South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham drew widespread criticism for opening his questions to US Supreme Court justice nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson by asking about her faith, including whether she can “fairly judge a Catholic” and requesting her to rate the importance of her faith “on a scale of one to 10”.
His remarks, which often cut of Judge Jackson from responding, appeared to suggest that conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who was nominated to the high court by Donald Trump, was unfairly treated by his political opponents during her confirmation hearings.
“What faith are you, by the way?” he asked. “Could you fairly judge a Catholic? … I’m just asking this question because – how important is your faith to you?”
“Senator, personally, my faith is very important, but as you know, there’s no religious test in the Constitution,” Judge Jackson responded.
He continued to interrupt her responses while the senator asked more probing questions, including whether she attends church regularly and “on a scale of one to 10, how faithful would you say you are, in terms of religion?”
Recommended GOP senators air grievances of nominations past on first day of questions for Ketanji Brown Jackson Ketanji Brown Jackson pushes back on Ted Cruz when asked if she believes ‘babies are racist’ Lindsey Graham mocked for storming off after ranting at Ketanji Brown Jackson
“How would you feel if somebody up here on our side said, ‘You know, you attend too much church for me, or your faith is a little bit different to me’, and they would suggest that it would affect your decision?” Senator Graham added. “The reason I ask these questions is, I have no doubt that your faith is important to you and you can adjudicate these cases fairly if you were an atheist.”
New York congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, sharing footage of the interaction on Twitter, added “when you’re far more qualified than the person determining your qualifications”.
Following his questions on the second day of confirmation hearings in the Senate Judiciary Committee, Senator Graham appeared to abruptly leave after raging against prominent liberal groups that have supported Judge Jackson over Michelle Childs, another judge who was in consideration for the nomination. She has been nominated to fill the District of Columbia Circuit Court seat that Judge Jackson will vacate if confirmed to the Supreme Court.
Senator Graham claimed “a lot of people from the left” sought to “destroy” Judge Childs and asked whether Judge Jackson was aware of a “concerted effort to disqualify” her.
“All I can say is the fact that so many of these left-wing radical groups, that would destroy the law as we know it, declared war on Michelle Childs and supported you is problematic for me,” he said.
Critics mocked Senator Graham over his response.
Scott Dworkin tweeted: “Lindsey Graham threw a tantrum and walked out of Judge Jackson’s Supreme Court hearing, because FAKE DRAMA”.
Recommended White House slams Hawley for ‘QAnon’ questions of Ketanji Brown Jackson - live White House calls Hawley questioning of Ketanji Brown Jackson ‘QAnon-signaling smear’ Judge Jackson grilled on Guantanamo detainee representation
Mr Graham’s opponent in the 2020 election, Democratic National Committee chair Jamie Harrison, also joined in the criticism.
“I’m so embarrassed for SC for the immature high school dramatic theatrics that we continue to see in Supreme Court hearings.”