The Home Office has admitted exercising an unlawful and secret policy of seizing mobile phones from all migrants crossing the English Channel.
Lawyers representing the home secretary made the admission at the High Court on Thursday, while fighting legal action brought by three asylum seekers.
The men, from Iraq and Iran, were all arrested on arrival in the UK despite committing no crime, and were stripped of their possessions.
British authorities kept their mobile phones for several months, leaving them unable to contact their loved ones, as one of the men feared his wife and seven-year-old daughter had been killed.
The claimants are asking the High Court to make declarations of “serious illegality”, award damages and require the Home Office to alert everyone affected by the unlawful policy.
Recommended Home Office triggered unlawful prosecutions by hunting down asylum seekers who steered Channel boats Court of Appeal finds Channel boat crossings by asylum seekers not illegal as convictions quashed Home Office loses case over stripping citizenship without notice after challenge by alleged Isis member
Their lawyers estimate that hundreds or thousands of mobile phones may have been unlawfully seized dating back to 2018.
The Home Office denied the policy existed in initial correspondence with the claimants' lawyers, and apologised for failing a “duty of candour”.
Alan Payne QC, representing the Home Office, told the High Court: “The home secretary is accepting that the seizure policies were unlawful, were not in accordance with the law for the purpose of the European Convention on Human Rights andi did not provide a lawful basis for the processing of data.”
Mr Payne said a version of a mobile phone policy that has been scrapped was unlawful because it was “blanket and unpublished”.
He also admitted that a separate policy to keep asylum seekers' phones for a minimum of three months was a “disproportionate interference” with human rights, and that the complete extraction of data from every phone violated the Data Protection Act.
The Home Office also admits that a practice where asylum seekers were ordered to hand over their PIN numbers to allow immigration officers to access their phones was unlawful, as were the data protection impact assessments done at the time.
Lawyers for the claimants argued that the concessions were “manifestly incomplete and inadequate to reflect the extent of the illegality”, but the home secretary’s team argued that the remaining grounds of legal challenge were “academic” and should be dismissed.
？
Record Year Sees More Than 28 300 People Cross Channel To Uk
The court heard that the “blanket seizure policy” operated at the Tug Haven reception unit in Dover between April and November 2020.
Home Office lawyers said its “precise origins are not known” and the policy “appears to have developed organically”.
Sir James Eadie QC, representing the home secretary, said there was a “misunderstanding permeating that an illegal entry offence was always committed by passengers” on small boats at the time.
In December, the Court of Appeal ruled that crossing the Channel with the aim of being intercepted and claiming asylum did not amount to illegal entry, and that a “legal heresy” had developed among authorities and caused a series of wrongful prosecutions.
Lord Justice Edis, who heard both that case and the current challenge, said material received subsequently suggests “the origin of the error was actually in the Home Office and its agencies”.
In July 2020, the Home Office changed the policy to retain seized phones for a minimum of three months because there was a “lack of infrastructure” to process them as small boat crossings rose.
A backlog developed and in October 2020, Border Force started a “bulk returns process” - but the three claimants’ phones were not returned until legal action was threatened.
Their lawyers said that during one period, the Home Office told asylum seekers to call a phone number to arrange the return of their property or their phones would be destroyed.
But “calls to that phone number were not answered”, and it was replaced by an email that did not result in responses for months.
An Iranian asylum seeker, known as HM, was wrongly told that he had entered the UK illegally after he was intercepted on a small boat on 2 September 2020.
