QT: Audience member asks what Labour are doing
A member of the Question Time audience sparked laughter and applause this evening after she remarked she’s “starting to think Labour doesn’t actually know what it’s doing”.
The observation came after a tense row between senior minister Nick Thomas-Symonds and Fiona Bruce over how many farms will actually be affected by Rachel Reeves’ planned tractor tax.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
Keir Starmer squirms as his farmer tax blunder is exposed live on-air
343 Comments
If Ministers don't listen, this could be the end of UK farming as we know it
53 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
88 Comments
POLL: Should Labour U-turn on farmer inheritance tax?
214 Comments
Seventh generation farmer accuses Labour of trying to destroy sector with Budget changes
22 Comments
Labour's hypocrisy laid bare as Cabinet Secretary admits U-turn on farm inheritance tax
700 Comments
Farmer protests LIVE: Huge tractor convoy masses as Keir Starmer faces huge backlash
1296 Comments
Labour tax raid warning as shoppers buying milk and eggs face paying more
7 Comments
Fury as it's revealed foreign farmers are being handed ￡500m in aid amid tractor tax row
456 Comments
Tesco and Asda shoppers warned of food shortages and higher prices over Labour tax raid
1 Comments
Kemi Badenoch warns Labour's ‘cruel' tax on farmers will destroy farming in Britain
304 Comments
Farmers 'stabbed in back' by Labour's 'cruel' tax raid to unleash fury at protest
36 Comments
Keir Starmer claims 'first job was on a farm' as massive protest erupts
65 Comments
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
Keir Starmer squirms as his farmer tax blunder is exposed live on-air
343 Comments
If Ministers don't listen, this could be the end of UK farming as we know it
53 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
88 Comments
POLL: Should Labour U-turn on farmer inheritance tax?
214 Comments
Seventh generation farmer accuses Labour of trying to destroy sector with Budget changes
22 Comments
Labour's hypocrisy laid bare as Cabinet Secretary admits U-turn on farm inheritance tax
700 Comments
Farmer protests LIVE: Huge tractor convoy masses as Keir Starmer faces huge backlash
1296 Comments
Labour tax raid warning as shoppers buying milk and eggs face paying more
7 Comments
Fury as it's revealed foreign farmers are being handed ￡500m in aid amid tractor tax row
456 Comments
Tesco and Asda shoppers warned of food shortages and higher prices over Labour tax raid
1 Comments
Kemi Badenoch warns Labour's ‘cruel' tax on farmers will destroy farming in Britain
304 Comments
Farmers 'stabbed in back' by Labour's 'cruel' tax raid to unleash fury at protest
36 Comments
Keir Starmer claims 'first job was on a farm' as massive protest erupts
65 Comments
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
Turning to the audience, the BBC Question Time host went to a woman who blasted Labour over their incompetence and love of tax rises.
She quipped: “I’m starting to think that Labour doesn’t actually know what it’s doing.
“You’ve taxed people who grow and make food, you want to make people poorer who have actually worked and contributed - what are you doing?
READ MORE: Fury at foreign farmers being handed ￡500m in overseas aid
The audience member tore into Labour's plans (Image: BBC)
“I think it’s just a stalling tactic just to tax people in the end. What are you doing? I don’t know!”
The camera then cut to Cabinet Office minister Nick Thomas-Symonds shaking his head as the audience applauded.
A second audience member also criticised the government’s inheritance tax policy, saying farmers don’t just hand out a business but a livelihood.
The man said: “I thought inheritance tax was to tax the wealth that somebody inherits, whereas these farmers are inheriting a way of life, a livelihood.
“Therefore they’re not gaining anything in wealth, so if they were to sell [the farm] ok yes go for the capital gains and other taxes. But inheritance tax, no, this is one they shouldn’t get burdened with.”
A farmer in the Wiltshire audience said that while he accepts there is a burden on the country’s tax pot at the moment, he worries that at the point inheritance tax becomes due “you aren’t in a position to pay it without selling an asset that then destabilises the exact entity you’ve built up to create a profit from.”
He explained that his parents who own the farm are in their 80s, and therefore the 7-year rule around gifting to avoid inheritance tax “is not relevant to many many people to parents who are farming with their children.”
Don't miss...
