OPINION
A year since taking power, big challenges face the PM (Image: Getty)
After last year’s election, I argued Britain needs to start thinking like a business if it wants to get back on track. I supported the Prime Minister and Chancellor’s commitment to put growth at the top of their priority list with measurable objectives and hard deadlines.
Their support for clear targets made a good deal of sense. Most people instinctively understand the difference between a vague ambition and a time bound target pinned to someone’s name. Ministers call it “mission-led government.” Every pledge would be tracked, measured and judged in public. The private sector has a name for this form of analysis - the Key Performance Indicator. As a former CEO of an online trading company, this is something I’m more than familiar with.
Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Rachel Reeves 'considering tax raid' on pensioners after winter fuel U-turn
978 Comments
Warning lights flashing red on UK economy and it's all on woeful Rachel Reeves's watch
313 Comments
Rachel Reeves savaged by Reform as Chancellor warned a 'crisis' is incoming
6 Comments
Water bills set to soar by 30% in just five years as Ofwat to be scrapped
60 Comments
Labour have sat on their hands for 14 years - and their latest policy proves it
9 Comments
Raise personal tax allowance to ￡15,597 major update as new push starts
13 Comments
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Rachel Reeves Budget backlash as food prices rise again
9 Comments
Triple lock policy change risks 'negatively impact' for state pensioners
Comments
The 5 ways to protect your money from Rachel Reeves' tax raids
Comments
State pension triple lock 'major changes' warning issued
128 Comments
Rachel Reeves facing judgement day as recession fears explode over ￡30bn black hole
439 Comments
Labour lives in fantasy bubble and can't see it's making mistakes of 1970s
60 Comments
Angela Rayner 'clashes' with Rachel Reeves over demand for new tax
36 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'considering tax raid' on pensioners after winter fuel U-turn
978 Comments
Warning lights flashing red on UK economy and it's all on woeful Rachel Reeves's watch
313 Comments
Rachel Reeves savaged by Reform as Chancellor warned a 'crisis' is incoming
6 Comments
Water bills set to soar by 30% in just five years as Ofwat to be scrapped
60 Comments
Labour have sat on their hands for 14 years - and their latest policy proves it
9 Comments
Raise personal tax allowance to ￡15,597 major update as new push starts
13 Comments
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Rachel Reeves Budget backlash as food prices rise again
9 Comments
Triple lock policy change risks 'negatively impact' for state pensioners
Comments
The 5 ways to protect your money from Rachel Reeves' tax raids
Comments
State pension triple lock 'major changes' warning issued
128 Comments
Rachel Reeves facing judgement day as recession fears explode over ￡30bn black hole
439 Comments
Labour lives in fantasy bubble and can't see it's making mistakes of 1970s
60 Comments
Angela Rayner 'clashes' with Rachel Reeves over demand for new tax
36 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'considering tax raid' on pensioners after winter fuel U-turn
978 Comments
Warning lights flashing red on UK economy and it's all on woeful Rachel Reeves's watch
313 Comments
Rachel Reeves savaged by Reform as Chancellor warned a 'crisis' is incoming
6 Comments
Water bills set to soar by 30% in just five years as Ofwat to be scrapped
60 Comments
Labour have sat on their hands for 14 years - and their latest policy proves it
9 Comments
Raise personal tax allowance to ￡15,597 major update as new push starts
13 Comments
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Rachel Reeves Budget backlash as food prices rise again
9 Comments
Triple lock policy change risks 'negatively impact' for state pensioners
Comments
The 5 ways to protect your money from Rachel Reeves' tax raids
Comments
State pension triple lock 'major changes' warning issued
128 Comments
Rachel Reeves facing judgement day as recession fears explode over ￡30bn black hole
439 Comments
Labour lives in fantasy bubble and can't see it's making mistakes of 1970s
60 Comments
Angela Rayner 'clashes' with Rachel Reeves over demand for new tax
36 Comments
Read more: Crunch moment for Rachel Reeves as recession fears mount
Read more: Reform UK says Nigel Farage is PM in waiting after new poll boost
The KPI system, which ranks performance from red to green, is a good way to enhance focus and accountability. The traffic light system triggers debate, because there’s so little room to hide - the “devil really is in the detail.”
Sadly, one year into their time in office, the government seems to have abandoned its commitment to this kind of transparency. And, a year later, reality looks rather different.
Whilst many targets have been set - and some are genuinely ambitious, there are still too many five-year goals, too many get-outs, and too little accountability.
Worse still, the much-touted Mission Boards, which were supposed to scrutinise delivery, have vanished into the ether.
It says something about modern politics that even in the digital age, when almost any metric can be tracked in real time, the electorate still has to surf multiple websites to see if the promises made to them are being kept.
In a business, this wouldn’t be tolerated. You don’t get to shirk responsibility. You don’t get to shrug and blame the economic weather when your targets flash red. You certainly don’t get to hide the numbers.