UK news in pictures Show all 50
1/50UK news in pictures
UK news in pictures 27 January 2022 A rare six-week-old southern white rhino calf called Zawadi, explores her paddock for the first time at Africa Alive! in Lowestoft
PA
UK news in pictures 26 January 2022 British Prime Minister Boris Johnson jogs with his dog Dilyn, in London
REUTERS
UK news in pictures 25 January 2022 A member of staff looks at Francis Bacon’s work ‘Second Version of Triptych 1944’ on display in the Francis Bacon: Man and Beast exhibition at the the Royal Academy of Arts in London
PA
UK news in pictures 24 January 2022 Rowers (front to back) Charlotte Irving, Kat Cordiner and Abby Johnston, on their way to shatter the world record for rowing across the Atlantic
PA
UK news in pictures 23 January 2022 A grey seal pup on the beach at Horsey Gap in Norfolk, as the pupping season draws to a close at one of the UK’s most important sites for the mammals
PA
UK news in pictures 22 January 2022 Participants prepare to take part in the Crisis icebreaker cold water challenge at Tooting Bec Lido in London
EPA
UK news in pictures 21 January 2022 Willesborough Windmill, a white smock mill built in 1869 is bathed in the morning sunshine as the moon sets behind in Ashford, Kent
PA
UK news in pictures 20 January 2022 A jet skier jumps the waves off the coast at Blyth in Northumberland
PA
UK news in pictures 19 January 2022 Britain’s Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, participate in a therapy session with individuals who have experienced the care system, during a visit to the Foundling Museum in London
REUTERS
UK news in pictures 18 January 2022 Surfers enter the sea as the sun rises over Tynemouth on the North East coast
PA
UK news in pictures 17 January 2022 Bonhams’ Danny McIlwraith holds a Nigerian polycrome carved wood mask during a photocall for the sale of the Jim Lennon Collection at Bonhams in Edinburgh
PA
UK news in pictures 16 January 2022 The moon rises above the Spinnaker Tower in Portsmouth, Hampshire
PA
UK news in pictures 15 January 2022 Demonstrators outside Downing Street during a ‘Kill The Bill’ protest against The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill in London
PA
UK news in pictures 14 January 2022 Ecologist Emma Smart (left) and retired GP Dr Diana Warner outside HMP Bronzefield, in Surrey, following their release from the prison where Emma undertook a 26-day hunger strike during her incarceration. Ms Smart was sentenced in November, along with other members of Insulate Britain, to serve four months for breaking a High Court injunction by taking part in a blockade at junction 25 of the M25 motorway during the morning rush hour on 8 October last year
PA
UK news in pictures 13 January 2022 A TV presenter holds a copy of a newspaper outside 10 Downing Streetafter the Prime Minister apologised for attending a gathering of colleagues in the Number Ten garden in May 2020, while the UK was in strict lockdown due to the Coronavirus pandemic
Getty
UK news in pictures 12 January 2022 Fitness guru Derrick Evans after receiving an MBE during an investiture ceremony at Windsor Castle
PA
UK news in pictures 11 January 2022 A couple walk underneath an umbrella during wet weather on Westminster Bridge in central London
PA
UK news in pictures 10 January 2022 A jogger passes the Covid Memorial Wall in London
AP
UK news in pictures 9 January 2021 The sun rises over horses at Seaton Sluice in Northumberland
PA
UK news in pictures 8 January 2022 Riders compete during the Veterans Men's race at the UK Cyclo-Cross National Championships 2022 in Ardingly, south of London
AFP/Getty
UK news in pictures 7 January 2022 A dog looks out of a car window at the wintry conditions in Killeshin, Co. Laois
PA
UK news in pictures 6 January 2022 People walk through frost and mist alongside a frozen lake during sunrise in Bushy Park, London
REUTERS
UK news in pictures 5 January 2022 A skier jumps on the slopes at Allenheads in the Pennines to the north of Weardale in Northumberland
PA
UK news in pictures 4 January 2022 Freshly-fallen snow covers houses in Corbridge, near Hexham in Northumberland
PA
UK news in pictures 3 January 2022 Dean Morrison, 13, receives his Covid-19 vaccine from student nurse Anthony McLaughlin during a vaccination clinic at the Glasgow Central Mosque
PA
UK news in pictures 2 January 2022 Konastantinos Tsimikas of Liverpool with Chelsea’s Mason Mount during the Premier League match at Stamfrod Bridge
Liverpool FC/Getty
UK news in pictures 1 January 2022 New Year’s Eve Lasers, drones and fireworks illuminate the sky in front of the Royal Naval College in Greenwich shortly after midnight in London
EPA
UK news in pictures 31 December 2021 Competitors in fancy dress run across the Pennine tops near Haworth, West Yorkshire, in the annual Auld Lang Syne Fell race which attracts hundreds of runners every year
PA
UK news in pictures 30 December 2021 Sunrise at Bamburgh Castle in Northumberland
PA
UK news in pictures 29 December 2021 The Very Revd Dr Robert Willis, Dean of Canterbury Cathedral, looks at Becket, a six month old red-billed chough as he visits Wildwood Wildlife Park in Kent on the anniversary of the murder of Thomas Becket
PA
UK news in pictures 28 December 2021 Troops of the Household Cavalry are seen reflected in a puddle during the changing of the Queen’s Life Guard, on Horse Guards Parade, in central London
PA
UK news in pictures 27 December 2021 A pedestrian walks past a winter sale sign outside a John Lewis store on Oxford street in London
Getty
UK news in pictures 26 December 2021 Riders take their bikes through the snow near Castleside, County Durham
PA
UK news in pictures 25 December 2021 Patrick Corkery wears a santa hat and beard as waves crash over him at Forty Foot near Dublin during a Christmas Day dip
PA
UK news in pictures 24 December 2021 People stand inside Kings Cross Station on Christmas Eve in London
Reuters
UK news in pictures 23 December 2021 Christmas shoppers fill the car park at Fosse Shopping Park in Leicester
PA
UK news in pictures 22 December 2021 The sun rises behind the stones as people gather for the winter solstice at Stonehenge.
