Sir Keir Starmer and Albanian PM Edi Rama - who rejected the idea of return hubs in his country (Image: Getty)
Sir Keir Starmer's proposal to establish "return hubs" in countries like Kosovo for failed asylum seekers has come under intense criticism, with shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp labelling the plan as "laughable" amid a significant surge in illegal Channel crossings. The initiative aims to relocate individuals whose asylum applications have been rejected in the UK to third countries, such as Kosovo, for processing and eventual deportation.
The approach is intended to serve as a deterrent to illegal migration and to alleviate pressure on the UK's asylum system. However, the plan has been met with skepticism and opposition from various quarters. Referring to the aborted Rwanda scheme, Mr Philp criticised the proposal, saying: “Keir Starmer laughably claimed he would smash the gangs, but all he’s done is scrap our deterrent before it started - a deterrent the National Crime Agency labelled as critical."
Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT
Salma Hayek, 58, Shows Off Her Perfect Figure In These PhotosGanbiz | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
DON'T MISS
Powered by
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
Fury as Keir Starmer fails to vote to end migrant crisis - 'can't be bothered!'
414 Comments
GB News interrupted for tragic 'breaking news' announcement in blow to Keir Starmer
107 Comments
LBC's Nick Ferrari hysterical over Starmer's migrant plan: 'Forgotten the tents'
79 Comments
Pollster John Curtice issues devastating warning for Keir Starmer on U-turn
328 Comments
DWP Winter Fuel Payment U-turn update as Starmer holds talks
3 Comments
Floundering Keir Starmer humiliated as he can't put a cap on EU immigration numbers
97 Comments
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
52 Comments
Nevada Residents With Credit Card Debt Could Be In For a Big SurpriseTopDebtProgrmas | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Keir Starmer warned migrant return hubs plan 'doomed to fail'
518 Comments
Keir Starmer to beg nine countries to take migrants as Labour's immigration chaos continue
326 Comments
Lookup Anyone's Home Value Instantly by Address (Take a Look)QuestionHero | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Bumbling Bridget Phillipson in denial after Keir Starmer mocked over Albania trip
63 Comments
Migration bombshell as true number of Channel deportations revealed
399 Comments
Has Honda Done It Again? The New Honda CR-V is Finally Here.TheFactualist | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Migration mayhem as 800 migrants cross Channel today in border chaos
1031 Comments
Keir Starmer left red-faced as 'return hub' plan snubbed by Albania
20 Comments
Get Ozempic, Wegovy or Mounjaro at a low priceMedvi | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Tiny Device Reveals Why Japanese Rarely Need Assisted LivingUS Medicine Today | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Undo
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Doctors Speechless: Simple Trick For ED Works Lightning FastLifeHacks for Men | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
Type In Any Name, Wait 127 Seconds, See Instant ResultsFastest Search | Sponsored Sponsored
Search Now
Undo
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
Fury as Keir Starmer fails to vote to end migrant crisis - 'can't be bothered!'
414 Comments
A Potent Blend Of Organic Manuka Honey & Nourishing Oilstryblossom | Sponsored Sponsored
Shop Now
Undo
GB News interrupted for tragic 'breaking news' announcement in blow to Keir Starmer
107 Comments
LBC's Nick Ferrari hysterical over Starmer's migrant plan: 'Forgotten the tents'
79 Comments
Mature Singles, 50+ UsersInstantalks | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
Pollster John Curtice issues devastating warning for Keir Starmer on U-turn
328 Comments
DWP Winter Fuel Payment U-turn update as Starmer holds talks
3 Comments
I’m partnering with IFCJIFCJ | The Fellowship | Sponsored Sponsored
Donate Now
Undo
Floundering Keir Starmer humiliated as he can't put a cap on EU immigration numbers
97 Comments
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
52 Comments
Keir Starmer warned migrant return hubs plan 'doomed to fail'
518 Comments
Keir Starmer to beg nine countries to take migrants as Labour's immigration chaos continue
326 Comments
Bumbling Bridget Phillipson in denial after Keir Starmer mocked over Albania trip
63 Comments
Migration bombshell as true number of Channel deportations revealed
399 Comments
Migration mayhem as 800 migrants cross Channel today in border chaos
1031 Comments
Keir Starmer left red-faced as 'return hub' plan snubbed by Albania
20 Comments
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
READ MORE: Keir Starmer warned migrant return hubs plan 'doomed to fail' [INSIGHT]
Kosovo's Prime Minister Vjosa Osmani (Image: Getty)
He added: “As a result, since Labour took power over 37,000 illegal migrants have crossed the channel and 2025 so far has been the worst on record for illegal immigrants."
