Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves (Image: PA)

       Rachel Reeves is facing fresh misery as the unfolding car loan mis-selling scandal threatens to blow a ￡5.5bn hole in the public finances, piling further pressure on the Chancellor as she struggles to balance Britain’s books.

       Treasury officials fear a wave of compensation payouts to drivers who were mis-sold car loans could permit major firms to legally slash their tax bills, depriving the Government of revenue.

       by Taboola by Taboola

       Sponsored Sponsored

       Promoted Links Promoted Links

       世上最好的7种「长寿药」，竟然都是免费的！知道你就赚大了…Rebang 360 了解更多

       Undo

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       Premium Bonds rate could fall again to this level as NS&I announces new cut

       1 Comments

       These six life-changing rules must be followed by anyone who wants to build wealth

       Comments

       HMRC issues ￡900 fines over tax return problem after interest cut

       Comments

       HMRC outcry as penalty tax trap squeezes enormous sums in interest payments

       13 Comments

       HMRC warning as 1.1m could be hit with ￡900 fine

       Comments

       Keir Starmer must act on this one huge injustice raiding British people's pockets

       23 Comments

       'Out of her depth!' Rachel Reeves blasted as inflation jumps to 10-month high

       121 Comments

       Rachel Reeves pressure builds as expert warns taxpayers after death tax receipts surge

       5 Comments

       Victory for drivers as Supreme Court rejects Reeves' intervention in car loan scandal

       14 Comments

       Hargreaves Lansdown urges anyone with savings to beat Rachel Reeves ‘Cash ISA raid'

       1 Comments

       Cash ISA update as Rachel Reeves breaks silence on '￡4,000 limit'

       103 Comments

       As Rachel Reeves targets our Cash ISAs - there's an even bigger threat and YOU'RE to blame

       48 Comments

       Treasury pockets ￡7bn inheritance tax but Rachel Reeves could be out for more

       2 Comments

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       Premium Bonds rate could fall again to this level as NS&I announces new cut

       1 Comments

       These six life-changing rules must be followed by anyone who wants to build wealth

       Comments

       HMRC issues ￡900 fines over tax return problem after interest cut

       Comments

       HMRC outcry as penalty tax trap squeezes enormous sums in interest payments

       13 Comments

       HMRC warning as 1.1m could be hit with ￡900 fine

       Comments

       Keir Starmer must act on this one huge injustice raiding British people's pockets

       23 Comments

       'Out of her depth!' Rachel Reeves blasted as inflation jumps to 10-month high

       121 Comments

       Rachel Reeves pressure builds as expert warns taxpayers after death tax receipts surge

       5 Comments

       Victory for drivers as Supreme Court rejects Reeves' intervention in car loan scandal

       14 Comments

       Hargreaves Lansdown urges anyone with savings to beat Rachel Reeves ‘Cash ISA raid'

       1 Comments

       Cash ISA update as Rachel Reeves breaks silence on '￡4,000 limit'

       103 Comments

       As Rachel Reeves targets our Cash ISAs - there's an even bigger threat and YOU'RE to blame

       48 Comments

       Treasury pockets ￡7bn inheritance tax but Rachel Reeves could be out for more

       2 Comments

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       Analysts at RBC Capital have estimated that as much as ￡5.5bn in corporation tax receipts could be lost to the Treasury as a result.

       Such a shortfall would make Ms Reeves’ task of balancing the books even tougher. The Chancellor has so far refused to rule out tax rises or spending cuts in March, hamstrung as she is by weak economic growth and soaring borrowing costs, which have eaten away at her financial headroom.

       The controversy deepened after the Supreme Court blocked Ms Reeves’s attempt to intervene in a high-stakes car finance case, which found that lenders had unlawfully paid commissions to dealers without customers’ knowledge.

       Sponsored

       Interactive Brokers Learn More

       Try the Options Wizard tool now!

       Undo

       by Taboola by Taboola

       READ MORE: Pensioners to get one-off ￡100 fuel payment after Reeves DWP cut

       Former Chancellor George Osborne (Image: Getty)

       If the Court ultimately upholds the Court of Appeal’s previous ruling, it could trigger the largest wave of mis-selling payouts.

       Under current tax rules, financial services firms, including insurers and asset managers, can treat compensation payments as deductible expenses for corporation tax purposes. This could result in a dramatic drop in tax receipts at a time when the Treasury can ill afford another fiscal shock.

       Former Chancellor George Osborne moved to prevent high street banks from writing off their PPI-related payouts against their tax bills in 2015 in a bid to stem the collapse in corporation tax revenues. The PPI scandal eventually cost lenders an estimated ￡50bn.

       The car finance market is much more complex, involving various institutions beyond traditional banks. While Mr Osborne’s restriction applied specifically to “banking companies,” which are typically defined as deposit-taking institutions, many high street lenders conduct their car finance businesses through subsidiaries which may not fall under the same rules.

       Lloyds Bank is thought to be one of the lenders most at risk (Image: Getty)

       Lloyds Bank, regarded as one of the most exposed institutions, runs its car finance operations through its Black Horse subsidiary. Other lenders range from major car manufacturers such as Volkswagen to smaller subprime finance firms, resulting in a legal grey area over how tax rules will apply.

       Wayne Gibbard, of law firm Shoosmiths, told the Telegraph: “There is quite a significant difference in structure if you look across the market. They all have such different models and their route to market is different.

       “Not everything is equivalent and frankly that’s why it’s taken so long to unpick because there isn’t just one model, there’s not just one commission, it’s not just one product. It’s quite a complex market.”

