Lindsay Hoyle sparks Commons uproar
A senior Tory MP has started a motion of no confidence in Commons speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle, after he sparked fury and uproar in the Commons this lunchtime at a level not seen since the fevered Brexit rows of 2019.
The Speaker drew comparisons with his predecessor John Bercow, after tearing up the rule book to allow a vote on a Labour motion around Gaza and Israel.
The SNP have been allocated a day's debate today, and chose Gaza and Israel in the hope of splitting the Labour Party.
However last night Labour submitted their own amendment to allow its divided MPs to unite over the controversial foreign policy issue.
The Government also submitted an amendment backing Israel's right to self-defence, and precedent would dictate that the Government's amendment would be voted on instead of Labour’s.
Stay up-to-date with the latest Politics news Join us on WhatsApp Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
Commons chaos as Sir Lindsay tears up the rule book (Image: Parliament Live)
However in a departure from longstanding rules, Sir Lindsay announced MPs would vote on both Labour and the Government's amendments.
The confirmation after hours of rumour and deliberation sparked immediate Commons chaos among both Tory and SNP MPs.
In a tense point of order, the SNP's Chief Whip in Westminster demanded to know what the point of their opposition day debate now is after Labour has been given such sway over what's being voted on.
Such was the anger, one MP shouted "Bring back Bercow" after Sir Lindsay confirmed his decision. Another MP compared the Speaker's lengthy deliberation over whether to break Commons rules as "Bercow levels of s**t”.
In response, senior Tory MP Will Wragg was seen storming out the Commons and shortly after confirmed he has laid an Early Day Motion saying that the Commons has no faith in the Speaker.
Don't miss...
Brexiteer warns of Labour 'socialists' dragging UK back into EU in PMQs attack [LATEST]
SNP uses mini embassy in Brussels to pitch independent Scotland as EU member [LATEST]
Penny Mordaunt backed by Tory voters over Rishi Sunak for general election win [LATEST]
The SNP Chief Whip fumed at Sir Lindsay Hoyle's decision (Image: Parliament Live)
Become an Express Premium member Support fearless journalism Read The Daily Express online, advert free Get super-fast page loading
Start 30-day
FREE trial
Fellow Tory MP Maria Caulfield tweeted: "Now we know why Sue Gray was on the Speakers corridor ahead of the start of the opposition day debate and then outside the Labour whip’s office".
Explaining his decision to ditch Parliamentary convention, Sir Lindsay Hoyle accepted it was “exceptional” and struggled to get through his statement due to heckling.
He told MPs that he would honour his election commitment of publishing any advice from his clerks amid controversial decisions, after a Tory MP pre-empted Sir Lindsay’s rule-breaking move after PMQs and raised a point of order demanding he stick to his promise.
The Speaker told the House: “In my opinion, the operation of [the relevant rule], which governs the way opposition day motions are dealt with, reflects an outdated approach which restricts…
At this point the Commons erupted in anger, with cries of “shame”, and Sir Lindsay had to demand quiet.
He continued that the current rules, in his view, “restricts the options which can put to the house" and announced his intention to ask the Commons Procedure Committee to consider the the rule.
Trending
Responding to the announcement, SNP frontbencher Owen Thompson demanded to know why the SNP’s Opposition Day debate had been railroaded by the Labour Party.
Mr Thompson pointed out that the purpose of an opposition day debate is to allow their party to put forward their business.
