OPINION
The Chancellor's tears were rational (Image: PA)
The Crying Game has always been part of British politics. Winston Churchill, our greatest national leader, was famously lachrymose whether in adversity or triumph, while the departures of Margaret Thatcher in 1990 and Theresa May in 2019 were both accompanied by reddened eyes and cracked voices. Less upset was Wiliam Gladstone who was disgusted by the “blubbering” of colleagues at his last Cabinet in March 1894. Earlier in the 19th century, Viscount Goderich acquired the nickname “The Blubberer” after he cried in front of King George IV on his dismissal as Prime Minister in 1828.
The first Labour Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald was a romantic Scot, whose public life was tragically blighted by the death of his wife in 1911. “He was in tears a lot of the time,” recalled his son Malcom. Another Scottish leader. Robert McClennan, who was in charge of the SDP in its final days, cried so regularly that, according to a colleague, there were “concerns about his mental stability”.
Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT
Dexcom G7 is proven to lower A1C and increase time in range3？？.Dexcom G7 shows your glucose in real time, so you can...Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall hides during PMQs after benefit U-turn humiliation
11 Comments
Rachel Reeves's sister shows her true colours moments after tears in PMQs
142 Comments
Keir Starmer blasted for ‘worst start by new PM ever' by polling guru John Curtice
34 Comments
Keir Starmer 'more likely than ever to quit as Prime Minister' following U-turns
137 Comments
I was in the Commons when Rachel Reeves cried and one thing stood out
273 Comments
Ed Miliband in the running to replace Rachel Reeves as chancellor - runners and riders
213 Comments
'Humiliated' Keir Starmer torn apart on GB News with crushing 'U-turn' verdict
53 Comments
This Sneaker’s Secret Cushion Will Change Your LifeWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Order Now
Undo
Piers Morgan has brutal response to Rachel Reeves 'crying' with nine-word question
22 Comments
Rachel Reeves allies 'reveal real reason for PMQs tears' - and one person's to blame
679 Comments
This Sneaker’s Secret Cushion Will Change Your LifeWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Order Now
Undo
The 1 clear sign Rachel Reeves was crumbling decoded by body language expert
52 Comments
POLL: Do you feel sorry for Rachel Reeves?
541 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Tory questions 'legality' of DWP PIP changes ahead of key decision
33 Comments
‘Government in crisis' as GB News star delivers damning verdict on emotional Commons
4 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall hides during PMQs after benefit U-turn humiliation
11 Comments
Compare Top Cloud Accounting Tools. #1 Pick May Surprise You. Research AI...2025's AI Accounting | Sponsored Sponsored
Click Here
Undo
Rachel Reeves's sister shows her true colours moments after tears in PMQs
142 Comments
Keir Starmer blasted for ‘worst start by new PM ever' by polling guru John Curtice
34 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Keir Starmer 'more likely than ever to quit as Prime Minister' following U-turns
137 Comments
I was in the Commons when Rachel Reeves cried and one thing stood out
273 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Ed Miliband in the running to replace Rachel Reeves as chancellor - runners and riders
213 Comments
'Humiliated' Keir Starmer torn apart on GB News with crushing 'U-turn' verdict
53 Comments
Piers Morgan has brutal response to Rachel Reeves 'crying' with nine-word question
22 Comments
Rachel Reeves allies 'reveal real reason for PMQs tears' - and one person's to blame
679 Comments
The 1 clear sign Rachel Reeves was crumbling decoded by body language expert
52 Comments
POLL: Do you feel sorry for Rachel Reeves?
541 Comments
Tory questions 'legality' of DWP PIP changes ahead of key decision
33 Comments
‘Government in crisis' as GB News star delivers damning verdict on emotional Commons
4 Comments
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Don't miss...
Rachel Reeves issues blunt four-word response to crying during PMQs [LATEST]
After Rachel Reeves's tears, here are 10 more politicians to famously cry [LATEST]
Similar anxieties were expressed during the Suez Crisis in 1956 when the Prime Minister Sir Anthony Eden broke down in a Cabinet meeting and wailed at his colleagues, “You are all deserting me.” Weeping uncontrollably, he fled to his upstairs flat in Downing Street. Within two months he had resigned as Prime Minister.
But none of this matches the raw emotion displayed in public by the Chancellor Rachel Reeves in the Commons on Wednesday. Sitting on the front bench during Prime Minister’s Questions, she was unable to hold back a stream of tears when Sir Keir Starmer – goaded by the Tory leader Kemi Badenoch – failed to express his full support for her. It was a remarkable scene that embodied the Government’s turmoil and bitterness over the humiliating collapse of their welfare policy.
Powered By
10 Sec
1
0
Just Treatment campaigners slam Labour's 10 year NHS plan
Next
Stay
Although Labour have stressed that the cause of her anguish was a “personal matter” rather than anything political, the Chancellor has been under immense pressure in recent days because of the ferocious internal opposition to welfare reform.
Sponsored
Pubyfun | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
This New AC Cooler Cools the Room In Seconds
Undo
Her determination to make cuts and shore up the Government’s fiscal position has reportedly led to angry confrontations with backbench MPs and Ministerial colleagues. She is also said to have been bruised by a clash with the Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, the darling of the left-wing activists.
Indeed, elements of the Labour left, sensing the weakness of Starmer and Reeves after this harrowing week, are on manoeuvres to precipitate a leadership crisis. It is astonishing how quickly the pair’s authority has been eroded. A year ago Labour came to power with a massive majority. But failing on every front, Starmer’s inept, divided and vacillating Government has seen the most dramatic plunge in popularity of any administration in history.
