Sir Keir Starmer launching Labour's plans for British railways. (Image: Getty)
Taxpayers should not shoulder the cost of the “failed tactic” of nationalisation, Tory MPs have warned.
They said Sir Keir Starmer’s plans to take steel and rail into public ownership would impose the “burden of the industry’s uncompetitiveness” on Britons.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Keir Starmer's slapstick Cabinet show Labour still hasn't learned its lesson
328 Comments
Huge boost to African country handed ￡539m for trains and airports
8 Comments
Huge boost to three ￡87.1bn UK infrastructure projects set for a very big acceleration
22 Comments
Cruel Rachel Reeves takes winter fuel payment from her OWN elderly mother
531 Comments
Awkward moment for Keir Starmer as BBC Breakfast host asks: ‘Why are you so unpopular?'
896 Comments
Labour MPs, it's not too late to do the right thing and stand up for farmers
64 Comments
Labour is killing the economy and it hasn't even got started yet!
1320 Comments
Labour plan to renationalise British steel industry blasted as 'complete disgrace'
35 Comments
Labour to renationalise three UK rail firms in huge move - but not everyone is happy
100 Comments
Now Rachel Reeves shoots Starmer in foot as economic slump sinks Labour relaunch
649 Comments
Labour's nightmare budget raid cost the economy ￡10 billion and puts 125,000 jobs at risk
455 Comments
Transport Secretary refuses to commit to cheaper bills despite renationalisation
68 Comments
Rachel Reeves blasted over Brexit betrayal as she plots major 'reset' with EU
1727 Comments
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Keir Starmer's slapstick Cabinet show Labour still hasn't learned its lesson
328 Comments
Huge boost to African country handed ￡539m for trains and airports
8 Comments
Huge boost to three ￡87.1bn UK infrastructure projects set for a very big acceleration
22 Comments
Cruel Rachel Reeves takes winter fuel payment from her OWN elderly mother
531 Comments
Awkward moment for Keir Starmer as BBC Breakfast host asks: ‘Why are you so unpopular?'
896 Comments
Labour MPs, it's not too late to do the right thing and stand up for farmers
64 Comments
Labour is killing the economy and it hasn't even got started yet!
1320 Comments
Labour plan to renationalise British steel industry blasted as 'complete disgrace'
35 Comments
Labour to renationalise three UK rail firms in huge move - but not everyone is happy
100 Comments
Now Rachel Reeves shoots Starmer in foot as economic slump sinks Labour relaunch
649 Comments
Labour's nightmare budget raid cost the economy ￡10 billion and puts 125,000 jobs at risk
455 Comments
Transport Secretary refuses to commit to cheaper bills despite renationalisation
68 Comments
Rachel Reeves blasted over Brexit betrayal as she plots major 'reset' with EU
1727 Comments
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Mark Garnier MP said: “Nationalising British steel will not solve the industry's woes - just as nationalising the railways won’t lower fares or end delays. All nationalisation will do is put the financial burden of the industry’s uncompetitiveness on to taxpayers.
“Instead of heaping liabilities onto the public balance sheet, the government needs to address the structural problems the industry is facing.”
Ministers are considering renationalising British Steel in a last-ditch attempt to save thousands of jobs.
It comes amid a standoff between the government and the company’s Chinese owners over a ￡1 billion investment.
Harriett Baldwin MP said: “Those who don’t learn from history’s mistakes are doomed to repeat them. How many times does Labour have to make the same mistake to learn that nationalisation doesn’t work?
“Our steel industry is clearly in a difficult position and the government must take action to address the challenges it faces. But British taxpayers shouldn’t be made to shoulder the cost of the failed tactic of nationalisation.
READ MORE: The beautiful 164-mile train journey that's the most scenic in the UK
“Instead, the government should create a level playing field by pressing ahead with the conservative plan of a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).
This will ensure that poor-quality, high-carbon steel from China doesn’t flood the market and undercut British steelworks. It is unfair to expect our industry to play by the rules whilst China pollutes their way to success. It is time we created a free and fair market, underpinned by a CBAM, that would enable private steel firms to stand on their own two feet.”
A spokesperson for the Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds declined to rule out nationalising British Steel but said the government had “no plans” to do so.
They added: “We’re working across government in partnership with trade unions and businesses to secure a green steel transition that’s right for the workforce, represents a good investment for taxpayers and safeguards the future of the steel industry in Britain.”
