Labour's returns deal with the EU was slammed by the Tory bigwig (Image: Getty)
A Tory top dog has condemned the Labour Party’s alternative to the Government’s Rwanda plan and insisted it would lead to Britain “taking in more failed claimants than it removes”.
The scheme to deport refugees who make failed claims at asylum to Rwanda has been touted by PM Rishi Sunak as the “only way” to stop small boats making the dangerous journey across the Channel full of people looking to move to the UK, many of which are fleeing dangerous countries. But the controversial plan has been declared illegal by the UK’s highest court and faces widespread opposition from experts and politicians inside and outside of the Conservative Party.
Daniel Hannan, a Tory member of the House of Lords, conceded that the Rwanda plan was “expensive” and “cumbersome” - but claimed Labour’s alternative would only be worse. He said the Opposition’s “one concrete promise is a returns agreement with the EU which will result in Britain taking more failed claimants than it removes.”
READ MORE 'UK net migration is too high - we don’t have unlimited capacity'
Mr Hannan, writing for Conservative Home, added: “The figures here are telling. The last year that we had such a deal was as an EU member in 2020. That year, according to official figures, we tried to return 8,502 failed claimants to EU states, but they accepted only 105. They, by contrast, sought to send 2,331 failed claimants here, and we accepted 882.”
Powered By
00:00/00:50
10
10
Mark Francois says 'five families' can't back Rwanda bill
Share
Next
Stay
He said this was the “norm” when Britain was part of the bloc, adding: “No, talk of enhanced co-operation with Europe is as dishonest as talk of ‘breaking the gangs’. The only way to tackle the migration crisis is to make Britain a less attractive destination for people who have no right to enter.”
He suggested that the risk of being sent to Rwanda instead of staying in the UK is “bound to have a bearing on where you lodge your claim”.
Mr Hannan said: “They are choosing to leave a safe country, namely France. The prospect of swapping France, not for the UK, but for Rwanda, might well alter their calculations.”
But he also said there are severe drawbacks to the Rwanda plan. Mr Hannan wrote: “The drawbacks of the Rwanda plan are obvious. It is expensive. It is cumbersome. It will apply only to a minority of illegal entrants. It has taken up a huge amount of parliamentary time, and still has no certainty of success.
“There is, in any case, something distasteful about having to declare a foreign country safe by legislative fiat. There is, arguably, an aesthetic abjection to the whole notion of sending sans-papiers half way around the world.”
A Liberal Democrat-sponsored motion designed to block the bill was rejected in the Lords on Monday night, by 206 votes to 84, a majority of 122.
The draft legislation aims to contravene the supreme court’s finding that Rwanda was not a safe destination for asylum seekers due to the risk of them facing further persecution in the country.
Mr Hannan insisted Labour's plan would barely cut down on refugees being able to stay in the UK (Image: Getty)
Don't miss...
Italy gets Rwanda-style migration deal with Albania approved by top court [REVEAL]
Lee Anderson tears into ‘hypocrite’ Archbishop of Canterbury after Rwanda speech [INSIGHT]
Lord Ken Clarke warns UK hurtling towards 'elected dictatorship' [ANALYSIS]
Become an Express Premium member Support fearless journalism Read The Daily Express online, advert free Get super-fast page loading
Start 30-day
FREE trial
There will be further votes on amendments to the legislation next month, with votes on the bill having already provoked a Tory rebellion against Mr Sunak from Conservatives looking to make the Bill stronger.
Several members of the House of Lords gave impassioned speeches against the legislation, saying it would destroy the UK’s reputation on the world stage.
Crossbench constitutional expert Lord Hennessy said: “By rushing this emergency legislation through parliament with the intention of getting the deportation flights to Kigali under way by late spring, the government has already secured for itself a special place in British political history,” he said.