I am a fifth generation British farmer... but there may not be a sixth [LATEST]
Row as Labour denies any plans to u-turn over tractor tax despite media reports [LATEST]
Steve Reed refuses to apologise to farmers for 'anguish' caused by budget [LATEST]
Nick Thomas-Symonds squirmed as the audience laughed at Labour (Image: BBC)
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
Conservative MP Harriett Baldwin recounted the emotional stories she had heard from her local farmers who attended this week’s rally in Westminster.
Ms Baldwin said they were in floods of tears over their family livelihoods, and insisted all family farms will eventually be caught out by the tax over time.
She explained family farms “do something very precious for us”.
“They provide food security to the UK. One of the things that I learned this week was a phrase from Clement Attlee, about whom Nick [Thomas Symonds] has written a biography, which was that after the First World War when we ran into food security issues he vowed that the UK should never find itself in that position again.
“So that I think is what makes this different from the ordinary family who is caught in an inheritance tax situation.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
Keir Starmer squirms as his farmer tax blunder is exposed live on-air
343 Comments
If Ministers don't listen, this could be the end of UK farming as we know it
53 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
88 Comments
POLL: Should Labour U-turn on farmer inheritance tax?
214 Comments
Seventh generation farmer accuses Labour of trying to destroy sector with Budget changes
22 Comments
Labour's hypocrisy laid bare as Cabinet Secretary admits U-turn on farm inheritance tax
700 Comments
Farmer protests LIVE: Huge tractor convoy masses as Keir Starmer faces huge backlash
1296 Comments
Labour tax raid warning as shoppers buying milk and eggs face paying more
7 Comments
Fury as it's revealed foreign farmers are being handed ￡500m in aid amid tractor tax row
455 Comments
Tesco and Asda shoppers warned of food shortages and higher prices over Labour tax raid
1 Comments
Kemi Badenoch warns Labour's ‘cruel' tax on farmers will destroy farming in Britain
304 Comments
Farmers 'stabbed in back' by Labour's 'cruel' tax raid to unleash fury at protest
36 Comments
Keir Starmer claims 'first job was on a farm' as massive protest erupts
65 Comments
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
Keir Starmer squirms as his farmer tax blunder is exposed live on-air
343 Comments
If Ministers don't listen, this could be the end of UK farming as we know it
53 Comments
We must stand shoulder to shoulder with our farmers - they need us now
88 Comments
POLL: Should Labour U-turn on farmer inheritance tax?
214 Comments
Seventh generation farmer accuses Labour of trying to destroy sector with Budget changes
22 Comments
Labour's hypocrisy laid bare as Cabinet Secretary admits U-turn on farm inheritance tax
700 Comments
Farmer protests LIVE: Huge tractor convoy masses as Keir Starmer faces huge backlash
1296 Comments
Labour tax raid warning as shoppers buying milk and eggs face paying more
7 Comments
Fury as it's revealed foreign farmers are being handed ￡500m in aid amid tractor tax row
455 Comments
Tesco and Asda shoppers warned of food shortages and higher prices over Labour tax raid
1 Comments
Kemi Badenoch warns Labour's ‘cruel' tax on farmers will destroy farming in Britain
304 Comments
Farmers 'stabbed in back' by Labour's 'cruel' tax raid to unleash fury at protest
36 Comments
Keir Starmer claims 'first job was on a farm' as massive protest erupts
65 Comments
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer's MPs join Tories in calling for major U-turn
47 Comments
Farmer strike threat sparks panic in Labour Party with food shortage plans drawn up
320 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'refusing to engage' amid furious protests against Labour's family farm tax
9 Comments
Labour's 'war on farmers' sparks protest over inheritance tax and food security risks
53 Comments
The food and drink items Brits might struggle to get hold of this winter
2 Comments
Andrew Lloyd Webber praised for government takedown as he joins Clarkson at farmers' rally
29 Comments
Farmers have 'nothing to lose' as contingency plans drawn up over food shortage fears
141 Comments
“These are people who put food on our table, who provide the milk in our supermarket, who feed us.
“To take away a fifth of their farm every time it changes generation you can see how over the long term that is going to erode their ability not only to pass down the land but really importantly to pass down those traditions of dairy farming, arable farming.”
She won a large round of applause from the Wiltshire audience for her opposition to Labour’s policy.