That’s why, in the absence of an official scoreboard, the Adam Smith Institute and I have compiled our own. We’ve rolled up our sleeves and collected 16 of the government’s key performance indicators from manifestos, speeches and policy documents. When the targets were set over five years, we’ve prorated them to see where they should stand after 12 months. Where relevant, we have started our analysis on day one of their government.
And, to make things nice and simple, we did what any good board would do, colour-coded them. Green for success. Amber if they were close (or faced genuine mitigating factors). Red for failure.
I should stress that this type of analysis is unemotional, focusing on the performance of the previous 12 months. This analysis of performance versus KPIs does not seek to justify or commend the decisions of this government - simply to hold them to account.
Of the 16 KPIs, six are green and seven are red, with the rest being mixed or lacking adequate data. Worryingly, the reds include many of the main economic drivers. Monthly growth has averaged just 0.09% since July 2024, well below the rate needed to achieve the goal of 2.5% annual growth by 2029. What’s more, inflation, which the government pledged to stabilise at 2%, has also risen, with June’s annualised CPI inflation reaching 3.7%.
Of course, sluggish growth is hardly surprising when you factor in the government’s decision to raise National insurance contributions and scrap the non-dom regime.
Looking at the rest of the KPI portfolio, there are a few bright spots - particularly relating to spending. The government, to its credit, is on track to meet its proposals on delivering new NHS appointments, hiring more mental health staff and is likely to increase defence spending to 2.5% of GDP.
But, this raises wider questions about the government’s overall strategy. What does this mean for our public finances when the government is meeting its spending commitments but not growing the economy as planned?
The Adam Smith Institute's scorecard on the Government (Image: Adam Smith Institute)
In the end, the government’s performance against these KPIs has been disappointing. Regardless of what one might think of their mission, they’re far from making it a reality. And, they’re struggling to deliver where it matters most - economic growth.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Rachel Reeves Budget backlash as food prices rise again
9 Comments
Triple lock policy change risks 'negatively impact' for state pensioners
Comments
The 5 ways to protect your money from Rachel Reeves' tax raids
Comments
State pension triple lock 'major changes' warning issued
128 Comments
Rachel Reeves facing judgement day as recession fears explode over ￡30bn black hole
439 Comments
Labour lives in fantasy bubble and can't see it's making mistakes of 1970s
60 Comments
Angela Rayner 'clashes' with Rachel Reeves over demand for new tax
36 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'considering tax raid' on pensioners after winter fuel U-turn
978 Comments
Warning lights flashing red on UK economy and it's all on woeful Rachel Reeves's watch
313 Comments
Rachel Reeves savaged by Reform as Chancellor warned a 'crisis' is incoming
6 Comments
Water bills set to soar by 30% in just five years as Ofwat to be scrapped
60 Comments
Labour have sat on their hands for 14 years - and their latest policy proves it
9 Comments
Raise personal tax allowance to ￡15,597 major update as new push starts
13 Comments
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Rachel Reeves Budget backlash as food prices rise again
9 Comments
Triple lock policy change risks 'negatively impact' for state pensioners
Comments
The 5 ways to protect your money from Rachel Reeves' tax raids
Comments
State pension triple lock 'major changes' warning issued
128 Comments
Rachel Reeves facing judgement day as recession fears explode over ￡30bn black hole
439 Comments
Labour lives in fantasy bubble and can't see it's making mistakes of 1970s
60 Comments
Angela Rayner 'clashes' with Rachel Reeves over demand for new tax
36 Comments
Rachel Reeves 'considering tax raid' on pensioners after winter fuel U-turn
978 Comments
Warning lights flashing red on UK economy and it's all on woeful Rachel Reeves's watch
313 Comments
Rachel Reeves savaged by Reform as Chancellor warned a 'crisis' is incoming
6 Comments
Water bills set to soar by 30% in just five years as Ofwat to be scrapped
60 Comments
Labour have sat on their hands for 14 years - and their latest policy proves it
9 Comments
Raise personal tax allowance to ￡15,597 major update as new push starts
13 Comments
Labour makes huge sewage pledge to save Britain's waterways
163 Comments
DWP State Pension looks set for another major change
6 Comments
New calls for over-60s to be exempt from paying National Insurance
3 Comments
Rachel Reeves has 'made one huge mistake' - and 'now we have the proof'
169 Comments
Massive tax hikes 'looming' as Kemi Badenoch issues major warning
446 Comments
Rachel Reeves given 'bad' warning as Budget pressure mounts
1 Comments
GMB's Ed Balls clash with Feargal Sharkey leaves viewers all saying same thing
90 Comments
Ministers now need to focus - really focus - on these KPIs. The PM, like any good CEO, will need to hold his Ministers to account. Ministers who persistently fail to meet their targets will need to be replaced. When the KPI flashes red, they won’t be able to hide behind the spin.
The next twelve months will define this government’s legacy. Delivering on these commitments won’t just look good on a spreadsheet. It could also help restore public confidence and show that, after years of drift, there is finally a plan that works.
Charles White-Thomson is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute.
Read Next
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy