UK homes complaining they can't watch television

       36 Comments

       Warning to anyone who has used M&S online shopping

       3 Comments

       I chanced upon vital support as cancer patient - but how many are missing out?

       Comments

       UK households urged to reuse shower water for 2 key tasks

       2 Comments

       IPSO upholds Accuracy complaint against express.co.uk 'mortgage rates' headline

       9 Comments

       'I'm a travel expert and have 1 method for never getting lost - even without Wi-Fi'

       3 Comments

       Kanye West's 'horrendous' new antisemitic song banned on Spotify

       4 Comments

       Make Sure You're Alone Before Looking At These Dubai PhotosStars Are Made | Sponsored Sponsored

       Read More

       Undo

       Doctor warns UK's 'screendemic' is 'poisoning our children' in mental health fears

       20 Comments

       Watch the incredible moment monkey in 'performs operation' on woman

       1 Comments

       Siemens Energy Powers AI Data Center ExpansionSiemens Energy | Sponsored Sponsored

       Read More

       Undo

       Warning issued to anyone who leaves multiple tabs open on their computer

       2 Comments

       Google Pixel 9 falls to 'lowest price' in Sky sale as major Android update unveiled

       2 Comments

       13 Oldest Hollywood Stars We Didn't Know Were Still AliveScreen Scoop | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Your Chrome browser is getting its most vital free upgrade in years - here's what's new

       Comments

       Fitbit offers very smart free upgrade but there is a catch for UK users

       1 Comments

       Malia Reveals Her Boyfriend & You Will Easily Recognize HimScreen Scoop | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       After Losing Weight Kevin James Looks Like A ModelCash Roadster | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       Check Your Credit Score for Free TodayIntuit Credit Karma | Sponsored Sponsored

       Sign Up

       Undo

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       They Were So Beautiful Before; Now Look At Them; Number 10 Will Shock YouFab Pop | Sponsored Sponsored

       Learn More

       Undo

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Sky TV still down with UK homes complaining they can't watch television

       36 Comments

       Milana Vayntrub, 38, Show Her Huge Size In A New PhotoThe Latest Article | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Warning to anyone who has used M&S online shopping

       3 Comments

       I chanced upon vital support as cancer patient - but how many are missing out?

       Comments

       Eagle Tries to Steal Puppy from Yard – Whatch What the Neighbors DidTips and Tricks | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       UK households urged to reuse shower water for 2 key tasks

       2 Comments

       IPSO upholds Accuracy complaint against express.co.uk 'mortgage rates' headline

       9 Comments

       Valerie Bertinelli's Inheritance Makes The HeadlinesGameBea | Sponsored Sponsored

       Read More

       Undo

       'I'm a travel expert and have 1 method for never getting lost - even without Wi-Fi'

       3 Comments

       Kanye West's 'horrendous' new antisemitic song banned on Spotify

       4 Comments

       Doctor warns UK's 'screendemic' is 'poisoning our children' in mental health fears

       20 Comments

       Watch the incredible moment monkey in 'performs operation' on woman

       1 Comments

       Warning issued to anyone who leaves multiple tabs open on their computer

       2 Comments

       Google Pixel 9 falls to 'lowest price' in Sky sale as major Android update unveiled

       2 Comments

       Your Chrome browser is getting its most vital free upgrade in years - here's what's new

       Comments

       Fitbit offers very smart free upgrade but there is a catch for UK users

       1 Comments

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Not just their own, mind you. Under Labour’s new law, employees will be able to take offence on behalf of one of their colleagues.

       Given that we live in an age in which some are hyper-sensitive, the implications for the hospitality sector of turbo-charging the Equality Act in this way are mind-boggling.

       Powered By

       10 Sec

       644.6K

       120

       Cat Deeley interviews Rishi Sunak on This Morning

       Next

       Stay

       Don't miss...