He further pointed out that Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama had made it clear there would be no UK return hubs in Albania during the PM's recent visit to the Balkan country.
Powered By
00:00/01:29
10 Sec
1K
1K
Celebrities Who Have Had Strange Pets
Next
Stay
He explained: “The Prime Minister’s attempt to get Albania to act as a return hub was humiliatingly dismissed by the Albanian Prime Minister.
Sponsored
Glucose Monitor | Sponsored Sponsored
Learn More
Pain-Free Glucose Monitoring Is Here! Seniors Are Ditching Finger Pricks for This
Undo
“Returns hubs will anyway not work as a deterrent because only illegal immigrants whose asylum claims fail get removed. The vast majority who illegally cross the channel have their asylum claims accepted, so would never be removed under the returns hub plan.
“Labour has only removed 5% of illegal immigrants crossing the channel since the election - no wonder illegal immigrants are flooding in under this failing Government.”
Don't miss...
Angela Rayner's one-word verdict on whether she'll replace Keir Starmer as PM [INSIGHT]
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level' [ANALYSIS]
'Speak plainly' Trevor Phillips skewers Angela Rayner in Sky News clash [PICTURES]
Migrants crossing the English Channel in a flimsy dinghy (Image: Getty)
SUBSCRIBE Invalid email
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy
The plan's viability has also been questioned due to the lack of formal agreements with potential host countries Kosovo's President Vjosa Osmani commenting: "There's been no formal talks with the UK on this issue. "It hasn't been raised so far. We would be open to discussing it, however, I can't say more than that because I don't know the details."
The proposal comes at a time when illegal Channel crossings have reached record levels. According to the BBC, the number of people crossing the Channel has passed 12,000 since January, putting 2025 on course to be a record year.
In response to recent criticism, Sir Keir defended the initiative, stating: "We are in talks with a number of countries about return hubs. I see them as a really important innovation."
He emphasised that the return hubs would focus on individuals who have exhausted all legal avenues in the UK and are currently in the country, costing millions of taxpayers.
Trending
Despite the Government's intentions, experts have raised concerns about the effectiveness and legality of the proposed return hubs.
Enver Solomon, the chief executive of the Refugee Council, warned: "Threatening to detain people in countries they've never set foot in causes fear and panic, leading to low rates of compliance. The government’s approach to returns must be based on evidence if it's going to work."
The Government’s approach contrasts with the previous Conservative administration’s Rwanda scheme, which involved sending migrants to have their asylum claims processed in the African country.
DON'T MISS
Powered by
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
Fury as Keir Starmer fails to vote to end migrant crisis - 'can't be bothered!'
