Keir Starmer malfunctioned over immigration (Image: Getty)

       I’ve just emerged from No. 10 Downing Street after sitting through my second major immigration press conference of the day.

       First up this morning was Nigel Farage, who was typically keen to leap on this morning’s damning figures to clobber the Tories’ record.

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       Stuttering Keir Starmer 'out of his depth' as This Morning interview mocked by viewers

       67 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition

       607 Comments

       Reform UK win key by-election as Nigel Farage celebrates: 'Something is happening'

       1652 Comments

       I was in the room for Kemi Badenoch's first big Westminster speech as Tory leader

       29 Comments

       Nigel Farage ‘delighted' as Reform announces big job for mega rich ex-Tory donor

       272 Comments

       Iain Duncan Smith blasts 'astonishingly stupid' Starmer for 'naive' China diplomacy move

       44 Comments

       PMQs LIVE: Angela Rayner faces Commons wrath as she steps in for Keir Starmer

       328 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't be worried about petition demanding General Election now

       1305 Comments

       Keir Starmer is the class clown plunging Britain into sixth-form politics

       42 Comments

       Keir Starmer battered by new storm as petition exposes public anger over Labour 'lies'

       50 Comments

       UK election map shows every seat Reform would win if bombshell petition succeeds

       778 Comments

       Andrea Jenkyns joins Nigel Farage's Reform UK in devastating blow for Tories

       773 Comments

       Nigel Farage accuses Keir Starmer of major U-turn as he's so worried about Reform

       113 Comments

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       Stuttering Keir Starmer 'out of his depth' as This Morning interview mocked by viewers

       67 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition

       607 Comments

       Reform UK win key by-election as Nigel Farage celebrates: 'Something is happening'

       1652 Comments

       I was in the room for Kemi Badenoch's first big Westminster speech as Tory leader

       29 Comments

       Nigel Farage ‘delighted' as Reform announces big job for mega rich ex-Tory donor

       272 Comments

       Iain Duncan Smith blasts 'astonishingly stupid' Starmer for 'naive' China diplomacy move

       44 Comments

       PMQs LIVE: Angela Rayner faces Commons wrath as she steps in for Keir Starmer

       328 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't be worried about petition demanding General Election now

       1305 Comments

       Keir Starmer is the class clown plunging Britain into sixth-form politics

       42 Comments

       Keir Starmer battered by new storm as petition exposes public anger over Labour 'lies'

       50 Comments

       UK election map shows every seat Reform would win if bombshell petition succeeds

       778 Comments

       Andrea Jenkyns joins Nigel Farage's Reform UK in devastating blow for Tories

       773 Comments

       Nigel Farage accuses Keir Starmer of major U-turn as he's so worried about Reform

       113 Comments

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       The second was Keir Starmer, who made a rare forward-attacking speech on the topic of immigration - certainly not the typical battleground you find a Labour leader waging war on.

       His reason was obvious: this morning’s figures are shocking, and yet could he be certain that voters will rightly blame the Tories given they have come out while Labour is in power.

       Within the first couple of minutes of his speech, I had already counted at least four direct attacks on both the previous Conservative government’s record, and the current party leadership.

       READ MORE: Keir Starmer blames Brexit for net migration chaos as new figures revealed

       ?????? Keir Starmer just malfunctioned when asked a basic question about immigration. @christiancalgie reacts to the Prime Minister's press conference on today's migrant numbers. #Immigration #KeirStarmer @Expresspolitics pic.twitter.com/UvNpYfWN8Y

       — Daily Express (@Daily_Express) November 28, 2024

       For once I actually felt Keir Starmer came across quite commanding on the issue of what has gone wrong over the past few years.

       He accused Rishi Sunak, Liz Truss and Boris Johnson of presiding over an experiment in “open borders”, attacking their “chorus of excuses”, and saying his opponents owe voters an explanation.

       He joked that you “have to double take” when seeing the reality of just how out-of-control Britain’s immigration system had become, blasting their legacy as “unforgivable”.

       Some of this was straight from the Faragist populist playbook, and to give credit to Keir Starmer, it was a convincing display of indignation.

       However, much like having to put up with Pepsi in a restaurant when you really wanted a classic Coke, if voters want to hear a convincing plan for the future, they’ll be much more satisfied listening to Nigel Farage than Keir Starmer.

       The PM was much weaker on his plan to bring immigration down in the future, promising a policy white paper early next year but refusing to set out what he may do.

       Don't miss...