He slammed the Labour Party for already delaying the debate by at least 30 minutes due to a number of Point of Orders after PMQs, and Labour forcing an unnecessary vote on a 10-minute rule motion prior to the start of the Gaza debate.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Palestine protest: Jaw-dropping moment 'from the river to the sea' projected onto Big Ben
2502 Comments
Full list of MPs voting no confidence in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle after Commons uproar
137 Comments
Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today
268 Comments
Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker after chaos
262 Comments
Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate
1123 Comments
Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant
17 Comments
Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle issues grovelling apology amid MP shouts to 'resign'
128 Comments
Lindsay Hoyle and SNP leader standoff in the Wild West saloon of Westminster
37 Comments
Furious MPs plot to oust Lindsay Hoyle over Labour 'stitch-up' of crunch Gaza vote
1577 Comments
Rishi Sunak hits out at 'very concerning' rule-bending by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle
75 Comments
The Gaza debate became a clown show - but here's why we shouldn't be laughing
100 Comments
Chaos erupts in Commons as Penny Mordaunt takes aim at speaker over Gaza vote
130 Comments
Sadiq Khan fact-checked on X after hitting out at Rishi Sunak over Gaza
175 Comments
Our latest poll suggests Tory plots against Rishi Sunak are doomed
12 Comments
Keir Starmer urged to come clean on what he told Speaker Lindsay Hoyle as pressure mounts
1159 Comments
Nigel Farage issues stark warning after chaos erupts in Commons over Gaza
688 Comments
Who should be the next speaker of the House of Commons?
18 Comments
Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle
883 Comments
Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle fights for political survival as 67 MPs call for him to go
602 Comments
Should Speaker Lindsay Hoyle resign after Commons chaos over Gaza? Vote here
660 Comments
Palestine protest: Jaw-dropping moment 'from the river to the sea' projected onto Big Ben
2502 Comments
Full list of MPs voting no confidence in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle after Commons uproar
137 Comments
Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today
268 Comments
Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker after chaos
262 Comments
Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate
1123 Comments
Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant
17 Comments
Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle issues grovelling apology amid MP shouts to 'resign'
128 Comments
Lindsay Hoyle and SNP leader standoff in the Wild West saloon of Westminster
37 Comments
Furious MPs plot to oust Lindsay Hoyle over Labour 'stitch-up' of crunch Gaza vote
1577 Comments
Rishi Sunak hits out at 'very concerning' rule-bending by Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle
75 Comments
The Gaza debate became a clown show - but here's why we shouldn't be laughing
100 Comments
Chaos erupts in Commons as Penny Mordaunt takes aim at speaker over Gaza vote
130 Comments
Sadiq Khan fact-checked on X after hitting out at Rishi Sunak over Gaza
175 Comments
Our latest poll suggests Tory plots against Rishi Sunak are doomed
12 Comments
Keir Starmer urged to come clean on what he told Speaker Lindsay Hoyle as pressure mounts
1159 Comments
Nigel Farage issues stark warning after chaos erupts in Commons over Gaza
688 Comments
Who should be the next speaker of the House of Commons?
18 Comments
Tories and SNP storm out of Commons in furious protest against Lindsay Hoyle
883 Comments
Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle fights for political survival as 67 MPs call for him to go
602 Comments
Should Speaker Lindsay Hoyle resign after Commons chaos over Gaza? Vote here
660 Comments
Palestine protest: Jaw-dropping moment 'from the river to the sea' projected onto Big Ben
2502 Comments
Full list of MPs voting no confidence in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle after Commons uproar
137 Comments
Ring of steel placed around Parliament as pro-Palestine mob descends on Westminster today
268 Comments
Sir Lindsay Hoyle clinging to job as dozens of MPs lose confidence in Speaker after chaos
262 Comments
Keir Starmer referred to top parliamentary ethics watchdog by MP over Speaker-gate
1123 Comments
Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle destroyed his reputation as a straight dealer in an instant
17 Comments
Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle issues grovelling apology amid MP shouts to 'resign'
128 Comments
The SNP chief whip fumed: “We appear to be doing things in a way that has never been done before!
“Can I ask you, Mr Speaker, what is the point of an opposition day if it’s going to be done like this?"
SNP MPs broke out into applause at the point, something explicitly banned by Commons rules, sparking further anger from the Speaker.
Related articles David Cameron takes swipe at his own Brexit referendum during Falklands visit Rishi Sunak heading for another by-election nightmare as MP faces suspension Fury at ‘failing’ Bank of England, but Andrew Bailey gives hope of rates cut Campaigners warn not to believe Labour triple lock pledge yet Furious Tory MP tears into European Court of Human Rights over Alkali Attacker