Meanwhile, Labour announced last week that three more operators will be renationalised in 2025.
The Party’s first wave of rail renationalisation means that by the end of 2025, about four in 10 journeys on Britain’s trains will likely be on publicly-owned services.
At present, nearly a quarter of passenger journeys across the country are on services run by companies that are in public hands.
Trending
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander last week could not say what the cost of nationalising rail operators will be but said it would be “a fraction” of what is currently paid in management fees to train companies.
She said: “The primary aim of this is to improve reliability and clamp down on the delays, the cancellation, the waste and the inefficiency that we’ve seen over the last 30 years.
“We’ve had private train-operating companies running train services in this country over the last few decades, and it clearly hasn’t worked.”
DON'T MISS
Powered by
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Keir Starmer's slapstick Cabinet show Labour still hasn't learned its lesson
328 Comments
Huge boost to African country handed ￡539m for trains and airports
8 Comments
Huge boost to three ￡87.1bn UK infrastructure projects set for a very big acceleration
22 Comments
Cruel Rachel Reeves takes winter fuel payment from her OWN elderly mother
531 Comments
Awkward moment for Keir Starmer as BBC Breakfast host asks: ‘Why are you so unpopular?'
896 Comments
Labour MPs, it's not too late to do the right thing and stand up for farmers
64 Comments
Labour is killing the economy and it hasn't even got started yet!
1320 Comments
Labour plan to renationalise British steel industry blasted as 'complete disgrace'
35 Comments
Labour to renationalise three UK rail firms in huge move - but not everyone is happy
100 Comments
Now Rachel Reeves shoots Starmer in foot as economic slump sinks Labour relaunch
649 Comments
Labour's nightmare budget raid cost the economy ￡10 billion and puts 125,000 jobs at risk
455 Comments
Transport Secretary refuses to commit to cheaper bills despite renationalisation
68 Comments
Rachel Reeves blasted over Brexit betrayal as she plots major 'reset' with EU
1727 Comments
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Keir Starmer's slapstick Cabinet show Labour still hasn't learned its lesson
328 Comments
Huge boost to African country handed ￡539m for trains and airports
8 Comments
Huge boost to three ￡87.1bn UK infrastructure projects set for a very big acceleration
22 Comments
Cruel Rachel Reeves takes winter fuel payment from her OWN elderly mother
531 Comments
Awkward moment for Keir Starmer as BBC Breakfast host asks: ‘Why are you so unpopular?'
896 Comments
Labour MPs, it's not too late to do the right thing and stand up for farmers
64 Comments
Labour is killing the economy and it hasn't even got started yet!
1320 Comments
Labour plan to renationalise British steel industry blasted as 'complete disgrace'
35 Comments
Labour to renationalise three UK rail firms in huge move - but not everyone is happy
100 Comments
Now Rachel Reeves shoots Starmer in foot as economic slump sinks Labour relaunch
649 Comments
Labour's nightmare budget raid cost the economy ￡10 billion and puts 125,000 jobs at risk
455 Comments
Transport Secretary refuses to commit to cheaper bills despite renationalisation
68 Comments
Rachel Reeves blasted over Brexit betrayal as she plots major 'reset' with EU
1727 Comments
Kier - this is utterly ridiculous! Bin your pointless lists and do some governing
273 Comments
Rachel Reeves' dead hand economics and how she is digging a hole for herself
98 Comments
Keir Starmer ‘to seek foreign investment' for UK nuclear project
229 Comments
Fresh blow to Rachel Reeves as UK growth expectations take 'decisive turn for the worse'
165 Comments
The most helpful thing Labour can do for small businesses is to get out of their way
19 Comments
Pretty European village that looks like a fairytale will pay you ￡18,000 to relocate
Comments
This hidden Budget tax risk could devastate UK economy - it's another Rachel Reeves fiasco
497 Comments
Ms Baldwin said bringing the operators into public ownership was a “first step” to a “more integrated and unified railway”, and pointed to the impact of bringing LNER and Southeastern into public ownership.
“So if you look at LNER, for example, we have reduced the number of trains that are cancelled because of staff shortages to basically zero, and we reduced other cancellations to about 5%.
“Southeastern, which is also now in public ownership, is in the top five of train operators for punctuality.”