       Migration fury as critics warn Keir Starmer huge numbers 'make us poorer' [LATEST]

       New migrant figures show more than one million entered Britain in single year [POLITICS]

       Nigel Farage accuses Keir Starmer of huge U-turn as he's so worried about Reform [NIGEL FARAGE]

       Voters will find Nigel Farage much more persuasive (Image: Getty)

       SUBSCRIBE Invalid email

       We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

       Crucially he also refused to put a number on what levels of immigration he would be happy with, and while I appreciate previous Tory pledges to have a cap were worth about as much as Neville Chamberlain’s ‘peace in our time’ document, voters nonetheless would appreciate a target by which to judge the PM’s success or failure.

       I thought the most illuminating moment was when he was asked not about economics, but about politics - whether he understands why voters are not just angry about jobs and wages, but about Britain’s changing culture.

       At this point Sir Keir gave one of the worst responses by a PM to a simple question I’ve heard in many years.

       It was like someone had poured a bucket of cold water over a robot, he simply malfunctioned. One could almost hear his internal processor shouting: “Error, error, error”.

       Trending

       He insisted it’s an issue of economics, burbling on and on about ensuring British workers have the skills they need.

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       Stuttering Keir Starmer 'out of his depth' as This Morning interview mocked by viewers

       67 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition

       607 Comments

       Reform UK win key by-election as Nigel Farage celebrates: 'Something is happening'

       1652 Comments

       I was in the room for Kemi Badenoch's first big Westminster speech as Tory leader

       29 Comments

       Nigel Farage ‘delighted' as Reform announces big job for mega rich ex-Tory donor

       272 Comments

       Iain Duncan Smith blasts 'astonishingly stupid' Starmer for 'naive' China diplomacy move

       44 Comments

       PMQs LIVE: Angela Rayner faces Commons wrath as she steps in for Keir Starmer

       328 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't be worried about petition demanding General Election now

       1305 Comments

       Keir Starmer is the class clown plunging Britain into sixth-form politics

       42 Comments

       Keir Starmer battered by new storm as petition exposes public anger over Labour 'lies'

       50 Comments

       UK election map shows every seat Reform would win if bombshell petition succeeds

       778 Comments

       Andrea Jenkyns joins Nigel Farage's Reform UK in devastating blow for Tories

       773 Comments

       Nigel Farage accuses Keir Starmer of major U-turn as he's so worried about Reform

       113 Comments

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       Stuttering Keir Starmer 'out of his depth' as This Morning interview mocked by viewers

       67 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't get away with shrugging off General Election Now petition

       607 Comments

       Reform UK win key by-election as Nigel Farage celebrates: 'Something is happening'

       1652 Comments

       I was in the room for Kemi Badenoch's first big Westminster speech as Tory leader

       29 Comments

       Nigel Farage ‘delighted' as Reform announces big job for mega rich ex-Tory donor

       272 Comments

       Iain Duncan Smith blasts 'astonishingly stupid' Starmer for 'naive' China diplomacy move

       44 Comments

       PMQs LIVE: Angela Rayner faces Commons wrath as she steps in for Keir Starmer

       328 Comments

       Why Keir Starmer won't be worried about petition demanding General Election now

       1305 Comments

       Keir Starmer is the class clown plunging Britain into sixth-form politics

       42 Comments

       Keir Starmer battered by new storm as petition exposes public anger over Labour 'lies'

       50 Comments

       UK election map shows every seat Reform would win if bombshell petition succeeds

       778 Comments

       Andrea Jenkyns joins Nigel Farage's Reform UK in devastating blow for Tories

       773 Comments

       Nigel Farage accuses Keir Starmer of major U-turn as he's so worried about Reform

       113 Comments

       Nadine Dorries predicts Boris Johnson will return as leader and 'knock Labour into orbit'

       464 Comments

       MAPPED: UK towns and cities where most voters want Keir Starmer to call a general election

       442 Comments

       New polling shows Kemi Badenoch's path to power

       94 Comments

       Labour civil war fears as Starmer urged to 'swallow pride' and ask for Nigel Farage's help

       176 Comments

       Nigel Farage sets out master plan for Reform as he eyes crunch election

       223 Comments

       Rachel Reeves refuses three times to explain CV economist claims in excruciating clip

       185 Comments

       New EU-UK 'reset' European bureaucrat will get paid ￡35k more than the Prime Minister

       374 Comments

       He banged on about this point for about 40 seconds, refusing to touch the question of British culture and identity with a barge pole, leaving those of us in the room bewildered.

       Nigel Farage gets this, and is much more comfortable talking about the watering down of Britishness than our metropolitan North London Prime Minister.

       Keir Starmer has done some homework, but he should continue revising from the Farage playbook if he wants to convince voters any time soon.