Sign up for the daily Inside Washington email for exclusive US coverage and analysis sent to your inbox Get our free Inside Washington email
Please enter a valid email address
Please enter a valid email address
SIGN UP
I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy notice
Thanks for signing up to the
Inside Washington email
{{ #verifyErrors }} {{ message }} {{ /verifyErrors }} {{ ^verifyErrors }} Something went wrong. Please try again later {{ /verifyErrors }}
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court ruling in Texas that allows the state to ban emergency abortions, saying the current federal statute in the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) does not preempt the state law that outlaws the procedure.
In a ruling on Tuesday, the conservative-majority appeals court said the US Department of Human Health Services (HHS) erred in their interpretation of the EMTALA when the agency issued guidance in May 2023 to all hospitals participating in Medicare.
The decision is a blow to abortion rights activists in Texas who have been fighting to expand abortion access in the state.
The HHS’s guidance told hospitals they were “obligated under EMTALA to offer stabilizing care to patients who need emergency care” and that the federal statute overrode any anti-abortion state laws that did not include exceptions that met EMTALA’s emergency medical condition definition.
However, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton challenged the guidance saying no part of the law authorised the federal government to compel healthcare providers to perform abortions.
RECOMMENDED
Emma Watson clarifies what being ‘self-partnered’ means to her
Undo
Mother housebound with severe incontinence shares simple fix giving her life back
Undo
Combat Siege
If you have a mouse, play this game for 1 minute and see why everyone is addicted.Combat Siege| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
investing.com
Millionaire Laughs At Poor Family In Restaurant, Then Waitress Hands Him An Unbelievable Note On The Billinvesting.com| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Powered by Taboola Powered by Taboola
The Fifth Circuit agreed with Mr Paxton and the district court, adding, “EMTALA does not provide an unqualified right for the pregnant mother to abort her child”.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
" srcset="https://static.independent.co.uk/2024/01/03/16/SEI184958019.jpg?quality=75&width=320&auto=webp 320w, https://static.independent.co.uk/2024/01/03/16/SEI184958019.jpg?quality=75&width=640&auto=webp 640w" src="https://static.independent.co.uk/2024/01/03/16/SEI184958019.jpg" data-gallery-length="2" class="i-amphtml-fill-content i-amphtml-replaced-content">
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
(AP)
After the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade in 2022, Texas enacted a strict anti-abortion law that criminalises nearly all abortions before a fetal heartbeat is detectable except in some vaguely-described situations.
Promoted stories
opti
opti - the platform for the eye optics industryopti Learn More
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
However, due to the law’s unspecific nature, doctors have been unable to confidently provide the necessary care for pregnant patients who seemingly meet the law’s exceptions. Last month, Mr Paxton sent letters threatening legal action to hospitals where Kate Cox, a woman seeking a medically necessary abortion, could have obtained care.
The HHS’s guidance, issued shortly after the Supreme Court ruling, was an attempt to persuade states to allow for medically necessary abortions to continue in order to prevent death or health risks.
Under the 1986 law, EMTALA, hospitals that receive federal funding must treat or stabilise a patient regardless of their ability to pay or insurance status. However, the law does not explicitly mandate which medical treatments are necessary.
The Fifth Circuit said the HHS’s guidance “goes beyond EMTALA by mandating abortion.”
Rochelle Garza, the President of the Texas Civil Rights Project and current Democratic nominee for Texas Attorney General, called the ruling “deeply disturbing.”
“Hospitals and doctors should not have their hands tied when attempting to provide life-saving care for their patients. This cruelty, spearheaded by AG Paxton, puts women in life-threatening danger,” Ms Garza wrote on X.
More about Texas abortion Abortion right Ken Paxton
Join our commenting forum Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments
1/ 2Fifth Circuit allows Texas to deny emergency abortions
Fifth Circuit allows Texas to deny emergency abortions
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
AP
Fifth Circuit allows Texas to deny emergency abortions
A few abortion rights demonstrators remain in the crowd after hours of public comments and discussion as Dentona？？s city council meets to vote on a resolution seeking to make enforcing Texas
REUTERS
StreetInsider.com
They Found This Deep In The Ocean, It's Worrying ScientistsStreetInsider.com| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Eco Houses
Unsold Eco Houses (Take A Look)Eco Houses| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Luxurylevels.com
Nine years ago they were called the most beautiful twins in the world. Look at them nowLuxurylevels.com| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Investructor
Rosamund Pike, 44, Shows Off Her Perfect Figure In A New PhotoInvestructor| Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
？ Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Subscribe
Already subscribed? Log in