Getty
UK news in pictures 21 December 2021 People take part in a winter solstice swim at Portobello Beach in Edinburgh to mark the solstice and to witness the dawn after the longest night of the year
PA
UK news in pictures 20 December 2021 An auction employee displays poultry to buyers and sellers attending the Christmas Poultry Sale at York Auction Centre in Murton
PA
UK news in pictures 19 December 2021 Joao Moutinho of Wolverhampton Wanderers looks on during the Premier League match between Wolverhampton Wanderers and Chelsea at Molineux
Getty Images
UK news in pictures 18 December 2021 Freight lorries queuing at the port of Dover in Kent
PA
UK news in pictures 17 December 2021 Newly elected Liberal Democrat MP Helen Morgan, bursts 'Boris' bubble' held by colleague Tim Farron, as she celebrates following her victory in the North Shropshire by-election
PA
UK news in pictures 16 December 2021 Brussels sprouts are harvested by workers as they prepare for the busy Christmas period near Boston in Lincolnshire
PA
UK news in pictures 15 December 2021 Lewis Hamilton is made a Knight Bachelor by the Prince of Wales at Windsor Castle
PA
UK news in pictures 14 December 2021 The Royal Liver Buildings surrounded by early morning fog in Liverpool
PA
UK news in pictures 13 December 2021 People queue outside a walk-in Covid-19 vaccination centre at St Thomas's Hospital in Westminster
Getty Images
UK news in pictures 12 December 2021 People take part in the Big Leeds Santa Dash in Roundhay Park, Leeds
PA
UK news in pictures 11 December 2021 People arrive at a Covid-19 vaccination centre at Elland Road in Leeds,
PA
UK news in pictures 10 December 2021 Stella Moris speaks to the media after the US Government won its High Court bid to overturn a judge’s decision not to extradite WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange
PA
UK news in pictures 9 December 2021 Camels are lead around Salisbury Cathedral during a rehearsal for the Christmas Eve Service
PA
He was told to remove his shoes, jacket, wedding ring and watch, hand over his bag, empty his pockets and searched.
HM was never charged with an offence but his phone was not given back for over three months, while his wedding ring and other possessions have not been returned.
The court heard that he spent months not knowing if his wife and seven-year old daughter were alive because of the phone seizure, fearing that they had been killed.
He has since been identified as a potential victim of trafficking, the court heard.
The second claimant, an Iraqi asylum seeker known as MA, was picked up by Border Force in the Channel on 8 May 2020.
He was also arrested, searched and had his phone and possessions seized.
MA was told he had to provide his PIN number and complied, and was not given the phone back for 10 months.
The third claimant, an Iraqi asylum seeker known as KH, was intercepted in a small boat on 25 April 2020 and had his mobile phone seized without explanation.
Data from MA and KH’s phones was extracted, analysed, shared and stored, but HM’s phone was not used.
Mr Payne said “nearly every aspect” of the mobile phone policy had changed, and that currently phones were not being seized from small boat passengers who are classed as witnesses or victims of smuggling.
The home secretary’s lawyers maintain that seizures can still be legal under a clause that enables searches for items that “can be used to assist an escape from lawful custody and/or as a weapon”.
Mr Payne asked judges to consider “fairness” for the staff who operated the illegal policy.
“What is being challenged is operational decisions taken under huge pressure in response to an evolving emergency,” Mr Payne said.
“These decisions and steps were taken by dedicated people who aren’t lawyers, doing the very best they could to deal with an incredibly difficult situation
Recommended Solution for tackling migrant crossings ‘not at sea’, MPs told Home Office loses case over stripping citizenship without notice Home Office refuses to equip immigration officers with bodycams despite IOPC advice
“No one had time to sit down and look at material and write a 67-page thesis on the Data Protection Act and have that benefit of hindsight to unpick decisions.”
The case, before Lord Justice Edis and Mr Justice Lane, continues.