       UK pubs delivered another blow as Starmer bans popular drinking law change [LATEST]

       School bans hit record high - 'Labour must get a grip' [LATEST]

       ‘Now Labour bans talking in pubs in sinister Angela Rayner plan' [LATEST]

       The law could see employees sue their employers for lack of protection against harassment (Image: Getty)

       What “reasonable steps” will a publican be expected to take to protect his or her staff from overhearing conversations between customers that might upset them?

       Sponsored

       Insider | Travel Deals | Sponsored Sponsored

       Seniors Can Now Fly Business Class For the Price Of Economy

       Undo

       Will it be sufficient to include a notice on the wall warning customers to keep their opinions to themselves, on issues such as gender neutral toilets, mass immigration and the Israel-Gaza conflict? Or will publicans need to go further and employ “banter bouncers” to eavesdrop on customers and eject anyone for saying something “inappropriate” or “problematic”, such as telling a saucy joke?

       It seems extraordinary that this Government, which claims to be pro-growth, is about to impose additional compliance costs on a sector that’s already on its knees. According to the Campaign for Real Ale, 37 pubs close every week in Britain.

       There’s little doubt that this new law will accelerate that rate of closure – and those that remain will be sanitized “safe spaces” in which no one dares express a controversial opinion or tell a joke.

       That’s one reason why Hospitality UK and the British Beer and Pub Association have come out against the “banter ban”. But it isn’t just pubs. In football stadiums, it’s not unusual for fans to shout “Are you blind?” at the linesman for failing to rule a goal offside or spot a handball.

       Once this new law is on the books, a partially sighted steward who overhears this could sue the club for not taking “all reasonable steps” to protect him from being “harassed”, i.e., overhearing that expostulation.

       Don't miss...

       Readers debate whether Angela Rayner would make a better PM than Keir Starmer [LATEST]

       'The 12 biggest lies Keir Starmer told us – now they're coming back to bite him' [LATEST]

       'Keir Starmer spinning in wind is enough to make you wonder why he became PM' [LATEST]

       The proposed law would force football clubs to crack down on chants deemed offensive (Image: Getty)

       SUBSCRIBE Invalid email

       We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

       Trending

       Indeed, any of his colleagues could sue the club on his behalf. That, in turn, means football clubs will have to clamp down on any expostulations or chants that might cause offence. If Sir Keir Starmer has his way, it won’t just be his beloved Arsenal that’s a library! Expecting employers to police the speech of their customers in this way will have a hugely chilling effect on free speech.

       The fearful atmosphere that prevails in so many workplaces since the passing of the Equality Act, with people looking over their shoulders before whispering what they really think about a controversial issue, will be extended to the venues people go to in their leisure time.

       The era when every pub was a parliament, to use Nigel Farage’s memorable phrase, will be over. In the Commons, the Conservatives tabled an amendment to the Employment Rights Bill disapplying clause 20 in its entirety, and another excluding pubs, sports and hospitality venues from its impact.

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Sky TV still down with UK homes complaining they can't watch television

       36 Comments

       Warning to anyone who has used M&S online shopping

       3 Comments

       I chanced upon vital support as cancer patient - but how many are missing out?

       Comments

       UK households urged to reuse shower water for 2 key tasks

       2 Comments

       IPSO upholds Accuracy complaint against express.co.uk 'mortgage rates' headline

       9 Comments

       'I'm a travel expert and have 1 method for never getting lost - even without Wi-Fi'

       3 Comments

       Kanye West's 'horrendous' new antisemitic song banned on Spotify

       4 Comments

       10 Best Mattresses by Consumer Reports (Here's What You May Not Want to Miss)QuestionHero | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Doctor warns UK's 'screendemic' is 'poisoning our children' in mental health fears

       20 Comments

       Watch the incredible moment monkey in 'performs operation' on woman

       1 Comments

       Malia Steps Out With Her Boyfriend And You Will Easily Recognize Him.App Cute | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Warning issued to anyone who leaves multiple tabs open on their computer

       2 Comments

       Google Pixel 9 falls to 'lowest price' in Sky sale as major Android update unveiled