As Chancellor, Reeves has been a key architect of this catastrophe. Growth was meant to be her top priority but instead she has driven up taxes, debts, borrowing and unemployment.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall hides during PMQs after benefit U-turn humiliation
11 Comments
Rachel Reeves's sister shows her true colours moments after tears in PMQs
142 Comments
Keir Starmer blasted for ‘worst start by new PM ever' by polling guru John Curtice
34 Comments
Keir Starmer 'more likely than ever to quit as Prime Minister' following U-turns
137 Comments
I was in the Commons when Rachel Reeves cried and one thing stood out
273 Comments
Ed Miliband in the running to replace Rachel Reeves as chancellor - runners and riders
213 Comments
'Humiliated' Keir Starmer torn apart on GB News with crushing 'U-turn' verdict
53 Comments
This Sneaker’s Secret Cushion Will Change Your LifeWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Order Now
Undo
Piers Morgan has brutal response to Rachel Reeves 'crying' with nine-word question
22 Comments
Rachel Reeves allies 'reveal real reason for PMQs tears' - and one person's to blame
679 Comments
New Service Helps Seniors Get Brand New Windows (See If You Qualify)Home Window Prices | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
The 1 clear sign Rachel Reeves was crumbling decoded by body language expert
52 Comments
POLL: Do you feel sorry for Rachel Reeves?
541 Comments
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20 minutes before it happens. Dexcom | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Tory questions 'legality' of DWP PIP changes ahead of key decision
33 Comments
‘Government in crisis' as GB News star delivers damning verdict on emotional Commons
4 Comments
High Speed Internet for Seniors at low rates worth switchingHigh-Speed Wi-Fi Internet Deal | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
Nevada Seniors Get Brand New Windows (See If You Qualify)Home Window Prices | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
This Sneaker’s Secret Cushion Will Change Your LifeWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Order Now
Undo
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
Shoe CEO Drops Business Sneakers Taking The NFL By Storm Wolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Shop Now
Undo
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall hides during PMQs after benefit U-turn humiliation
11 Comments
Transform Your Space with Local Home BuilderHome Builder | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Rachel Reeves's sister shows her true colours moments after tears in PMQs
142 Comments
Keir Starmer blasted for ‘worst start by new PM ever' by polling guru John Curtice
34 Comments
The Business Sneaker Loved by CEOs and NFL StarsWolf & Shepherd | Sponsored Sponsored
Shop Now
Undo
Keir Starmer 'more likely than ever to quit as Prime Minister' following U-turns
137 Comments
I was in the Commons when Rachel Reeves cried and one thing stood out
273 Comments
High Speed Internet for Seniors at low rates worth switchingHigh-Speed Wi-Fi Internet Deal | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Ed Miliband in the running to replace Rachel Reeves as chancellor - runners and riders
213 Comments
'Humiliated' Keir Starmer torn apart on GB News with crushing 'U-turn' verdict
53 Comments
Piers Morgan has brutal response to Rachel Reeves 'crying' with nine-word question
22 Comments
Rachel Reeves allies 'reveal real reason for PMQs tears' - and one person's to blame
679 Comments
The 1 clear sign Rachel Reeves was crumbling decoded by body language expert
52 Comments
POLL: Do you feel sorry for Rachel Reeves?
541 Comments
Tory questions 'legality' of DWP PIP changes ahead of key decision
33 Comments
‘Government in crisis' as GB News star delivers damning verdict on emotional Commons
4 Comments
Starmer sidekick torn to shreds in car crash interview after Labour climbdown
6 Comments
Ed Balls issues devastating verdict on Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves
49 Comments
Starmer branded 'puppet of the Left' over welfare U-turn after Rachel Reeves meltdown
11 Comments
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle issues blunt 2-word statement on Rachel Reeves crying rumour
146 Comments
Rachel Reeves starts crying at PMQs as Keir Starmer refuses to say if she can keep her job
896 Comments
Keir Starmer refuses to say Rachel Reeves will keep job as Chancellor
23 Comments
Keir Starmer's welfare cuts narrowly pass as 49 furious MPs stage rebellion
482 Comments
Shoe CEO Drops Business Sneakers Taking The...Wolf & Shepherd
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Nevada Seniors Get Brand New Windows (See I...Home Window Prices
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
New Service Helps Seniors Get New WindowsHome Window Prices
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
This CGM can alert you of low glucose 20...Dexcom
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
The fiasco over welfare reform is another vital element in this catalogue of failure. “This Government must not and will not duck big challenges,” declared Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall. But that is exactly what Labour Ministers have done. The Government had no stomach for the fight, offering so many concessions that the Welfare Reform Bill became utterly pointless.
Shaken by discord, the Labour Party has cocooned itself in its traditional socialist comfort zone, where no awkward questions are asked about the dependency culture or the destruction of personal responsibility. But this sentimentality is a travesty of reality. In truth the lax system is ruthlessly exploited by the workshy, just as the definitions of disability have been so widened as to encompass drug addiction and even alcoholism.
The Chancellor’s tears for fears were rational. She knows that the black hole now left in the public finances will have to be filled by higher taxes, dragging Labour deeper into the mire of unpopularity. At the same time, the party will be gripped by more chaos and division, especially when Starmer’s weak leadership comes under threat from Rayner. If she gains the crown, that really will be a real cause for weeping.