       Treasury officials reportedly believe that bank-owned car finance firms will be unable to offset their compensation payouts, but this still leaves a major loophole for non-bank lenders, which are responsible for most of the seven million outstanding car loan agreements.

       SUBSCRIBE Invalid email

       We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

       Don't miss...

       Farmers' kids write 'protest song' as Rachel Reeves tax raids hit hard [INSIGHT]

       Rachel Reeves in Labour civil war over whether to raise taxes or cut spending [ANALYSIS]

       Rachel Reeves in DWP war over plans for ￡5 billion in benefit cuts [PICTURES]

       Rachel Reeves and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (Image: Getty)

       RBC estimates that if the Court of Appeal’s ruling is upheld, the car finance industry could face a total compensation bill of ￡33bn, leading to a ￡5.5bn loss in corporation tax revenue. Even if the ruling is overturned, the Treasury could still face a hit of up to ￡3bn.

       The Treasury had argued before the Supreme Court that allowing tens of billions of pounds in compensation payments would damage Britain’s reputation as a business-friendly environment, warning of knock-on effects on economic growth.

       However, it did not highlight the potential fiscal impact; instead, it emphasised concerns that a flood of claims could restrict access to car finance, particularly for low-income families.

       Meanwhile, Lloyds Bank has increased its compensation provisions to over ￡1bn, warning that the potential payouts would be at “odds with 30 years of regulation.” The FTSE 100 bank has now set aside an additional ￡700m, on top of the ￡450m allocated last year, to cover the potential costs of compensation.

       Rachel Reeves with Renaud-Basso, president of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (Image: PA)

       Trending

       Charlie Nunn, Lloyds’s chief executive, described the new provision as a “best estimate” based on multiple scenarios, including legal rulings and regulatory decisions.

       DON'T MISS

       Powered by

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       Premium Bonds rate could fall again to this level as NS&I announces new cut

       1 Comments

       These six life-changing rules must be followed by anyone who wants to build wealth

       Comments

       HMRC issues ￡900 fines over tax return problem after interest cut

       Comments

       HMRC outcry as penalty tax trap squeezes enormous sums in interest payments

       13 Comments

       HMRC warning as 1.1m could be hit with ￡900 fine

       Comments

       Keir Starmer must act on this one huge injustice raiding British people's pockets

       23 Comments

       'Out of her depth!' Rachel Reeves blasted as inflation jumps to 10-month high

       121 Comments

       Rachel Reeves pressure builds as expert warns taxpayers after death tax receipts surge

       5 Comments

       Victory for drivers as Supreme Court rejects Reeves' intervention in car loan scandal

       14 Comments

       Hargreaves Lansdown urges anyone with savings to beat Rachel Reeves ‘Cash ISA raid'

       1 Comments

       Cash ISA update as Rachel Reeves breaks silence on '￡4,000 limit'

       103 Comments

       As Rachel Reeves targets our Cash ISAs - there's an even bigger threat and YOU'RE to blame

       48 Comments

       Treasury pockets ￡7bn inheritance tax but Rachel Reeves could be out for more

       2 Comments

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       Premium Bonds rate could fall again to this level as NS&I announces new cut

       1 Comments

       These six life-changing rules must be followed by anyone who wants to build wealth

       Comments

       HMRC issues ￡900 fines over tax return problem after interest cut

       Comments

       HMRC outcry as penalty tax trap squeezes enormous sums in interest payments

       13 Comments

       HMRC warning as 1.1m could be hit with ￡900 fine

       Comments

       Keir Starmer must act on this one huge injustice raiding British people's pockets

       23 Comments

       'Out of her depth!' Rachel Reeves blasted as inflation jumps to 10-month high

       121 Comments

       Rachel Reeves pressure builds as expert warns taxpayers after death tax receipts surge

       5 Comments

       Victory for drivers as Supreme Court rejects Reeves' intervention in car loan scandal

       14 Comments

       Hargreaves Lansdown urges anyone with savings to beat Rachel Reeves ‘Cash ISA raid'

       1 Comments

       Cash ISA update as Rachel Reeves breaks silence on '￡4,000 limit'

       103 Comments

       As Rachel Reeves targets our Cash ISAs - there's an even bigger threat and YOU'RE to blame

       48 Comments

       Treasury pockets ￡7bn inheritance tax but Rachel Reeves could be out for more

       2 Comments

       'Use it or lose it' ISA warning with weeks to deadline and rumoured Reeves raid

       4 Comments

       Nationwide issues warning amid fears of Rachel Reeves budget changes

       2 Comments

       NS&I hikes Cash ISA interest rate 'with immediate effect'

       1 Comments

       Rachel Reeves's plan to save economy is as credible as her CV - and we'll all pay

       94 Comments

       Rachel Reeves has told 12 rotten lies - and they're about to destroy her

       544 Comments

       Ofwat just proved that they hold water bill payers in contempt as judge slams watchdog

       12 Comments

       'Dire state of affairs': Expert's damning verdict on Rachel Reeves after 3% inflation blow

       48 Comments

       The Court of Appeal ruled last year that banks had mis-sold car loans by paying “hidden” commissions to dealers. A final Supreme Court decision on the matter is expected in April, determining the scale of the financial fallout.

       Lloyds had initially set aside ￡450m in response to an ongoing Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) investigation into discretionary commission arrangements, which have been under scrutiny for over a year. The FCA is waiting for the Supreme Court ruling before deciding on a potential redress scheme for affected borrowers.

       Express.co.uk has approached the HMT Treasury for comment.