Trending
“The day may not be far off when the Rwanda bill, having cleared all of its parliamentary stages, will be forwarded from the Cabinet Office to Buckingham Palace to receive Royal Assent.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Peers threaten to derail Rishi Sunak's Rwanda bill, Tory MPs warn of opposition
570 Comments
'Gibraltar needs its own MP,' says Chief Minister as EU negotiations reach crucial stage
87 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into ‘hypocrite' Archbishop with demand he puts migrants in own Palace
317 Comments
Lords warned being 'too obstructive' on Rwanda will strengthen calls to abolish them
134 Comments
EU chaos as Viktor Orban lashes out at bloc's ‘blackmail' with MEPs 'under pressure'
24 Comments
The future of democracy depends on the House of Lords respecting the Rwanda bill
40 Comments
Lee Anderson claims he was offered ￡400k to quit Tory Party for Reform UK
156 Comments
Unhappy with Brexit? Blame the ardent Remainers who delayed out exit says, MARK FRANCOIS
315 Comments
Charles Michel makes humiliating U-turn to save EU from Viktor Orban takeover
335 Comments
Fed-up Tories ditching party for Reform UK with members growing sick of 'abhorrent' spats
244 Comments
Rishi Sunak vows to defy European judges over Rwanda despite bitter judge's warning
1299 Comments
Why Simon Clarke's botched leadership coup to oust Rishi Sunak failed
54 Comments
Europhile Donald Tusk accused of 'putting democracy and freedom in danger' in Poland
4 Comments
Lord Cameron urges Lords to back Rwanda asylum plan
29 Comments
Lord Ken Clarke warns UK hurtling towards 'elected dictatorship' in angry migration rant
391 Comments
Nigel Farage slaps down Archbishop of Canterbury over attack on Rwanda Bill
187 Comments
Brussels' extreme punishment will help drive Hungary out of the EU
65 Comments
Italy gets Rwanda-style migration deal with Albania approved by top court
24 Comments
House of Lords 'protecting democracy from itself' as it refuses to ratify Rwanda plans
232 Comments
Archbishop of Canterbury told 'hand-wringing' will not stop the boats
138 Comments
Peers threaten to derail Rishi Sunak's Rwanda bill, Tory MPs warn of opposition
570 Comments
'Gibraltar needs its own MP,' says Chief Minister as EU negotiations reach crucial stage
87 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into ‘hypocrite' Archbishop with demand he puts migrants in own Palace
317 Comments
Lords warned being 'too obstructive' on Rwanda will strengthen calls to abolish them
134 Comments
EU chaos as Viktor Orban lashes out at bloc's ‘blackmail' with MEPs 'under pressure'
24 Comments
The future of democracy depends on the House of Lords respecting the Rwanda bill
40 Comments
Lee Anderson claims he was offered ￡400k to quit Tory Party for Reform UK
156 Comments
Unhappy with Brexit? Blame the ardent Remainers who delayed out exit says, MARK FRANCOIS
315 Comments
Charles Michel makes humiliating U-turn to save EU from Viktor Orban takeover
335 Comments
Fed-up Tories ditching party for Reform UK with members growing sick of 'abhorrent' spats
244 Comments
Rishi Sunak vows to defy European judges over Rwanda despite bitter judge's warning
1299 Comments
Why Simon Clarke's botched leadership coup to oust Rishi Sunak failed
54 Comments
Europhile Donald Tusk accused of 'putting democracy and freedom in danger' in Poland
4 Comments
Lord Cameron urges Lords to back Rwanda asylum plan
29 Comments
Lord Ken Clarke warns UK hurtling towards 'elected dictatorship' in angry migration rant
391 Comments
Nigel Farage slaps down Archbishop of Canterbury over attack on Rwanda Bill
187 Comments
Brussels' extreme punishment will help drive Hungary out of the EU
65 Comments
Italy gets Rwanda-style migration deal with Albania approved by top court
24 Comments
House of Lords 'protecting democracy from itself' as it refuses to ratify Rwanda plans
232 Comments
Archbishop of Canterbury told 'hand-wringing' will not stop the boats
138 Comments
Peers threaten to derail Rishi Sunak's Rwanda bill, Tory MPs warn of opposition
570 Comments
'Gibraltar needs its own MP,' says Chief Minister as EU negotiations reach crucial stage
87 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into ‘hypocrite' Archbishop with demand he puts migrants in own Palace
317 Comments
Lords warned being 'too obstructive' on Rwanda will strengthen calls to abolish them
134 Comments
EU chaos as Viktor Orban lashes out at bloc's ‘blackmail' with MEPs 'under pressure'
24 Comments
The future of democracy depends on the House of Lords respecting the Rwanda bill
40 Comments
Lee Anderson claims he was offered ￡400k to quit Tory Party for Reform UK
156 Comments
“In the few minutes it takes to pass down the Mall and across the tip of St James’s Park and its return journey to Whitehall, our country will change, for the government will have removed us from the list of rule-of-law nations.”
While former Home Secretary Ken Clarke, who has supported previous Rwanda laws, said Sunak’s bill was a “step too far”, adding: “I don’t think I can possibly support this bill unless it is substantially amended as it goes through this House, and we should urge the Commons to revise it.”
Express.co.uk has contacted the Labour Party for comment.
Related articles Tories urge PM to tackle 'unsustainable' legal migration ahead of election Parliament could abolish House of Lords if Rwanda scheme wrecked Labour is simply not equipped to put forward any kind of viable plan Lee Anderson claims he was offered ￡400k to quit Tory Party for Reform UK Peers threaten to derail Rishi Sunak's Rwanda bill, Tory MPs warn of opposition