Campaigners said taxpayers would be fed-up to know that a cheaper alternative could have been used. (Image: Getty)
Billions of pounds of taxpayers cash could have been saved had the government not ignored an alternative to the HS2 high speed rail scheme, campaigners have said.
The plan from High Speed UK (HSUK) would have lopped an estimated ￡20 billion off the bill.
Earlier this year Rishi Sunak axed the Birmingham to Manchester leg of the scheme and promised to use the ￡36 billion of savings to fund hundreds of other transport schemes.
The Prime Minister said he was ending the HS2 saga because the project’s costs had “more than doubled”.
Powered By
00:00/01:11
10
10
Matt Hancock mistakenly commiserates death of alive politician
Share
Next
Stay
Building the rail link between London and Birmingham is expected to cost a staggering ￡70 billion.
The HSUK plan included building new lines, upgrading existing ones and restoring abandoned ones across Britain.
But it was ignored nine years ago after being presented to the House of Lords Economic Affairs committee.
Don't miss... Penny Mordaunt takes hilarious swipe at David Cameron in brutal speech
A similar plan was given the green light instead.
At the time HSUK, whose railway engineers Quentin Macdonald and Colin Hoff have a combined 80 years of experience, claimed their plan would have a capital cost of ￡40 billion compared to HS2’s ￡60 billion.
The ￡60 billion figure spiralled to around ￡100 billion until the Prime Minister stepped in.
They told the committee their plan would have saved 600 million tonnes of CO2 and avoided the Chilterns AONB.
Campaigners said taxpayers would be fed-up to know that a cheaper alternative could have been used.
John O’Connell, chief executive of the TaxPayers’ Alliance, said: “Taxpayers will be tearing their hair out at this missed opportunity.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
The ￡157bn web of railway lines that will connect six countries but keeps getting delayed
6 Comments
It's time for the Tories to scrap the hated inheritance tax, says Dame Priti Patel
34 Comments
Brazen EU makes plans to work with Switzerland while Bern strikes deal with UK
2136 Comments
Rail fares in England hiked by up to 4.9 per cent for millions of commuters
8 Comments
Rishi Sunak plans to axe inheritance tax in huge giveaway before 2024 election
842 Comments
'Worst year ever' for tourism predicted in 2024 as locals become fed up with visitors
13 Comments
'Skewed priorities!' - Humza Yousaf under fire as SNP blows ￡83,000 on American 'embassy'
490 Comments
London mayor Sadiq Khan hit by ￡6.5m blow to ULEZ as drivers challenge fines
33 Comments
Britain tourism bounces back post-pandemic
2 Comments
Inheritance tax changes could be in Spring Budget as thousands hit by rising costs
15 Comments
British cheese producers furious as Canada lets post-Brexit trade agreement expire
337 Comments
Tories looking at how to fire slacking civil servants more easily and get more in offices
260 Comments
Global financial warning as US economy heading for 'biggest single crash of our lifetimes'
9 Comments
Huge tax rule change to hit ‘millions' of eBay, Etsy, and Vinted users in days
20 Comments
Sunak plan to scrap inheritance tax is a naked electoral bribe - would you vote for it?
144 Comments
POLL: What do you think should happen to inheritance tax?
Comments
Jeremy Hunt confirms date of the next Budget, as reports emerge of major tax giveaway
383 Comments
Princess Charlotte's incredible net worth as she beats George to richest royal grandchild
4 Comments
Jeremy Hunt considering major tax changes to rescue Tory election hopes
175 Comments
'Ludicrous!' Fury as funds meant for north of England to be used to fix potholes in London
65 Comments
The ￡157bn web of railway lines that will connect six countries but keeps getting delayed
6 Comments
It's time for the Tories to scrap the hated inheritance tax, says Dame Priti Patel
34 Comments
Brazen EU makes plans to work with Switzerland while Bern strikes deal with UK
2136 Comments
Rail fares in England hiked by up to 4.9 per cent for millions of commuters
8 Comments
Rishi Sunak plans to axe inheritance tax in huge giveaway before 2024 election
842 Comments
'Worst year ever' for tourism predicted in 2024 as locals become fed up with visitors
13 Comments
'Skewed priorities!' - Humza Yousaf under fire as SNP blows ￡83,000 on American 'embassy'
490 Comments
London mayor Sadiq Khan hit by ￡6.5m blow to ULEZ as drivers challenge fines
33 Comments
Britain tourism bounces back post-pandemic
2 Comments
Inheritance tax changes could be in Spring Budget as thousands hit by rising costs
15 Comments
British cheese producers furious as Canada lets post-Brexit trade agreement expire
337 Comments
Tories looking at how to fire slacking civil servants more easily and get more in offices
260 Comments
Global financial warning as US economy heading for 'biggest single crash of our lifetimes'
9 Comments
Huge tax rule change to hit ‘millions' of eBay, Etsy, and Vinted users in days
20 Comments
Sunak plan to scrap inheritance tax is a naked electoral bribe - would you vote for it?
144 Comments
POLL: What do you think should happen to inheritance tax?
Comments
Jeremy Hunt confirms date of the next Budget, as reports emerge of major tax giveaway
383 Comments
Princess Charlotte's incredible net worth as she beats George to richest royal grandchild
4 Comments
Jeremy Hunt considering major tax changes to rescue Tory election hopes
175 Comments
'Ludicrous!' Fury as funds meant for north of England to be used to fix potholes in London
65 Comments
The ￡157bn web of railway lines that will connect six countries but keeps getting delayed
6 Comments
It's time for the Tories to scrap the hated inheritance tax, says Dame Priti Patel
34 Comments
Brazen EU makes plans to work with Switzerland while Bern strikes deal with UK
2136 Comments
Rail fares in England hiked by up to 4.9 per cent for millions of commuters
8 Comments
Rishi Sunak plans to axe inheritance tax in huge giveaway before 2024 election
842 Comments
'Worst year ever' for tourism predicted in 2024 as locals become fed up with visitors
13 Comments
'Skewed priorities!' - Humza Yousaf under fire as SNP blows ￡83,000 on American 'embassy'
490 Comments
Trending
“HSUK, like the TPA, was calling for a cheaper alternative to HS2 long before the white elephant hit the buffers, but were ignored while billions were wasted.
“Ministers have questions to answer about why they ignored calls for a wider connectivity plan that would have saved money and connected Great Britain.”
A government source said: “Taxpayers will be rightly frustrated that costs have gone up but the Prime Prime Minister has taken decisive action to end the ongoing saga and provide a clear and cost-effective plan for the future that will benefit more people in the north.”
Related articles Sunak facing ultimatum from Tory MPs to hand over HS2 cash before the election HS2 bosses deny multi-billion pound 'cover-up' after top secret files leaked 'Our pretty village has been ripped apart by builders who keep us up at night' David Cameron’s rebuke of Rishi Sunak just 41 days before political comeback Massive ￡8bn pledge to fix potholes barely scratches the surface, say experts
Become an Express Premium member Support fearless journalism Read The Daily Express online, advert free Get super-fast page loading
Start 30-day
FREE trial