414 Comments
GB News interrupted for tragic 'breaking news' announcement in blow to Keir Starmer
107 Comments
LBC's Nick Ferrari hysterical over Starmer's migrant plan: 'Forgotten the tents'
79 Comments
Pollster John Curtice issues devastating warning for Keir Starmer on U-turn
328 Comments
DWP Winter Fuel Payment U-turn update as Starmer holds talks
3 Comments
Floundering Keir Starmer humiliated as he can't put a cap on EU immigration numbers
97 Comments
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
52 Comments
Make Sure You're Alone Before Looking At These Dubai PhotosStars Are Made | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
Keir Starmer warned migrant return hubs plan 'doomed to fail'
518 Comments
Keir Starmer to beg nine countries to take migrants as Labour's immigration chaos continue
326 Comments
Check Your Credit Score for Free TodayIntuit Credit Karma | Sponsored Sponsored
Sign Up
Undo
Bumbling Bridget Phillipson in denial after Keir Starmer mocked over Albania trip
63 Comments
Migration bombshell as true number of Channel deportations revealed
399 Comments
Malia Reveals Her Boyfriend & You Will Easily Recognize HimOne Daily | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Migration mayhem as 800 migrants cross Channel today in border chaos
1031 Comments
Keir Starmer left red-faced as 'return hub' plan snubbed by Albania
20 Comments
Mature Dating Starts TodaySecretmeet | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Why More Seniors in Las Vegas Are Remodeling Their KitchensPearl Remodeling | Sponsored Sponsored
Read More
Undo
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Type In Any Name, Wait 120+ Seconds, See Instant ResultsFastest Search | Sponsored Sponsored
Search Now
Undo
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
21 Photos Accidentally Captured by Trail Cams.App Cute | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
Fury as Keir Starmer fails to vote to end migrant crisis - 'can't be bothered!'
414 Comments
10 Best Mattresses by Consumer Reports (Here's What You May Not Want to Miss)QuestionHero | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
GB News interrupted for tragic 'breaking news' announcement in blow to Keir Starmer
107 Comments
LBC's Nick Ferrari hysterical over Starmer's migrant plan: 'Forgotten the tents'
79 Comments
Here's The Estimated Cost for a 1-day Gutter Guards InstallationHomeBuddy | Sponsored Sponsored
Undo
Pollster John Curtice issues devastating warning for Keir Starmer on U-turn
328 Comments
DWP Winter Fuel Payment U-turn update as Starmer holds talks
3 Comments
Hydrator & Moisturizer Providing Fast, Long-Lasting Comforttryblossom | Sponsored Sponsored
Shop Now
Undo
Floundering Keir Starmer humiliated as he can't put a cap on EU immigration numbers
97 Comments
Keir Starmer's winter fuel 'panic' exposed as PM warned 'voters won't buy it'
52 Comments
Keir Starmer warned migrant return hubs plan 'doomed to fail'
518 Comments
Keir Starmer to beg nine countries to take migrants as Labour's immigration chaos continue
326 Comments
Bumbling Bridget Phillipson in denial after Keir Starmer mocked over Albania trip
63 Comments
Migration bombshell as true number of Channel deportations revealed
399 Comments
Migration mayhem as 800 migrants cross Channel today in border chaos
1031 Comments
Keir Starmer left red-faced as 'return hub' plan snubbed by Albania
20 Comments
The shocking number of migrants still moving to Britain revealed in major update
349 Comments
Lee Anderson tears into Keir Starmer over migrant figures - 'answer question'
234 Comments
Andrew Neil accuses Keir Starmer of 'gaslighting to a deplorable level'
157 Comments
Keir Starmer dealt humiliating blow on GB News: 'It's just theatre!'
57 Comments
Migration madness as Keir Starmer plots stealth 'free movement' deal
481 Comments
Keir Starmer in major U-turn to deport migrants to overseas countries
714 Comments
Keir Starmer told to make one demand at EU 'surrender summit' on Monday
15 Comments
3 Stocks That Could Rise 20-fold By 2029Oxford Club
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Grow Your Nest Egg In Las Vegas With High-APY SavingsNerdWallet
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Fabletics vs. Nike vs. Lululemon — We Tried All Three Brands And Found A WinnerPopdust For Fabletics Men
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Fabletics vs. Nike vs. Lululemon — Workout Gear Showdown Popdust For Fabletics Men
Undo
by Taboola by Taboola
Sponsored Links Sponsored Links
Promoted Links Promoted Links
Sir Keir's plan focuses on relocating failed asylum seekers to third countries for processing and eventual deportation, aiming to be more legally and ethically robust.
As the debate continues, the effectiveness of the proposed return hubs remains uncertain.
With illegal Channel crossings on the rise and formal agreements with potential host countries yet to be secured, the Government's plan faces significant challenges in its implementation.