       2 Comments

       Clint Eastwood's New Home Makes Us All Look TwiceThe Mom Pack | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Your Chrome browser is getting its most vital free upgrade in years - here's what's new

       Comments

       Fitbit offers very smart free upgrade but there is a catch for UK users

       1 Comments

       Larry Bird's Wife Is Hands Down The Most Beautiful Woman In The WorldGood Hype | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       AI Imagined Miss USA for Each State and It Got HilariousBigGlobalTravel | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       Aaron Rodgers Reveals His New Girlfriend & You Will Easily Recognize Her.The Mom Pack | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       Adam Lambert, 43, Takes off His Makeup and Leaves Us Without WordsSuburban Finance | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Sky TV still down with UK homes complaining they can't watch television

       36 Comments

       The secret trick transforming men in their 50s, and 60s.Cureva | Sponsored Sponsored

       Learn More

       Undo

       Warning to anyone who has used M&S online shopping

       3 Comments

       I chanced upon vital support as cancer patient - but how many are missing out?

       Comments

       Honey Boo Boo Is So Thin. See Her In Recent Fierce PhotoThe Latest Article | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       UK households urged to reuse shower water for 2 key tasks

       2 Comments

       IPSO upholds Accuracy complaint against express.co.uk 'mortgage rates' headline

       9 Comments

       Eagle Approaches Puppy in Yard - Watch What The Neighbor Did NextTips and Tricks | Sponsored Sponsored

       Undo

       'I'm a travel expert and have 1 method for never getting lost - even without Wi-Fi'

       3 Comments

       Kanye West's 'horrendous' new antisemitic song banned on Spotify

       4 Comments

       Doctor warns UK's 'screendemic' is 'poisoning our children' in mental health fears

       20 Comments

       Watch the incredible moment monkey in 'performs operation' on woman

       1 Comments

       Warning issued to anyone who leaves multiple tabs open on their computer

       2 Comments

       Google Pixel 9 falls to 'lowest price' in Sky sale as major Android update unveiled

       2 Comments

       Your Chrome browser is getting its most vital free upgrade in years - here's what's new

       Comments

       Fitbit offers very smart free upgrade but there is a catch for UK users

       1 Comments

       iPhone users issued urgent warning to turn off feature now

       1 Comments

       Millions of Android users placed on red alert and told to follow four new rules

       Comments

       Ex-airport security officer shares 'vital' thing to avoid before boarding a plane

       Comments

       The huge megalopolis where 4 of world's biggest mega-cities are merging together

       Comments

       'I had no idea about this game-changing iPhone feature'

       Comments

       Expert shares 'best way' to increase property value - but you must do 1 thing

       Comments

       All Chrome users must 'relaunch' their browser now - don't ignore new alert

       1 Comments

       Seniors Born 1941-1979 Receive 12+ Benefits This Month if They AskUSWalletSaver

       Undo

       by Taboola by Taboola

       Sponsored Links Sponsored Links

       Promoted Links Promoted Links

       Amazon Is Losing Money as Nevada Shoppers Are Canceling Prime for This Clever HackOnline Shopping Tools

       Undo

       by Taboola by Taboola

       Sponsored Links Sponsored Links

       Promoted Links Promoted Links

       27-year-old Lives In This Shed - Take a look insideTips and Tricks

       Undo

       by Taboola by Taboola

       Sponsored Links Sponsored Links

       Promoted Links Promoted Links

       Serious Dating for SeniorsSecretmeet

       Undo

       by Taboola by Taboola

       Sponsored Links Sponsored Links

       Promoted Links Promoted Links

       But not a single Labour or Lib Dem MP voted for either. Amending the Bill in the House of Lords – which I’m currently trying to do – is our last chance to stop this attempt to ramp up the policing of speech outside the workplace.

       One final point: when the Equality Act was originally passed, it included a clause making employers liable for the harassment of employees by third parties, but it was repealed in 2013 because it proved to be so costly and difficult for employers to comply with. We mustn’t make the same mistake again.

       Lord Young of Acton is the general secretary of the Free Speech Union